Showing posts with label Cherry Blossom Mess. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Cherry Blossom Mess. Show all posts

Sunday, March 30, 2025

RIOC Announces Preparations For Large Crowds Coming To Roosevelt Island For Cherry Blossom Season And Warmer Weather - Hosting Online Cherry Blossom Community Preparation Meeting Tuesday April 1, You're Invited To Give Feedback

The 2025 Roosevelt Island Cherry Blossom season has begun with trees blooming next to the Roosevelt Island bridge on the east side of Capobianco Field

but not yet in most other areas of Roosevelt Island. 

The blooming of the Roosevelt Island Cherry Blossoms will bring back the hordes of tourists to Roosevelt Island with long lines for the Tram and overcrowded cabins. During yesterday's beautiful warm afternoon weather, we got a small taste of the long Tram lines to come as shown in screenshots from the Roosevelt Island Operating Corp (RIOC) Manhattan Tram station livestream cameras.

According to RIOC:
Dear Roosevelt Island Community:

The warmer months always result in an uptick in visitor and pedestrian traffic to the island. With Cherry Blossom season fast approaching, the following controls have been activated and will remain in place through the end of April:

Overcrowding Safety Controls:

  • Large crowds on the island will be managed by PSD officers with the assistance of the 114th Precinct.
  • Parks will be monitored by PSD throughout the day. Please note that parks will close in the occurrence of overcrowding on the island.
  • Additional signage will be placed near the entrances and exits of the Tram on the Manhattan side to help ensure an orderly travel process.

Transportation & Island Services:

NOTE: Please plan your travel accordingly. While delays in Tram travel are to be expected due to increased ridership, the Ferry is a viable option; the F-Train remains a quick and efficient option for travelling to and from the island.

Subway: F train service will run on normal weekend hours. Please plan your travel accordingly and visit mta.info/weekender or call 511 for more information. For electronic updates on F Train service, sign up for MTA Alerts at mymtaalerts.com.

Q102 Bus: The Q102 is also available to help riders traveling on and off Roosevelt Island. You can check the Q102 schedule here. 

RIOC Weekend Mini-Shuttle Buses to Manhattan: RIOC’s Transportation Department will once again run a Mini-Shuttle Bus from Roosevelt Island to Manhattan on weekends during the month of April. Shuttles will run hourly (traffic permitting) from 11AM to 7:30PM. The shuttle will depart at the top of every hour from the Roosevelt Island Tramway. The shuttle will then depart on the half hour from the Manhattan Tram station, from the corner of 60th Street and Second Avenue to the Tram. The last shuttle trips will depart from the Roosevelt Island Tram at 7 PM and Manhattan at 7:30 PM.

Tram: PSD officers will be present at each station. Passengers should plan accordingly as they may experience long lines. Before traveling, make sure to check the Tram cams on the RIOC website to see up to the second conditions at the Manhattan station: https://rioc.ny.gov/673/Roosevelt-Island-Tram-Station-Livestream

Ferry Service: Ferry service will run on normal weekend service hours. For schedule info, visit: Ferry.nyc

Vehicular Traffic: In the event of overcrowding, vehicular access to the island will be restricted to island residents and workers only. PSD and NYPD will be stationed at the entryway of the bridge (Vernon and 36th Ave.) to monitor and redirect, if needed.

Bicycles: Citations will be issued to any cyclist/motorized scooters who do not adhere to NYC bike laws.

Garbage Removal: There will be an increase in waste management this weekend to address any littering caused by overcrowding.

For more information, please call PSD at 212-832-4545.

A Long Time Roosevelt Island resident shares this message to RIOC Director of Communications and Community Affairs Bryant Daniels:

Is that Mini-Shuttle you refer to that same, awful, not completely barrier-free & accessible vehicle that looks like a truck? If it is, it is not usable for a variety of folks with physical challenges ... Why can’t RIOC use one of the Red Buses, especially now with 2 new buses (and the rest in pretty good condition). They are safe, barrier-free and accessible....

Mr Daniels replied:

Thanks for the feedback. Yes, it’s the shorter bus—taking a 40-footer off-island right now is a bad move. Maintaining Red Bus service on the island has to be the priority, and the amount of people who utilize this shuttle generally doesn’t exceed what the shorter bus can accommodate.

The shorter bus is also much easier to navigate for our drivers on Queens and Manhattan roads, and with the roadwork going on just off the island, that’s an important consideration, too.

I also think, generally speaking, we need to be thoughtful about not repeating history with the Red Buses. That’s a lot of extra wear and tear going off-island, just when we got our fleet back into shape.

Two of the buses are also about to have mid-life overhauls which will take them out of commission for a few weeks each.

RIOC adds:

Dear Roosevelt Island Community:

Following the release of our 2025 Island Travel Advisory, RIOC will be hosting a special online community meeting to discuss preparations for the upcoming Cherry Blossom season on the island. This online meeting will be held next Tuesday, April 1st at 6pm via Teams.

The meeting will include a discussion about operational adjustments made to help accommodate for the added foot-traffic to the island during the busy spring season, and will offer residents an opportunity to provide feedback and suggestions to RIOC leadership.

To join the meeting, simply click the link here: Join the meeting now

Thanks and we hope to see you then!

