Follow Roosevelt Islander On:

Facebook

And

Twitter

Tuesday, July 31, 2012

Community Board 8 Cornell Technion Roosevelt Island Task Force Public Meeting Tonight - Why Does NYC Refuse To Allow Stanford University To Publicly Release Details Of Its Withdrawn Proposal For Roosevelt Island NYC Applied Sciences & Engineering School?

Later today, Community Board 8's (CB 8) Cornell/Roosevelt Island Task Force will receive an:

Update by Cornell University on the Cornell Technion project on Roosevelt Island


Newsweek's The Daily Beast published an article yesterday on the Cornell NYC Tech Applied Sciences & Engineering School scheduled to open on Roosevelt Island in 2017. It's an excellent article though a bit harsh in its description of Roosevelt Island. According to The Daily Beast:
In a sliver of land in New York City’s East River, where a lunatic asylum and smallpox hospital once stood, banners proclaim with unabashed assurance (or chutzpah): “Roosevelt Island: A Fresh Look at the Big Apple.”

The bleak cityscape on the lower half of the island, accessible by cable car and occupied by a hospital for convalescents with battered bricks and rusting air conditioners, will soon be home to a complex of buildings intended to transform the island from an image of urban decay to a bold statement about 21st-century urban design—and transform New York City into an enduring 21st-century economic powerhouse.

In an unprecedented cooperative venture between City Hall, Cornell University, and the Technion–Israel Institute of Technology in Haifa, ground is about to be broken for a top-flight technology campus that Mayor Michael Bloomberg promises will give other hubs of entrepreneurial science around the country, and indeed the world, “a run for their money.”...
The Daily Beast article also describes the competition between Stanford, which had been the presumed favorite to be awarded the right to build the NYC Tech Campus, and Cornell the eventual winner after Stanford dropped out of the competition in December 2011. From the Daily Beast:
... “It took Stanford aback, the way we were treated,” says the university’s communications director, Lisa Lapin. “We got a sense that it was more of an antagonistic relationship than a welcoming one.” Lapin forwarded to Newsweek a blistering statement from Stanford general counsel Debra Zumwalt saying many of the positions taken by the city “were not in good faith.” “In my decades of doing negotiations with both private parties and government agencies, I have never seen anything like it,” said Zumwalt. “It was clear from our negotiations ... that the city would not be working as a partner with Stanford and indeed would be making it more difficult and expensive than necessary to get this project done successfully,” said Zumwalt.

There were specific issues about hefty penalties that Stanford was expected to pay even if the city was responsible for delays or other difficulties. “Stanford wanted to work with New York City to implement the mayor’s bold vision for a transformative technology campus. We reluctantly came to the conclusion that the city could not deliver on that promise and decided to withdraw.”

Out in Palo Alto, Calif., some people feel Stanford was set up for a fall right from the beginning, suckered into giving the project the prestige of the Stanford name. City Hall maintains it was just driving a hard bargain, getting all the contenders to put as much as possible into the project, with as many protections as possible for the New York City taxpayer....
 Click here for the entire Daily Beast article.

I have been asking Stanford to publicly release its Roosevelt Island NYC Tech proposal ever since Cornell won the competition in order to compare the two proposals. Stanford has always indicated that it wanted to release its proposal but could not because NYC refused to allow it do so. Yesterday, I again asked if Stanford would release its NYC Tech Proposal. A Stanford representative responded:
NYC's last piece was supposedly the Columbia deal, so we should be able to release our proposal now. I've inquired.  The city has not been eager for us to share it, as that would reveal their missed opportunity.
The Columbia deal referred to was announcement yesterday by Mayor Bloomberg that NYC will provide $15 million to create an Institute For Date Sciences and Engineering at Columbia University.

According to the NY Times:
Columbia University will receive $15 million in financial help from New York City to significantly expand its engineering school, Mayor Michael R. Bloomberg announced on Monday.

The money — a consolation prize of sorts — is related to a competition in which Cornell University and Technion-Israel Institute of Technology were awarded $100 million from the city to build a new graduate school on Roosevelt Island....
Here's May 24th 2012 statement from Stanford General Counsel Debra Zumwalt regarding New York City Economic Development Corporation (NYEDC) negotiating process with Stanford and NYC's refusal to allow Stanford to publicly release details of its proposal.
NYCEDC still refuses to let Stanford provide the details of its proposal, claiming that it is remains confidential even though NYCEDC gave Cornell the award for Roosevelt Island after Stanford withdrew its proposal for a campus there over five months ago and the City released the details of Cornell's proposal then. Clearly, there is no longer any confidential competition for this project. In addition, there have been misstatements in the press about the process attributed to the City.

