Thursday, July 14, 2011

Large Branch From Roosevelt Island Tree Comes Crashing Down On Octagon Red Bus Stop - Parent and Two Children Saved From Serious Injury By Top Of Bus Stop - Will RIOC Insure Safety of That Area?


View Larger Map Image of Roosevelt Island Octagon Bus Stop

A Roosevelt Island resident shares this almost tragic experience that occurred at the Octagon Red Bus Stop Wednesday evening during the sudden torrential rain storm.
This evening at approximately 7 pm I was waiting for the Red Bus at the Octagon with my two young children. As we were standing under the bus stop it started raining and a large - about twenty feet long, quite thick - tree branch came crashing down onto the top of the bus stop, coming to rest half on the top of the stop and the rest dangling onto the sidewalk and into the street. Thank goodness for the top of the bus stop or it's quite likely we would have been seriously hurt or killed. As it was we were terrified.

The doorman at the Octagon immediately notified Public Safety and two patrol cars and one RIOC car showed up fairly quickly. However all they did was push the large branch off to the grass by the bus stop and remove the other branches and leaves that fell onto the ground. They took some pictures of the tree and the branch and looked up at the tree for a minute or so. I was so surprised that they didn't rope off the area with caution tape until park service could determine if other branches were unstable. Then they left. The Red Bus continued picking up and dropping off from directly underneath this tree.

I tried to flag down the man in the black RIOC-marked SUV to explain how dangerous it was (white haired man). He looked directly at me waving him down and pointing to the tree and didn't stop. I tried to wave to Public Safety but they stayed by the tree and I wasn't bringing my kids back near that tree.\\

Thankfully no one was hurt but I really think they should have cordoned off the area until someone could take a proper look at this. I wish they had talked to me so I could explain what had really happened.

Thanks to Octagon management for putting up that bus stop - I've never been so grateful.
The Roosevelt Island Daily Public Safety Incident Report describes what happened this way:
Tree Branch - Fell by bus shelter. No injuries or damage. Referred to Grounds.
UPDATE 6 PM - Here is picture of fallen branch 


from this tree adjacent to the Red Bus Stop taken this afternoon.


I spoke with a RIOC employee today at the site who told me that the branch on the right side of the Tree Of Heaven will probably be taken down. According to the National Park Service:
...Tree-of-heaven is a common tree in disturbed urban areas, where it sprouts up just about anywhere, including alleys, sidewalks, parking lots, and streets. For example, the book “A Tree Grows in Brooklyn,” by Betty Smith, is based on the  tree-of-heaven. Away from cities, ailanthus is commonly seen in fields, and along roadsides, fencerows, woodland edges and forest openings. It occurs as seedlings that pop up by the hundreds in recently planted fields and as persistent thickets in rocky, untillable areas. Nationally, ailanthus is recognized to be a serious agricultural pest...

18 comments :

Gotta keep shaking said...

So, that women and her two children were standing exactly under that branch that fell? Or would it have fallen a bit next to them if the bus shelter were not stopping the fall, i.e. not injuring anybody anyway?

That said, two things.... look at the headline of this blog entry. We are really going for Daily News/NY Post style now, right?

Second, branches fall from trees all the time. Sometimes they hit people, most of the time they don't. It's more an act of nature than anything else and nobody can prevent this. I understand it was a scary thing to experience but getting all angry at the RIOC is a bit premature.

Guest said...

I'm sure RIOS is insured for the entire island.  I believe you are asking if they will ensure safety there.

KeptShakingMyHeadAndItFellOff said...

This branch was probably as skinny as a cane. Would a kid get hurt, yea, probably.

But typical of this island we make something out of pretty much nothing.

She wanted psd or RIOC to explain What really happened? Umm a branch fell. There's not mich else to it. No one convinced the tree to snap a branch off, no one physically cut it, no one forced the poor tree to lose it's limb.


All I can say is "wowwwwww".

Guest said...

I saw that branch this morning at the Octagon Red Bus stop and it's big. Pretty big. Last year a baby was killed in Central Park by a similar size branch.

And it seems her complaint - if you bothered to read the actual post - is not that the branch fell but that the tree wasn't cordoned off to be checked by grounds crew and that Public Safety didn't ask the Octagon doorman or witnesses what had happened. That's legitimate.

Sandra Levine said...

Clearly, the only solution is to cut down all the trees on the island that have branches.

Guest said...

The point is not that the branch fell but that Public Safety and RIOC did nothing to secure the area before they could get grounds crew to check the tree.

Guest said...

I have to disagree. The RIOC is now supposed to cordon off and inspect every single tree that lost a branch during a storm (it was very windy during the downpour)? I don't think that's possible. If it was more than a branch and there was sign that this tree is indeed endangering the ares, yes, something has to happen. But one branch? No, sorry.

Gotta keep shaking said...

One branch is not justification enough to mobilize the ground crew.

Guest said...

If it's not enough justification to mobilize the grounds crew they should have blocked off the area until they came on duty today.

Gotta keep shaking - are you writing from Public Safety or RIOC? Hmmm...

IShakedSoHardItFellOff said...

Hmm all you want. I am defiantly positively surely not writing from public safety nor RIOC. I am sure they have much more important things to tend to than to hear wahhhh-wahhhh from a message board.

I am a simple resident who moved here and would love to move out. Way overpriced and way too much drake for a small pebble in the water.

RooseveltIslander said...

Insure or ensure?
There are multiple definitions for insure. According to Dictionary, insure can mean:

Secure or protect someone against (a possible contingency)
- by appeasing Celia they might insure themselves against further misfortune
- such changes could insure against further violence and unrest

http://www.google.com/search?client=safari&rls=en&q=insure&ie=UTF-8&oe=UTF-8#hl=en&client=safari&rls=en&q=insure&tbs=dfn:1&tbo=u&sa=X&ei=EDsfTt3pKYji0QHInujHAw&ved=0CCsQkQ4&bav=on.2,or.r_gc.r_pw.&fp=34002b09b7606e46&biw=1214&bih=625

Guest said...

It's one branch that fell off a tree during a - wait for it... - *STORM*. A storm. When you are out in that kind of weather you must consider things like this. That's why that woman did it right and stood under the shelter. The shelter protected her and her children. Why do we have to make a big thing out of this? There is nothing wrong with the tree and the lesson we learned from this is "be careful when you are outside in stormy weather". Common sense, no?

Parks said...

Too bad city agencies don't cover RI - they are really responsive when limbs of the size in that picture fall off trees. You don't have to wait till morning for grounds crews to come - they come right away b/c they work 24/7.

Zoilita said...

Some residents are clueless here and want to blame Public Safety for everything...
Just like that woman who saw her sons - in photos they took of themselves - flashing gang signs in the presentation at the Gang Summit.  What did she say again?  Oh yeah, "Our kids never got arrested under the former Director."
Clueless!

Shakinghard said...

What I've noticed during my time here is that people will always blame someone else, even if it's their fault, or if there is no one to blame.

Good Kitty said...

Please let's give our few remaining trees on RI a chance.  Thank goodness nothing happened to the mom & her child but please let's not use the branch falling as an excuse to cut down another tree..  

Guest said...

That's not unusual for any place you go. The thing is that blogs like this give complainers a big bullhorn and make this blog look extremely silly.

Ri said...

I really wish we were under NYC for public works and not RIOC - I think they'd be more proactive about taking care of things and hire experts rather than teenage kids for summer work.