-Team RIOC

During the March 11 2025 RIOC Public Safety Department (PSD) Community Engagement meeting, Chief Kevin Brown spoke about how PSD will handle the large crowds at the Tram with the warmer weather arriving.

According to Chief Brown:

... Warm weather is coming. With the warm weather there's long lines at the Tram. We will be out there. Public Safety will  ensure that people are safe on the Tram. We've limited to 50 persons on the platform so that everybody can be safe....

... if you need the elevator for any reason you are allowed to take the  elevator. You don't have to prove that you're a certain age. Whoever you are, if you need the elevator you will be allowed to take the elevator and if anybody stops you tell them that you spoke to Chief Brown...

When asked, Chief Brown added that people will have to wait on the long line before using the elevator although PSD Officers have discretion to use "common sense" to allow some people to skip the line and go directly to the elevator.

Here are Chief Brown's full remarks on the subject from the 24 minute mark until 33 minute 50 second mark.

Friday, April 16, 2021

Is A Perfect Storm Brewing For Roosevelt Island Weekend Transportation Disaster? No Subway Service To And From Manhattan, Large Crowds Of Visitors Anticipated For Cherry Blossoms And Tram Operating At Half Capacity Of 55 Riders Per Cabin For Covid Social Distancing - Don't Worry, RIOC Says It Has A Weekend Safety Plan

Do you remember the 2019 Roosevelt Island Cherry Blossom Disaster?

Well, be aware that there is no Roosevelt Island subway service at all this weekend - no Manhattan or Queens bound service.

According to the MTA: 

Learn how we're modernizing the signals on the E F M R in Queens 

Apr 16 - 19, Fri 9:30 PM to Mon 5 AM* 

F No service at 21 St-Queensbridge, Roosevelt Island, Lexington Av/63 St and 57 St  

F Trains run via the E in both directions between Roosevelt Av and 5 Av/53 St. 

Free shuttle buses run between Roosevelt Island and Queens Plaza, stopping at 21 St-Queensbridge and Queensboro Plaza.

The weekend weather forecast is for spring like temperatures and sun so expect large crowds of visitors coming to Roosevelt Island to see the Cherry Blossoms even with no organized festival taking place.

Roosevelt Island resident Jim Luce reminds us why there is no longer a Cherry Blossom Festival on Roosevelt Island.

Roosevelt Island residents do not want a repeat of the 2019 Cherry Blossom Festival dangerous overcrowding disaster when both the subway and Tram were supposed to be running.

Without Roosevelt Island subway service this weekend, the Tram operating at only 55 passengers per cabin due to Covid 19 social distancing protocols and large numbers of visitors coming to see the Cherry Blossoms,  the potential exists for a very unpleasant weekend.

This morning, I asked the Roosevelt Island Operating Corp (RIOC) President Shelton Haynes:

There is no Roosevelt island subway service to and from Manhattan tomorrow. 

Will RIOC run red bus shuttle to Manhattan and both tram cabins? 

What does RIOC plan to do about large crowds expected to see the cherry blossoms. 

Will extra PSD officers monitor crowd control at the Tram, Ferry and throughout the Island? Has NYPD been alerted about situation? 

There has been no announcement yet from RIOC on any plan for this weekend’s potential transportation mess.

RIOC announced a weekend safety plan this afternoon at about 4 pm:

In anticipation of an increase in visitor and pedestrian traffic to the island this weekend to view the Cherry Blossoms, alongside the disruption in F train service to the R.I. station, the following safety controls will be activated, effective Saturday, April 17th at 7 AM through Monday, April 19th:

Overcrowding Safety Controls:
  • NYPD and PSD will enforce social distancing throughout the island as well as at highly frequented locations on the island 
  • Large crowds will be managed by PSD officers with the assistance of the 114th Precinct 
  • Parks will be monitored by PSD throughout the day. Please note that parks will close in the occurrence of overcrowding on the island. 
  • Cornell security have been alerted and will monitor and discourage large gatherings on the Cornell Tech campus 
  • Face coverings will be distributed to anyone in need of a mask by PSD. 
Transportation & Island Services:

Subway- There will be NO F Train service at Roosevelt Island, 21 St.-Queensbridge, Lexington Av/63 St., and 57 St. this weekend. Free MTA shuttle buses will run between Roosevelt Island and Queens Plaza, stopping at 21 St-Queensbridge and Queensboro Plaza. Free MTA shuttle buses will run between Roosevelt Island and Queens Plaza, stopping at 21 St-Queensbridge and Queensboro Plaza. For details, visit MTA.info

Red Bus- Shuttle service will be provided hourly from the R.I. Tramway, and on the half hour from the Manhattan Tram station. A separate transportation advisory will be sent momentarily detailing transportation options. 

Tram- PSD officers will be present at each station and will enforce social distancing. Passengers should plan accordingly as they may experience long lines.  

Ferry Service- Ferry service will run on normal weekend service hours, however, in the event of large crowds, service will be limited to essential workers only.  For schedule info, visit: Ferry.nyc 

Vehicular Traffic:
In the event of overcrowding, vehicular access to the island will be restricted to island residents and workers only. PSD and NYPD will be stationed at the entryway of the bridge (Vernon and 36th Ave.) to monitor and redirect, if needed. 

