Friday, September 10, 2010

FDR Memorial Boondoggle At Roosevelt Island's Southpoint Park Receives Puny $500 Thousand Dollars In Federal Funds Secured By Congresswoman Maloney

Update 9/13 - Image of View From Southpoint Park That Will Be Blocked By FDR Memorial Sculpture Room From the Main Street WIRE

Received a press release today from Congresswoman Carolyn Maloney's office announcing that she has secured $500,000 in federal funds for the FDR Memorial Boondoggle at Roosevelt Island's Southpoint Park.

Image of Proposed Roosevelt Island Four Freedoms Park FDR Memorial

At first, I was angry to learn that more taxpayer funds were going into this mausoleum that destroys beautiful panoramic East River waterfront and New York City Skyline views and replaces open green space with cement.

Image of FDR Memorial Sculpture Room (AKA Death Box) From Village Voice Runnin Scared Blog

Then I realized what a paltry sum from the Feds - $500,000, when you consider the $50 million or more total cost of the project, the $4 million in State funds, $4.5 million in City funds and even the $500,000 from the Manhattan Borough President committed to date - is not an overwhelming show of support for this ill conceived project which was described by art critic Thomas B. Hess when the design was first proposed in the 1970's this way:
... the sort of political edifice that the Italian fascists loved and Speer perfected for the glory of the Third Reich... The site itself is treated heartlessly. What was a modest, picturesquely rugged shoreline has been disciplined to straight lines and symetrical angles that have no significance beyond the alarming one of man's ability to impose a meaningless geometry on nature. The ultimate irony is that Roosevelt, who fought totalitarians to the death, is commemorated in the harsh style propogated by the dictators.
Southpoint Park Image From Time Out New York's Top Picnic Spots

Commenting on this horrible design for Southpoint Park, some Curbed readers remarked:

sighhhh

i will miss you unkept and overgrown southern tip

and
(one word) ... HORRIBLE!!!

FAREWELL NATURE!!! - We are relinquishing something that actually looked like the "tip of an island" that only needed minor grooming to keep it looking natural and beautiful. I visited the southern tip many times (seeing art installations, etc.) and enjoyed every visit because I really felt that I was on a remote island, and I could sit on the hill and have a casual picnic and watch the sky. NOW??? WTF??? This is a REAL TRAGEDY and PURE SHIT !!! As much as I hate to say it, I would have preferred a Trump Hotel on the site to this __???__ (something so disturbingly ugly that I am lost for words) .

LiqCity readers had this to say as well:
What an ugly park design.
and:
It looks like a concentration camp. Ugly ugly ugly.
If the intent of the FDR Memorial is truly to honor President Franklin Roosevelt and not the designer of the project Louis Kahn, it could have been accomplished with a simple statue of FDR sitting in a wheelchair or using crutches and look something like this bronze statue from EIS Studios.


The first granite delivery for the mausoleum room is expected on Monday. Will have more on all this next week.

Below is the press release from Ms. Maloney's office:
Congresswoman Carolyn Maloney (D-Manhattan & Queens) today announced that she had successfully secured $500,000 in this year’s federal budget to support the creation of Four Freedoms Park on the southern tip of Roosevelt Island.

“The Franklin D. Roosevelt Four Freedoms Park will be a world-class amenity and attraction for Roosevelt Islanders, New Yorkers, and visitors from around the globe, and I am proud to have spearheaded the successful effort to secure federal funds to support its creation,” said Congresswoman Maloney, who has represented Roosevelt Island in Congress since 1993.

“It is completely fitting that the federal government will be providing support for a park and statue of President Franklin Delano Roosevelt, the only memorial to one of our nation’s greatest leaders in the city that he and his wife Eleanor called home for so many years,” said Congresswoman Maloney.

“The Four Freedoms Park will be an extraordinary civic space honoring the president who led us through the Great Depression and the cataclysmic events of World War II,” she said.

Congresswoman Maloney led the effort to secure the appropriation in the U.S. House of Representatives. It was included in the Fiscal Year 2010 Transportation and Housing & Urban Development appropriations bill.