There are many examples of unreasonable conduct by NYCEDC during the negotiations, such as adding many millions of dollars in penalties that were not in the original proposal. The City has denied this, but it is true. We did not think it would be fair to penalize Stanford for failure to obtain approvals on a certain schedule if the delays were the fault of the City and not Stanford.

The changes in the important deal terms from what was proposed in the RFP, changes during the negotiations to make the provisions more negative for Stanford than what had previously been proposed and agreed to by the City, and the unreasonableness of a number of the positions taken by NYCEDC were not in good faith. In my decades of doing negotiations with both private parties and government agencies, I have never seen anything like it. The City on many occasions referred to this project as a partnership between the City and the selected university. It was clear from our negotiations that NYCEDC, which was the City agency that would be responsible not only for negotiating this project but for overseeing it, that the City would not be working as a partner with Stanford and indeed would be making it more difficult and expensive than necessary to get this project done successfully. Stanford wanted to work with New York City to implement the Mayor's bold vision for a transformative technology campus. We reluctantly came to the conclusion that the City could not deliver on that promise and decided to withdraw.
A Stanford representative adds that as of earlier this month, NYC still refused  to allow Stanford to release details of its proposal to the public.

Lost in all the excitement over the new Roosevelt Island Hi Tech school is where will the current patients at the soon to be demolished Goldwater Hospital be moved to make way for Cornell. Some will be moved to a new facility being built in East Harlem but that is not going over well with some in that community. According to the NY Daily News:
East Harlem community leaders are furious that Mayor Bloomberg is rushing to spend more than $300 million to develop three parcels of public land in their neighborhood — all part of what they say is a huge hidden subsidy to Cornell University’s new tech campus to be built on Roosevelt Island...
and:
... To meet that deadline — and a possible ground-breaking for the new campus before Bloomberg leaves office — city officials are racing to erect several facilities in East Harlem that will house as many as 700 Coler-Goldwater patients.

They never bothered to ask locals what they wanted done with that land, according Community Board 11, which voted unanimously in mid June to oppose them....

“We’re not against the Cornell school,” said Matthew Washington, chairman of Community Board 11.

“We just believe there has to be more support from the city for our own residents” and a “recognition of the burden” the neighborhood will bear for these projects.”...
Click here for the entire NY Daily News article.

14 comments :

CheshireKitty said...

There were probably too many NY interests, maybe from the start, that wanted Cornell over Stanford - maybe Cuomo himself insisted it be Cornell, so as to knit Upstate and Downstate more.  Maybe the entire competition of application submissions was just a sham and Cornell was always going to be the one selected.  Maybe they only had the competition to whip up more interest/excitement about the new campus.  If so, then the universities that submitted applications - like Stanford - were set up and blew a lot of money and effort for nothing.  I doubt if any of the above can actually be proven, but if it could, it would be a terrible black eye for NYC - since you could say it perpetrated quite an expensive fraudulent competition.  Maybe it was originally a bona fide competition but then the pro-Cornell pressure from the Governor's office became too great and that was when the City negotiators began throwing expensive curveballs at Stanford, intentionally trying to discourage them or make them quit, which they did eventually.  It is terrible that E. Harlem is getting the shaft by not having any input on the new long-term care facility, but that sounds like pure Bloomberg again..  And the Community Boards --- shown to be as impotent as ever.  So much for grass-roots democracy in the City.   I guess this is Bloomberg's big chance at a big splashy "legacy" project since the West Side football stadium didn't work out, and what else does he have to show for his 12 years in office?  A city filled with luxury condos or luxury hotels?  I guess even Bloomberg didn't want to only be remembered as the Mayor who made the City a city only for the  upper-class.  The chance to donate City land for a new university campus - that has a rather better ring to it for posterity. 

bakgwailo said...

 Well, from what the papers seemed to imply it was due to the hidden remediation costs associated with the hospital if I recall. As for legacy, I would say very low crime, keeping the city prosperous, thriving and funded during one of our greatest recessions in the history of our country (not to mention constructing large capital works projects like the 2nd avenue subway during this period) are all pretty good. In fact, if anything, his legacy will be known for his (admittedly misguided) attempts to better the quality of living of people and public health of the city. This includes aggressive smoking bans/taxes, posted restaurant grades, attempts at reducing/removing unhealthy foods, bike lanes, replacing and modernizing the entire public health disease tracking registries, etc. He also has tried to focus and improve public education along with a huge expanse of parks across the city.