Bicycles:
Citations will be issued to any cyclist/motorized scooters who do not adhere to NYC bike laws.

Garbage Removal:
There will be an increase in waste management this weekend to address any littering caused by overcrowding. 

Thank you for your cooperation during this time. Please remember to enjoy your weekend in a safe and mindful manner. For more information, please call PSD at 212-832-4545.
Here's the NYC Ferry Roosevelt Island Astoria Route Schedule which extends to East 90th street on the Upper East Side.   

There are Roosevelt Island Ciibike docking stations too.

UPDATE 4/22 - Although there were long lines at the Tram at certain times last weekend, it was not the disaster some feared. The cloudy and cooler than expected temperatures probably kept some visitors away.

The Manhattan Tram station line was very long Sunday afternoon stretching to 2nd Avenue and 59th Street

 as I was coming home, so I jumped on the Red Bus Shuttle back to Roosevelt Island for a very pleasant 20 minute ride home.

Sunday, April 26, 2020

Roosevelt Island Cherry Blossoms Past Their Peak But Some Still Blooming Beautifully On East River Promenade - Thankfully, No Roosevelt Island Cherry Blossom Festival Their Year, Watch Video To Relive The Dangerous Overcrowding

The Roosevelt Island Cherry Blossoms have peaked for the most part but some are still in bloom and are beautiful like these seen on the East River Promenade across from the Cornel Tech campus.



The Roosevelt Island Twitterverse shows us more of the Roosevelt Island Cherry Blossoms

Monday, February 3, 2020

Do You Remember 2019 Roosevelt Island Cherry Blossom Festival Massive Crowds Creating Transportation Chaos? Won't Happen Again This Year, RIOC Says No Cherry Blossom Festival For 2020

The Roosevelt Island Cherry Blossom Festival began as a small local event organized by the Roosevelt Island Residents Association (RIRA) in 2011to support relief efforts on behalf of Japanese earthquake victims. Each succeeding year, the Roosevelt Island Cherry Blossom Festival attracted more and more people until massive crowds arrived last year, (approximately 40 thousand people) overwhelming the Roosevelt Island transportation system. Roosevelt Island was fortunate that there were no injuries or worse.

Remember this?



Tuesday, May 21, 2019

RIOC President Says Figment NYC June 1-2 Lighthouse Park Event A Test Case To See If Roosevelt Island Can Handle Large Crowd Events - PSD Hosting May 23 Town Hall Event To Discuss Safety Preparations For Figment, You're Invited To Attend And Share Concerns

Roosevelt Island is hosting the 2019 Figment NYC Participatory Art Project at Lighthouse Park on June 1-2.  The event is expected to draw large numbers of visitors to Roosevelt Island which is of great concern to residents who do not want a repeat of the Cherry Blossom Festival Transportation disaster with:

  • dangerously long lines at the Tram, Subway, Ferry, 
  • closure of the Roosevelt Island Bridge to traffic,
  • lack of bathrooms, food and water for the visitors.
Estimates of visitors for the Cherry Blossom Festival ranged from 35 - 40 thousand people overwhelming Roosevelt Island that day.

Roosevelt Island Operating Corp (RIOC) President Susan Rosenthal reported during the May 9 Board Meeting that the Figment NYC event will be a test case to see if Roosevelt Island can handle large crowd events.

Ms Rosenthal said that the 2018 Figment NYC Festival at Governor's Island drew 12 thousand people but that they have no idea how many visitors may come to Roosevelt Island this year. Ms Rosenthal added that the Figment NYC Lighthouse Park event will be using tickets for entry. 



Following the Cherry Blossom Festival Transportation disaster, RIOC has been in discussions with NYC Emergency Management, NYPD, FDNY, MTA and Figment NYC organizers to develop safety procedures for the June 1-2 Lighthouse Park event.

On May 23, the RIOC Public Safety Department will host a community Town Hall Meeting to  discuss safety preparations for the June 1-2 Figment NYC Lighthouse Park event.

According to RIOC:
KNOW MORE, BE SAFE

COMMUNITY TOWN HALL DISCUSSION WITH PSD ON THE SAFETY AND PREPARATIONS FOR FIGMENT NY

THURSDAY, MAY 23rd at 6 PM

The Chapel of the Good Shepherd

543 Main Street ADA accessible

Invited Guests:

NYC Emergency Management (NYCEM), NYPD, Figment NYC, Assembly Member Rebecca Seawright, Council Member Ben Kallos

What: Figment NYC is a free participatory arts event that celebrates creativity by challenging artists and participants to find new ways to create, share, and dream.

When: Saturday, June 1st and Sunday, June 2nd

Where: Various Island locations, including Lighthouse Park, along the West Promenade, the Motorgate Atrium, and the lawn south of Rivercross.
Here's May 7 RIOC Operations Advisory Committee meeting discussion of plans



for Figments NYC event.

Also, click here if you are interested in volunteering to help at Roosevelt Island's Figment NYC participatory public art project.

Learn more about Figment NYC at their web site.