First envisioned in 1973 by the late Governor Nelson Rockefeller and the last project ever designed by the world-renowned architect Louis Kahn, the Franklin D. Roosevelt Four Freedoms Park will encompass 4.5 acres of open space on Roosevelt Island’s East River waterfront in the heart of New York City. It will include walkways lined with trees, a statue of the Franklin D. Roosevelt, and a granite monument symbolizing the “four freedoms” of the late President’s famous speech describing the four basic freedoms to which all persons enjoyed a right: freedom of speech and expression; freedom of religion; freedom from want; and freedom from fear.

The park’s construction is being managed by the Franklin D. Roosevelt Four Freedoms Park LLC, led by the Chair of its Board of Directors, William J. vanden Heuvel, and its President and Chief Executive Officer, Sally Minard.

UPDATE 9/13- Later this afternoon, New York State Governor David Paterson and New York City Mayor Michael Bloomberg will come to Roosevelt Island to welcome the arrival of the Granite Foundation Stones for the FDR Memorial Boondoggle. According to the event's invitation:
... 24 monolithic stones will be barged up the East River to the Park. The stones, 12" x 6" x 6", 36 tons each will be off-loaded by crane onto the site to form the foundation of what architect Louis B. Kahn called the "Room"...
Others call it the Death Room Mausoleum.


The Main Street WIRE photo at top of post is of the panoramic view of the East River Waterfront that will forever be lost once the granite "death room" is constructed.

Sad day for Roosevelt Island.

14 comments :

Anonymous said...

I've just begun my Senior year at Bronx High School of Science. I have always been intrigued by different landscapes and topography. When I first read the articles of the ownwer of this blog, I thought he may have had a point. So, this summer I took a survey of residents on our island. I asked folks waiting for the F Train what they thought. Out of the 500 people I asked, roughly 291 were in favor of the FDR Memorial Park being built. 132 people did not care either way, and 77 felt it should be left the way it was. Thus, the majority of folks polled, felt good about the new park, so I say majority rules. I have changed my mind, and am now looking forward to the new park. Maybe the owner of this blog can do the same.

~Just 1 person

Anonymous said...

I am with you, poster above. There have been polls and what not and every time it was split more or less in the middle with the pro-memorial party having the majority. The owner of this blog doesn't like the memorial and that's okay. I am very sure once it's built he'll have a change of heart.

I am not sure what all the complaints about 360 degree views is all about. You can get the same kind of view at Lighthouse Park just fine. Do we need both ends of the island to be like that? I'd say no.

Anonymous said...

I'm with both posters above. The owner of this blog is usually pretty good about reporting things down the middle (unlike the slanted WIRE), but for some reason, he has a bone with this park. It's going to be great for the island and we don't have to pay a dime for it. All the money is coming from outside sources. As a member of the Disabled Association I say, "It's about time that OUR island receives something nice without having to pay for it."

I say thank you to the FDR Memorial folks who are doing this for us. Now please let it go, Mr. O'Connor.

Anonymous said...

I'm with Rick O'Connor. This whole thing is a travesty. The president of the LLC building the Park is Sally Minard, a major contributor to Democratic candidates and chief fundraiser for Carolyn Maloney in her aborted primary challenge to Gillibrand for her Senate seat. It truly is the Kahn Memorial. Much of the money was donated by architechts, who insisted that Kahn's design be used. So, all of the meetings on the Island about the Park asking for our "input" were a total charade.

The appropriation was approved at least a few months ago; Maloney's press statement was timed to coincide with the primary and today's "gound breaking." Perhaps she also wanted to insure that there would be little opportunity to arrange an anti-park demonstration today. To add insult to injury, the construction contract was awarded without competitive bidding and went to a Long Island company. So much for Maloney using "stimulus money" to do something for her district.

Looking at the renderings of the Park on the official Park site is a weird experience. They bear little resemblance to the models. I assume this is because the Park folks want to make it seem as if the views won't be ruined.

In addition to the loss of the view, there are other issues. Today, someone (RIOC?) is providing transportation from the Island's subway station to the Park and gave driving instructions. Is it reasonable to assume that once the Park opens, visitors to it will park at Motorgate and ride the red buses down there? I think not. Instead, they will drive down there. Conveniently(?) Goldwater is going to be demolished in about 4 years. I suspect some of that land will end up being used to build parking lots/a garage for the Park. Of course, the same folks will tell us then that it's "necessary," as if the need for parking couldn't be foreseen.

Personally, I think the granite columns will be covered by cormorant guano almost immediately. Well, unless the sea gulls get there first.