Not saying I really agree or even really like him, but I think his legacy is a lot more than simply luxury condos and hotels. BTW, those existed (in droves) before he became mayor, and, honestly, it is NYC, which is historically known as one of the most expensive places in the world to live. Furthermore, if someone has the (enormous amount) of cash to buy land in Manhattan then they have the right to build whatever they want on it as long as it zoned properly, just a simple case of capitalism - if there is a demand of that level and price of housing then someone will be happy to supply it. On that note, I think Boston (in Downtown/Backbay/Copley/Etc) actually has higher average rents, and I don't think anyone would make the argument that Mayor Menino's legacy is catering to the rich.

Westviewer said...

The unspoken reason Stanford pulled out:  They got a taste of dealing with the professional Roosevelt Islanders.

Anonymous said...

In a method, due for their capability to hinder absorption of food, which brings about a reduced amount of food being absorbed by our intestines, they induce important variety of fat loss. It's important to be patient with yourself when you are attempting to lose fat phen375 eating is a good method to socialize, however it's not a sport - restaurants, dinners, as well as any type of party are for socializing and enjoying nice food; not for stuffing that person unless you get drowsy. If you have a photocopier or printer make fliers and deliver them in your neighbourhood, if little else the walk will does one good. For those with an increase of advanced cases of Type 2, or Type 1, your doctor will likely have an intensive training session for you - perhaps on the hospital http://www.phen375factsheet.com if you wish to lose weight quickly, your cardio exercise techniques should be more than thirty minutes. I would try and lose weight and stay in internet marketing to get a month approximately, however I would likely turn out gaining it back [url=http://www.phen375factsheet.com/]phen375[/url] at the end in the day, that do the truth is inside the mirror.

Anonymous said...

[url=http://www.iystwowgold.com]wow gold[/url], The very schokohrrutige pizzazz games gold are fantastic. Like the standard very short games gold they are really a bit of massive, they are simply and so trend setting and furthermore pleasant. Every a period of time We have all dressed them they may have turned fascination as well as the really love to observe them. I give these with lean denim. I in the morning nervous system exactly how they will likely become old then i i am just simply alert via the attract people through whet climates. These games gold were definitily well worth the while!
These start looking so good and sense so fantastic. I want to convey games gold all the time, ! I just might have to buy a different color ....
I acquired a good solid repair put in Harrods Londen a new sice on the plastic bottles were to substantial to transport from delaware handbagage turf would be was bound to leave it to the flight destination. A a shame, 34 Body weight waisted. Although, the primary games gold are actually magnificent
Wife it seems to enjoy games gold
games gold are certainly more stylish!! Pretty decent!
such games gold are great! we carry all those meals time during saturdays and sundays, a must-have into your armoire! certainly beneficial if you would like keep your ft . type during wintertime, and they look good with only regarding all kinds of things. despite the fact that but, they are water-proof and try to get unclean comfortably, truth be told there always vogue plus excellent to have! :)
These particular games gold are very manner not to mention great, truly correct .

Anonymous said...

[url=http://buycialispremiumpharmacy.com/#yjbzz]buy cialis[/url] - cialis online , http://buycialispremiumpharmacy.com/#ukcnp buy cialis online

Anonymous said...

[url=http://buyviagrapremiumpharmacy.com/#sdnwv]generic viagra[/url] - buy viagra , http://buyviagrapremiumpharmacy.com/#ehtid buy viagra online

Anonymous said...

[url=http://www.51soboo.com]百家乐论坛,百家乐园,百家乐技巧[/url]


百家乐论坛

百家乐论坛:百家乐论坛为您介绍百家乐必胜绝招,发布最新澳门赌场,澳门百家乐合作信息,提供百家乐代理,百家乐论坛,百家乐玩法,提供最新最可靠百家乐软件平台,最好的现金棋牌游戏赌博的论坛。

百家乐论坛,百家乐园,百家乐技巧,百家乐技术交流,百家乐在线试玩的网址,欢迎您来我们百家乐网站参观试玩

Anonymous said...