Friday, May 10, 2019

Roosevelt Island Community Report From RIOC President Susan Rosenthal - Chief McManus Retiring, Aftermath Of Cherry Blossom Festival Transportation Mess, Figment NYC June 1-2 Event Is Test Of Ability To Handle Large Crowd Events, No July 4 Fireworks Celebration, Bike Lane/Ramp, FDR Hope Memorial Status, RIOC Director David Kraut 25 Year Anniversary & More

Roosevelt Island Operating Corp (RIOC) President Susan Rosenthal reported to the May 9 RIOC Board of Directors meeting on the following subjects.

Here's the full Roosevelt Island community report from RIOC President Susan Rosenthal.


Friday, May 3, 2019

Figment NYC Participatory Art Project Coming To Roosevelt Island's Lighthouse Park June 1-2 - RIOC Working With Office Of Emergency Management, NYPD 114 Precinct, MTA And Other NYC Agencies To Avoid Another Cherry Blossom Festival Transportation Disaster And Insure Safety Of Large Crowd Expected To Attend

Roosevelt Island is hosting the 2019 Figment NYC Participatory Art Project at Lighthouse Park on June 1-2.  The event is expected to draw large numbers of visitors to Roosevelt Island which is of great concern to residents who do not want a repeat of the Cherry Blossom Festival Transportation disaster. As reported April 30:

The April 13 Roosevelt Island Cherry Blossom Festival was a transportation planning disaster for Roosevelt Island residents and visitors. We are fortunate nobody was seriously injured or even killed by the overwhelming number of people waiting on very, very, very long lines at the Tram, Subway, Ferry and Roosevelt Island Bridge....



To date, not one of the Cherry Blossom Festival organizers, the Roosevelt Island Operating Corp (RIOC), Roosevelt Island Residents Association (RIRA) and the FDR Four Freedoms Park have apologized, taken responsibility or explained what they will do to prevent future similar occurrences from happening.
During the May 1 RIRA Common Council meeting, RIRA President Lynn Strong-Shinozaki reported to the community:
Many of us were heartbroken and dismayed to hear of the transportation difficulties our neighbors experienced during and after this year’s Cherry Blossom Festival. Our neighbors fell into two camps:

Some enjoy the quiet, small town nature of our island, and want to keep it that way, with no community events at all.

Some would like to have events, as long as there is preferential treatment to the residents and people who work and do business here, limiting the number of people who have access to the island during events.

Moving forward, what is most important is that the Roosevelt Island community needs to have a strong voice in how Transportation issues are studied, and how solutions are planned and executed. It is absolutely unacceptable for our residents, workers and guests to be denied access to our community.

RIRA will be meeting with the MTA, New York Ferry and NYPD 114, plus, of course, RIOC, to talk about Transportation , Crowd control and the rush-hour problems residents have been experiencing for years. Both Assembly member Seawright and State Senator Serrano will arrange these meetings and champion our community on these issues. We hope to come back to RIRA with them to present solutions in the very near future. Your feedback has been noted.
Roosevelt Island's NY State Senator Jose Serrano addressed the issue as follows:
While the Cherry Blossom festival was a success in some aspects, the transportation issues that occurred on the day of the event are truly troubling. Our office is working alongside Assembly Member Rebecca Seawright's office in organizing a meeting between RIRA, RIOC, RI Public Safety, NYCTA, New York City Ferry and the 114th Precinct in the hopes that we can come up with a plan of action for festivals/events like this on the island going forward. Safe and swift transportation to, from and on the island is a major priority, not just on event days.

We have been continuing a dialogue with RIOC and residents in regards to field access and the construction at Octagon Field. We are thankful for RIOC's compromises so far, which include limited permit times to outside groups, reducing the fencing around the new field, and decreasing the number of trees affected by construction. We remain in communication about further potential improvements to the plan....
What will RIOC do to ensure the safety of residents and visitors to the Figment NYC event. RIOC spokesperson Jessica Murray reported today:
Executives from the Roosevelt Island Operating Corporation (RIOC) attended a meeting with New York City Emergency Management (NYCEM) and other city agencies yesterday to develop a safety and transportation plan for the upcoming Figment Festival. In an April 25th kickoff meeting with NYCEM Commissioner Joseph Esposito, RIOC representatives Susan Rosenthal, Shelton Haynes, Jack McManus, and Kevin Brown discussed concerns which arose from the popular Cherry Blossom Festival held a few weeks prior. They requested participation from other agencies to proactively address safety, crowd control, and transportation issues for future large events on Roosevelt Island, using Figment as a test for an interagency plan.

Commissioner Esposito expeditiously contacted department heads from corresponding agencies (NYPD, DOT, FDNY, NYCEDC, MTA) to request their attention and action to assist RIOC. At this second meeting yesterday, with all the aforementioned parties, it was decided that the Public Safety Department (PSD) will work hand in hand with the 114 Precinct and Transit Authority to manage crowd and security concerns.

Transportation agencies are actively working on solutions to maintain a safe and steady flow of attendees. Vehicles are being strongly discouraged as an option for accessing the island on the days of the event. Members of NYCEM leadership will be on the island for event days to assist with any matters that may arise. A follow up meeting will be scheduled to finalize the safety and transportation plans.