Then there are the linden trees. I note that these are now "little leaf lindens." I know regular linden trees won't grow on the Island--the soil is too salty. Maybe these will; I don't know. I do know, though, that it's extremely unlikely all of them will grow in neat little rows. A lot of the cherry trees planted on the Island by the Sutton Place Association died; I think a conservative estimate will be that no more than 75% of the trees planted will grow. They certainly won't be neat little rows like the artists' rendering--not with the winds down at the Southern tip.

As it is, the southern tip of the Island is closed down whenever there is a major event at the UN. It's too much of a security risk to leave it open. I assume that the building of the "box" will increase the security risk and that the Park will continue to be shut down whenever there is a UN General Assembly. Ironic isn't it?

Anonymous said...

I love the bronze statue of FDR and his wife on the picture. How nice it would be to have similar bronze statue here, on Roosevelt Island...

Why did L. Kahn decide to chop trees and put ugly granite on Roosevelt Island? Why? Why? Why?

David Kraut said...

Might be some confusion here. Lewis Kahn's design didn't chop any trees. The whole area of the memorial is landfill, using material dug out of the water-tunnel project up by where Octagon is now and graded and shaped specifically for the future memorial. Before then, the Island ended just past the Smallpox Hospital.

After the hill was put in place RIOC, led by its Board of Directors, decided to offer the space to the public temporarily while waiting for the FERI people to get their act together.

One other point: there are actually two projects going on down there at the moment. One is South Point Park, which goes from the crossing road south of Goldwater Hospital to the Smallpox Hospital Ruin. That is essentially a RIOC project using funding from a combination of sources. The other is the Kahn memorial, funded by donations through the Franklin and Eleanor Roosevelt Institute.

Anonymous said...

Ηello my frienԁ! I wish to ѕay thаt thіs
artіclе iѕ amazіng, great ωrіttеn anԁ іnclude
аlmоst all sіgnifіcant іnfos.
ӏ'd like to peer more posts like this .

My website payday loans online

Anonymous said...

ӏt is the best tіme to make a few plans for the future and it's time to be happy. I'ѵe rеad this submіt and if I mау Ι ԁesiгe to counsel you few fascinating things
or suggestіons. Perhapѕ you сan write subsequеnt artіclеs regarԁing this article.
I desire to read eνen mοre things abοut іt!


My web site instant cash loans

Anonymous said...

Ӏ have been explοring for a bit for аny high
quаlity articlеs or blog posts іn this kinԁ of space
. Εxploring іn Yahoо І at
laѕt stumbleԁ uрon this webѕite.
Reаԁing this info So i'm happy to express that I've
а very јust right uncanny feeling І found out just
what I needed. I most indubitably will make certain to do not
overlooκ thiѕ web ѕite аnd provіdеs іt a loоk οn a continuіng basis.


Here іs my page payday loans

Anonymous said...

Ηаνе you evеr thought аbout adding a little
bit more than juѕt your articles? Ӏ mean, what you say іs funԁamental аnԁ аll.

But іmagine if you аddеd some great
graphics οr vіdeo clips to give youг posts moгe, "pop"!
Your cοntent іs excеllent but with pics anԁ vidеo сlіρs,
this blοg could definitelу bе one of the veгy beѕt in itѕ niche.
Very good blog!

Alѕo visit my ωeblog Payday Loans

Anonymous said...

Тhe verу next time I reaԁ a blog, I hope thаt
it does not fail me as much as thіs οne.
ӏ meаn, I know it was mу сhoісе to read, hοwevеr I actually belіeνed you'd have something interesting to say. All I hear is a bunch of moaning about something you could fix if you weren't too busy searсhing for attention.


Here is mу webpage :: Same Day Payday Loans

Anonymous said...

Mу bгothеr suggeѕted I might like this website.
He was totаlly right. Тhis pοst truly madе my daу.
Yοu cаnn't imagine just how much time I had spent for this information! Thanks!

Here is my web page :: same day payday loans

Anonymous said...

Ηі there to all, how is all, I think eѵеry оne is getting more from thіs website,
аnd your vieωs are nice deѕigned
foг nеw ѵiѕіtorѕ.



Mу blog payday loans

Anonymous said...

Hello matеs, іts fantastic post conсerning teachinganԁ fully dеfineԁ,
keеρ it up all the timе.

My web blog; small loans