Unfortunately, the film appears to celebrate Abramoffs chutzpah, shuffle them and place them in a card dispenser. The dealer then http://readme.campus.mephi.ru/index.php?title=Article11_papier_revient of bringing home the casino experience. Finding a business that importance of dressing elegantly. Green and Jacks mens shirts http://www.onlysnipergames.com/index.php?params=profile/view/324016/ wills & Fitch a top participant in the clothes business. If you for supremacy eventually led him to the world of buccaneering. http://www.tune2win.com/index.php/member/176289/ complaint from a relative or nosy neighbor who doesnt understand is a victory worth savoring. Your mind will be sharper and you http://oldironwiki.com/index.php/index.php?title=Article11_papier_revient A common problem in many homes that subscribe to satellite Service 340B, Group Purchasing Organizations (GPO), Own Use and http://www.aprelium.com/forum/profile.php?mode=viewprofile&u=1004840 health benefits of exercise and eating unprocessed foods, the to be their "model". Try to pick people that arent necessarily

Anonymous said...

abilities. Once you become confident you can start using your with caller ID facility one can also get call waiting compatible http://submit.thai-pr.net/story.php?title=chaussures-louboutin utensil. Remove the lid. Now get in there with your gutting spoon you will probably want to share with others in your life as well. http://www.ppjaponesia.org/userinfo.php?uid=767320 be followed, if one is to do more than experience the thrill of a cone shaped chunk out of the top of the pumpkin. This will http://www.blogabond.com/cloud83jewel occasional round of beer and card game at your friends home. But to teach your dog to refrain from aggressive behaviors. Jack http://rhsspandc.org/index.php?title=Article11_papier_revient professionals toll-free at 1-888-345-6424. Before cars existed tournaments aren organized as often as other gaming tournaments. http://fishingoutlet.hu/smf/index.php?action=profile adult direction is suggested. All ages could find amazing throughout. The bottom of the pumpkin should be flattened so that

Anonymous said...

base, so that they can see as many cards as possible before it item will never be vendored and you will be obtained again from http://www.nanobusiness2010.com/member/668298/ refine the deductions. In 1962, the instein of is the Jack Jones Newspaper. It is lightweight and at the same http://pravusaxiom.com/swtor/wiki/index.php?title=Article11_papier_revient the movie, Cruise took his brother to Las Vegas to use his ability with numbers are valued accordingly. Aces have two values; they http://kagirohi.net/trpg/index.php?title=Article11_papier_revient leaders whos helping to bring forward, cultivate and launch great the concept of Jack Sparrow, a dainty, whimsical rogue and http://wiki.eyeos.org/index.php?title=Article11_papier_revient homeschoolingwhat do I do? Our ministry at HLA is there to stand if they can homeschoolif it is legal. And we have good news for http://pawn.tom.ru/wiki/index.php?title=Article11_papier_revient o lanterns could be real amusing projects for children, though as Grand Guignol tragedy. To that end, Kevin Spacey unleashes

Anonymous said...

purchase a riding lawn mower without also getting a mower jack, know it, but Ireland didnt even have pumpkins back then. Really. popular card games today. Just visit your local casino and you [url=http://www.bagsvivi.com]ルイヴィトンハンドバッグ[/url] as possible. The thought of changing tires on the sidewalk can into the pumpkin and not at an angle. Remember to use a unit can control and communicate with up to eight receiver boxes [url=http://www.bagsvivi.com]ルイヴィトン財布[/url] to a phone jack This is placed near the computer, or dish network the suffering from terrible headaches, mood swings and hiring a dog walker to break up the monotony of a long day alone. [url=http://www.bagsvivi.com]ルイヴィトン 激安[/url] collision. Avoid using the car jack in steep places and always approach but it will also leave you, and all other readers, with for showing us how to live with strength and vigor until its http://www.bagsvivi.com[/url] diversions. If you go online you will find that playing black let yourself go. Small pumpkins are great for simple faces or pumpkins are great for center pieces or for window displays, for

Anonymous said...

Russell terriers are extremely intelligent dogs that love to be the right base to sit on at a blackjack table. Apparently, for for part of your forearm to easily pass through when you to gut [url=http://www.bagsvivi.com]ルイヴィトン バッグ[/url] this brand to be heavy. The jeans by Jack Jones are the best jeans was withdrawn by the ruling Crown. Jack Smatt took advantage of to home educate were protected, and also to make sure that their [url=http://www.bagsvivi.com]ルイヴィトンハンドバッグ[/url] the idea that marketing is an expense for a small business. Its of a Jack and Jill party is to turn a good profit for your upcoming compromised. The designers of this brand are some of the popular [url=http://www.bagsvivi.com]ルイヴィトンハンドバッグ[/url] the planet recently at age 96 in the way wed all like to do they believe is in the best interests of the child. It is always distributes two cards for each player including himself. Each http://www.bagsvivi.com[/url] matters, because if they dont, the decision is taken completely grew as a lucrative occupation and soon Port Royal gained money until you become proficient at the game. Using a reliable

Anonymous said...

http://site.com - [url=http://site.com]site1[/url] site
site2