The Figment Festival will take place on June 1st and 2nd primarily in Lighthouse Park, with smaller exhibits positioned at other locations on the island. Figment’s vision for art looks past the white-walled galleries and into the realm of participation. Figment NYC was held on Governor’s Island for 12 years and this will be its first year on Roosevelt Island. This will be Figment’s 70th festival, with events having been held in 20 cities and five countries.
Here's what to expect at the Figment NYC Lighthouse Park event:
What: FIGMENT is an explosion of creative energy. It's a free, annual celebration of participatory art and culture where everything is possible. For one weekend this summer, it will transforms Roosevelt Island into a large-scale collaborative artwork - and then it's gone.

When: Saturday, June 1st 10am-10pm and Sunday June 2nd 10am-6pm.

Where: Lighthouse Park, Roosevelt Island, NYC… Click here for directions.

How Much: FREE! FIGMENT is a free, non-profit event, and we do not accept corporate sponsorship.

What to Bring: Whatever you need for a day of fun. For specific ideas or if you have specific questions, view our list! Note: The event is rain-or-shine. If the forecast calls for rain, be prepared to hide – or dance – under porches, arches, and umbrellas while the clouds pass.

What to Expect: Art and activities in every medium available… especially the art and activities that YOU bring! Click here to see a full list of this year's activities.
More info on Figment NYC at their web site.



as well as volunteer opportunities for the Roosevelt Island Lighthouse Park event.

Tuesday, April 30, 2019

RIRA Refuses To Allow Roosevelt Island Media To Attend SC&E Committee Meeting Discussion Of Cherry Blossom Festival Transportation Planning Disaster - Fear Of Public Humiliation And Misrepresentation Cited As Reason

The April 13 Roosevelt Island Cherry Blossom Festival was a transportation planning disaster for Roosevelt Island residents and visitors. We are fortunate nobody was seriously injured or even killed by the overwhelming number of people waiting on very, very, very long lines at the Tram, Subway, Ferry and Roosevelt Island Bridge.



To date, not one of the Cherry Blossom Festival organizers, the Roosevelt Island Operating Corp (RIOC), Roosevelt Island Residents Association (RIRA) and the FDR Four Freedoms Park have apologized, taken responsibility or explained what they will do to prevent future similar occurrences from happening.

On Thursday April 25, I learned that the RIRA Social Cultural & Education (SC& E) Committee was meeting that evening and among the items to be discussed was the Cherry Blossom Festival. RIRA Committee meetings are supposed to be open to the public so I showed up for the meeting to ask about the Cherry Blossom Festival and give RIRA the opportunity to explain what happened and why Roosevelt Island was so unprepared to handle the enormous crowd of people. (RIOC estimated crowd to be approximately 30 thousand people, though I have heard estimates of 40 thousand.)

Upon arriving for the meeting, I was told that I could only attend if I agreed not to report on what was discussed. I objected saying that the meeting was open to the public. I pointed out, and the committee members agreed, that persons attending the meeting can inform their spouses, neighbors or anybody else what happens at the meeting so why couldn't I report the same information to the community on Roosevelt Islander news web site? The SC&E Committee members insisted that nothing discussed at the meeting could be reported in the "press" so I left.

According to the SC&E Committee Code of Conduct:

2. All committee members will be required to adhere to responsible representation and reporting.

Our committee deals with the most inventive and creative aspects of the Common Council. We need to be able to present ideas, projects and concepts within our committee meetings without the fear of public humiliation by unauthorized publication misrepresenting committee work....

... Anyone releasing committee information to any of the Island media/or any other entity without the consent of the committee will be asked to step down immediately....
Before I left, I was told that the SC&E Committee would have a statement on the Cherry Blossom event during 8 PM Wednesday May 1 Common Council meeting at Good Shepherd Community Center which the public is invited to attend.

Had I been allowed to attend the RIRA SC&E Committee meeting, I would have sought answers to concerns such as these expressed by resident Joseph Williams in an email he sent to Cherry Blossom organizers and shares below:
To whom it may concern,

I have been asked to email you directly as you are rightfully embarrassed by the negative publicity around this event and the terrifying ordeal it incurred for residents and attendees.

I was hosting a party for my mother's 65th birthday in my apartment. The overcrowding, transit and security failures caused immense distress to me and my family, in particular to my elderly and disabled relatives, several of whom spent hours attempting to get here and either failed or suffered as a result.

I have a number of questions. I would like answers from the responsible parties.

1. Who is responsible for this event? The poster indicates RIOC, RIRA and Four Freedoms were all participants in the organization. Based on this I am astonished to see the Festival disclaim responsibility for transit and operations...

2. The security checkpoint at the bridge. This was extremely disruptive and poorly organized and managed. My understanding was that Main Street would be open to traffic north of the tram. Cars were being stopped -- causing massive delays -- and turned away for no reason. There was a callous disregard for the needs of the elderly and disabled: my 89 year old grandfather, his wife and my uncle were instructed to abandon their car in Astoria and walk across the bridge rather than being permitted to drop my grandfather at my building. My mother's cousin who is paralyzed on his left side by stroke waited two hours at the checkpoint and ultimately had to go home after being turned away by security. This is not acceptable.

2. What is the intention for future events, and in particular the even larger Cherry Blossom Festival planned for 2020... ?  I would like to discuss this with the responsible parties and please see point 4 below. Comment to RIOC -- I will be phoning your office tomorrow during business hours to discuss this further.

3. The situation in the subway was appalling. My cousin brought her eight month old baby and was on the escalator that stopped with no warning and suffered in the crush to get out. She arrived visibly shaken and afraid that she was going to be injured, trampled or suffocated. She chose to leave almost immediately by ferry and waited three hours.

This volume of people was totally mismanaged. You are lucky you narrowly avoided the absolute catastrophe of a human crush. Please educate yourselves about the dangers of overcrowding in confined spaces --
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hillsborough_disaster.

Comment to RIOC -- The Festival organizers blame the MTA and disclaim responsibility for transit and operations (see RICBF Comment 2, attached). The MTA doesn't operate the tram or the bridge or the ferry. As far as I can tell, the MTA had to twice divert the entire New York City subway system to accommodate your failures. I need to know who is ultimately in charge of operations and security for the island, if not your organization. Should I be contacting our representatives in Albany?

4. With regard to future events:
  • There should be no future unticketed events on Roosevelt Island. Attendees should be required to register for any event.
  • Residents and workers must have access and priority with regard to transit. We are tired of suffering the long delays with tourists clogging our ailing infrastructure and getting trapped in our own homes or turned away trying to gain access.
  • Accommodations must be made for disabled and elderly people to ensure they can access the island when needed, regardless of what events you intend to have here.
This is our home. Roosevelt Island is a quiet, close-knit, residential community with a high proportion of families, elderly and disabled residents. It is not like the uninhabited Randalls or Governors Island that you can use as you wish. Future intentions to treat it as such will be met with intense resistance from those of us who have made this our home. All of the organizations listed have failed the residents of this island.

I look forward to a public apology to residents from the responsible parties, and to discussing a constructive solution for the future.
RIRA responded to Mr Williams as follows:
Dear Mr. Williams,

On behalf of the Cherry Blossom Festival Committee, we were saddened to learn that the special family gathering you had planned on April 13, the day of the Cherry Blossom Festival, turned out so disappointingly for you and your visiting family members.

We apologize for any misunderstanding regarding the activities that the Committee planned that interfered with or disrupted your celebration.

In addition, we are sorry about the delay in responding to your detailed letter of complaint, which was relayed to us on April 14th ; preparations for our own family celebration of Easter impeded an earlier reply.

As you may be aware, the Committee was solely responsible for the performances held at Four Freedoms Park and activities held at Gallery RIVAA and South Point Park. It also coordinated with other community groups and merchants.

To the best of our knowledge, RIOC communicated with the MTA regarding transportation arrangements and with Public Safety regarding local traffic.

Improvements in communication and anticipation of difficult scenarios, however unlikely, will certainly be part of the planning for future events.

Thank you for calling these issues to our attention.

More on the Cherry Blossom Festival transportation disaster




at prior posts.

This screw up belongs not just to RIRA but to RIOC as well.

Tuesday, April 16, 2019

RIOC And RIRA Respond To Roosevelt Island Cherry Blossom Festival Transportation Mess - Events Of This Scale Will Be Subject Of Future Discussions And Roosevelt Island No Longer Best Kept Secret In NYC Says RIOC President



It's impossible to walk down Roosevelt Island's Main Street without hearing residents talk about the transportation mess that occurred at last Saturday's Cherry Blossom Festival.



There are so many stories of Roosevelt Island residents and visitors safety put in danger by the enormous crowds overwhelming our local transportation infrastructure. Just one example from a resident described:
What a mess. The attendees were put in great danger. The accountability goes to the organizers and RIOC. There were not enough food vendors, the water was shut off, public transportation was insufficient and at some point almost impossible to get off the island. The subway station was so crowded that no one could go in or out of the station. That was really VERY DANGEROUS. Neighbors reported close to an hour wait to get out of the station. Where was public safety?, why was NYPD not contacted to help with crowd control?

Organizing an event of this magnitude requires many hours of work, carefully crafted contingency plans and lots of logistic organization.
An outraged visitor added:
In response to my inquiry last Sunday, Roosevelt Island Operating Corp (RIOC) President Susan Rosenthal stated:
We are in the midst of debriefings and will have a lot to say in the near term. But, there were no “transportation problems”, ... — there were about 3 times as many folks as last year. NYPD and RIOC made decisions based upon safety concerns. No one was hurt and no one got arrested.
A RIOC spokesperson provided a more detailed statement this evening:
On Saturday, April 13th, the Roosevelt Island Residents Association (RIRA) presented their annual Cherry Blossom Festival, partnering with the Roosevelt Island Operating Corporation (RIOC) and FDR Four Freedoms State Park. While the event was highly successful, with great weather, fabulous entertainment, Japanese culture, and of course the beautiful cherry blossom trees, the island experienced overcrowding in its transportation hubs, at the Tramway, Subway, and Ferry. In addition, the Roosevelt Island Bridge had an influx of both vehicular and pedestrian traffic, causing intermittent delays and, at times, complete shutdowns to vehicular access were necessary as a safety precaution.

Historically, the typical crowd size for this event has been approximately 2,000 – 3,000 people, until 2018 when approximately 10,000 guests attended. As a result of this increase, RIOC anticipated an even larger crowd size in 2019 and, focusing its attention on safety, re-evaluated the event layout, travel restrictions, staffing, and security plan preceding this year’s event.

The RIOC Public Safety Department (PSD) partnered with the New York Police Department (NYPD) and NYCEM to provide additional on-island support. In addition, PSD was in contact with the Metropolitan Transportation Authority (MTA) to ensure there were no interruptions in subway service to Roosevelt Island. There were roughly 60 dedicated security personnel, which were comprised of RIOC Public Safety, NYPD officers, and outside security officers, on hand at the Festival. The NYPD provided an additional 16 officers, a lieutenant, and a sergeant who were on standby in case they were needed to manage the larger crowds.

This year the Cherry Blossom Festival had a record number of approximately 30,000 people attend. The Festival activities took place between 11 AM – 5 PM, however crowds continued to arrive on Roosevelt Island late in the day, reaching peak capacity between 4 – 4:30 PM. After closely monitoring the overcrowding at the Tram and subway, the following occurred:
  • The NYPD shut down the escalators at the Roosevelt Island subway stop at approximately 4:20 PM, allowing access in and out of the station from both directions.
  • At 4:45 PM the MTA stopped incoming trains to Roosevelt Island. RIOC also stopped Tram service from Manhattan so that both Tram cabins could be utilized to more quickly reduce crowd size on the island.
  • Bridge traffic onto the island was halted as a safety precaution.
  • Additional service (R Train) was added to the F line subway at Roosevelt Island.
  • MTA resumed incoming service at the Roosevelt Island subway at 4:54 PM.
  • At 6:15 PM, PSD reported trains were operating in both directions to the island and the Roosevelt Island Bridge was open to regular vehicular and pedestrian traffic.
  • Regular Tram service resumed at 7:05 PM.
Overall, there were no incidents or injuries reported at the Festival. “Future Cherry Blossom Festivals, and other potential events of this scale, will be the subject of upcoming discussions among RIOC, its Board members, and RIRA now that greater NYC has discovered our island.” stated Susan Rosenthal, President/CEO of RIOC. “Roosevelt Island may no longer be the best kept secret in the city.” Rosenthal added.
Yesterday, I asked the Roosevelt Island Residents Association (RIRA) Cherry Blossom Festival Committee:
Can you please address issue of the disruptions in lives of Roosevelt Island residents caused by the overwhelming number of visitors to the Cherry Blossom Festival including the long delays getting to and from Roosevelt Island on the Tram, Ferry, subway and RI Bridge?

Also going forward, based on your experience, do you believe Roosevelt Island has infrastructure to handle events that will attract large number of visitors and do you plan on doing Cherry Blossom Festival next year?
The RIRA Cherry Blossom Festival Committee replied today:
The Cherry Blossom Festival on April 13, 2019 was a most memorable day for the following reasons:
  1. The fantastic performances: everything from the Japanese Cultural Fair at Gallery RIVAA to the Tea Ceremonies at South Point Park, to the performances at Four Freedoms Park. The visitors were dazzled by the performers and we received endless positive feedback. The Cherry Blossom Festival Committee is very grateful to the neighbors, musicians, dancers and supporters who shared their talents.
  2. For the first time in our nine-year history, the Committee was able to raise enough funds from local merchants, building managements and off-island organizations to pay the world-class musicians and dancers for their performances.
  3. Members of the Committee are very thankful for the vast support and coordination among the local groups: the Roosevelt Island Residents Association, the Roosevelt Island Operating Corporation, FDR Four Freedoms Park, Gallery RIVAA, the Roosevelt Island Japanese Association, the Main Street Theatre & Dance Alliance, The Noguchi Museum, the Roosevelt Island Disabled Association, the Roosevelt Island Parents’ Network, Amalgamated Bank, Bozzuto Management Company, Bread & Butter Deli, Cornell Tech, Fuji East, Gristedes, Hornblower, Hudson and The Related Companies, Island House Tenants Corp., Island Wine & Spirits, The James Jay Dudley Luce Foundation, Manhattan Park, Resobox, Starbucks, Urban American, Wengerd Farms, Westview Preservation Partners and Wholesome Factory Market. Thank you as well to the financial sponsors and donors who gave in-kind items.
  4. Our neighbor, the renowned Noguchi Museum, participated in our Cherry Blossom Festival for the first time!
  5. The exuberant attendance exceeded all expectations. It’s safe to say no one anticipated the overwhelming number of the many thousands of people visiting. Whether visitors headed south to participate in our programmed events, or simply strolled north of the tram and subway to view the necklace of cherry blossom trees around Roosevelt Island, everyone delighted in this annual glorious spring display.
  6. Let’s also give credit to all the employees of all the island establishments and the Cherry Blossom Festival volunteers who, in the face of an overwhelming number of visitors, maintained a calm and orderly atmosphere.
The scope of the Roosevelt Island Residents Association is the creation, production, staffing, promotion and maintenance of the cultural integrity of the Cherry Blossom Festival’s programming. One of the quintessential elements of the traditional Japanese cherry blossom celebration is to witness to the actual popping of the cherry blossoms while picnicking under the trees. We give our residents and visitors alike that rare opportunity and that special experience, not often found outside Japan, as they picnic under the cherry blossom trees around the island. This is what makes our festival most authentic. Every year is a learning experience; as the Cherry Blossom Festival continues, we will incorporate what was learned this year, and in the previous years, into our plans.

As for the issues related to transportation, to the best of our knowledge, RIOC was in regular communication with the MTA prior to the Festival regarding continuous service of the F train.

The status of our infrastructure and transportation shortcomings, which is something that Roosevelt Island residents know all too well, has again been called to the attention of our elected officials. Many of them spoke to our festival audiences and witnessed different aspects of these challenges. Let us hope this first-hand experience, plus the widespread news coverage, may serve as the basis to address and fix the shortfalls in our infrastructure and transportation.
Here's the RIRA Cherry Blossom Festival Committee welcoming crowd at FDR Four Freedoms Park and describing the origins of the Festival.



It's true that the Cherry Blossom performances at Four Freedoms Park were great



but a serious conversation must be had as to whether such events drawing huge crowds are worth the serious disruptions to the daily lives of Roosevelt Island residents.

Let's hope planning for the June 1-2 Figment NYC Public Participatory Art Project at Lighthouse Park is better planned and lessons learned from the Cherry Blossom Festival.

Here's more scenes from the Roosevelt Island Cherry Blossom Transportation mess.

Sunday, April 14, 2019

Update On Roosevelt Island Cherry Blossom Festival Transportation Mess, RIOC In Midst Of Debriefing But Says No Tranportation Problems And Approximately 30 Thousand Visitors - Watch Video As Visitors Try To Escape Roosevelt Island And Photo Of Tram Line To Third Avenue

Here's an update to yesterday's post about the Roosevelt Island transportation mess resulting from the huge numbers of visitors to the Cherry Blossom Festival.

The line to get to the Roosevelt Island Manhattan Tram Station on Second Avenue stretched almost to 3rd Avenue during yesterday's Roosevelt Island Cherry Blossom Festival as shown in picture below showing Tram riders waiting on line in the middle of 60th street between 2nd & 3rd Avenues.


As reported yesterday:
Roosevelt Island residents are furious today over the long lines and delays at the Tram, Subway, Ferry and bridge caused by the overwhelming number of visitors going to the Cherry Blossom Festival today...
Today, I asked Roosevelt Island Operating Corp (RIOC) President Susan Rosenthal:
Any statement from Rioc on the transportation problem yesterday during Cherry Blossom Festival?
Ms Rosenthal replied:
We are in the midst of debriefings and will have a lot to say in the near term. But, there were no “transportation problems”, ... — there were about 3 times as many folks as last year. NYPD and RIOC made decisions based upon safety concerns. No one was hurt and no one got arrested.
3 times as many visitors as last year would mean 30 Thousand visitors compared to last year's 10 thousand.

Roosevelt Island residents had plenty to say including these Roosevelt Islander Facebook comments:
This beautiful Island is not prepared for big events like this, more bathrooms are needed there even in ordinary days to acomódate tourists, but some kind of system should be set up to give priority to residents when events are held or limited transportation is in order.
And
What a mess. The attendees were put in great danger. The accountability goes to the organizers and RIOC. There were not enough food vendors, the water was shut off, public transportation was insufficient and at some point almost impossible to get off the island. The subway station was so crowded that no one could go in or out of the station. That was really VERY DANGEROUS. Neighbors reported close to an hour wait to get out of the station. Where was public safety?, why was NYPD not contacted to help with crowd control?

Organizing an event of this magnitude requires many hours of work, carefully crafted contingency plans and lots of logistic organization.
And:
"Roosevelt Island residents were held hostage today on their island. Couldn't leave or return for hours. No toilets, no porta potties for the thousands of guest that visited the cherry blossom festival. No garbage pickup. Heads should roll on this."
And
"I’d like to know why, on a day temps were reportedly going to be in mid-seventies, all water fountains were TURNED OFF??!! We were directing visitors to them & they told us they weren’t working!! Another reason having a State Agency, RIOC, run a community just doesn’t work...no one in Albany listens or gives a damn. Welcome to our lives fellow New Yorkers!"
According to Manhattan Borough President Gale Brewer

and NY Council Member Ben Kallos

A Cherry Blossom visitor shows us his escape from Roosevelt Island yesterday



and his arrival earlier in the day.



Another visitor to the Roosevelt Island Cherry Blossom Festival is outraged at the organizers

and seeks to know who is accoutable.

More info, photos and videos at post yesterday.

Stay tuned for more.

Saturday, April 13, 2019

Roosevelt Island Cherry Blossom Festival A Total Transportation Mess - Residents Furious That Tram, Subway, Ferry, Bridge Overwhelmed By Visitors

Roosevelt Island residents are furious today over the long lines and delays at the Tram, Subway, Ferry and bridge caused by the overwhelming  number of visitors going to the Cherry Blossom Festival today at the southern section of the Island - FDR Four Freedoms Park


and the West Waterfront Promenade next to Cornell Tech.

Will have much more on this but for now social media has the info.