Roosevelt Island Operating Corp (RIOC) President/CEO Shelton Haynes and General
Counsel Gretchen Robinson have been on paid administrative leave since January
2024 awaiting the outcome of an investigation into charges made by RIOC staff of workplace wrongdoing by Mr
Haynes and Ms Robinson.
Last week, a usually reliable Tipster reported that Mr Haynes and Ms Robinson
were fired by the RIOC Board of Directors. On November 27, I asked RIOC Board
Chairperson/NY State Division Of Homes and Community Renewal Commissioner
RuthAnne Visnauskas and the RIOC Board of Directors:
Please confirm the status of RIOC President/CEO Shelton Haynes and General
Counsel Gretchen Robinson currently on paid administrative leave pending the
results of an internal investigation regarding allegations of wrongdoing on
their part.
I was told today that they were both fired from their positions and will not
be returning to their prior positions. Is that true?
What were the findings of the investigation?
What if any, is Mr Haynes and Ms Robinson's current position with RIOC?
If they are no longer with RIOC, what is the leadership plan for RIOC?
Please let me know if RIOC will comment on this important issue for the
Roosevelt Island community.
Today, the RIOC Board of Directors announced:
As of Monday, November 25th, Shelton Haynes and Gretchen Robinson are no
longer employed with the Roosevelt Island Operating Corporation. The Board
thanks them for their service to the Roosevelt Island community and wishes
them the very best in their future endeavors. The Board will immediately begin
an executive search for new leadership. In the interim, RIOC will continue to
be led by Vice President and Chief Financial Officer Dhruvika Amin, Acting
Chief Operating Officer Mary Cunneen, and Associate General Counsel Lada
Stasko until replacements for the CEO and General Counsel positions are
secured.
I followed up asking:
Has there been any resolution of the lawsuit?
What were the results of the investigation of charges by staff of wrongdoing
by Mr Haynes and Ms Robinson?
against RIOC and members of NY State Governor Kathy Hochul's staff:
... Do either Mr Haynes, Ms Robinson or yourself have any comment on the firing or any other aspect of this matter including the investigation of staff charges of wrongdoing brought against them and their pending lawsuit against RIOC and members of the Governor's staff...
Mr Williams replied:
On November 22, 2024, Shelton Haynes, former CEO and President, and Gretchen Robinson, former General Counsel of the Roosevelt Island Operating Corporation (RIOC), were unjustly terminated. This can only be viewed as retaliatory for their filing a lawsuit in late 2023 that exposed the systemic and pervasive discrimination and racism that they have endured at the hands of the Executive Chamber for the Office of New York Governor Hochul and RIOC
Fourteen times over the past three years, Haynes and Robinson have been investigated by several New York State entities and two law firms – costing New York taxpayers well more than half a million dollars.
Each and every investigation has found nothing more than unsubstantiated claims and concluded there were no material actionable findings.
These baseless probes, weaponized to undermine their leadership, demonstrate a pattern of retaliation and serve as yet another attempt to silence individuals who stand against injustice, particularly racial injustice.
This is nothing short of a travesty, Shelton Haynes and Gretchen Robinson have dedicated their careers to public service and served the Roosevelt Island community with integrity and excellence. Instead of addressing their legitimate concerns about systemic issues, they have again and again been met with retaliation and unfounded accusations. The actions taken against them, under the guise of a ‘loss of confidence,’ reflect a disturbing misuse of power that undermines the principles of fairness and justice.
I followed up asking Mr Williams:
Have you received the results of the most recent investigation?
Can you share what it said?
Mr Williams replied:
No findings or report from the last investigation at all. Very different from the Greenberg Traurig report which cleared them. Also, the areas that the recent investigation covered were substantially similar to what Greenberg Traurig cleared them for approximately 18 months ago.
But, Mr Fhala's style and behavior could sometimes be perceived as overly aggressive and confrontational which angered some and others thought his tactics were counter productive at times.
Image Of Ben Fhala At September 29, 2024 RIOC Board Of Directors Meeting
Rumors were swirling yesterday that Ben Fhala would soon be removed from the RIOC Board of Directors after Mr Fhala was spotted by several residents outside the Good Shepherd Church
during last Thursday evening's RIOC Board of Directors Executive Session.
The speculation was that he was outside during the meeting because he was one of
the subjects being discussed in the Executive Session.
Today Mr Fhala's removal was confirmed when he shared the following email he
sent to NY Governor Kathy Hochul this morning:
Dear Governor Hochul,
I am writing to formally submit my resignation as a member of the Board of
Directors of the Roosevelt Island Operating Corporation (RIOC), effective
immediately. It is my sincere hope that this decision might also help to
motivate board members whose terms have long expired to consider stepping down
to pave the way for others to step up and lead with the commitment, energy and
vision required to address the many challenges ahead.
For the past year, working alongside dedicated individuals, together we
advocated for and advised implementation of policies that benefit the
Roosevelt Island community.
Among these achievements:
Revised Updated Bylaws:
Governance Committee updated the bylaws
aimed at engagement, transparency and setting the stage for a more localized
governance and decision-making process. The revised Bylaws received the
approval of the ABO and the COOG and are ready for the consideration of the
full board.
Addressing Negligence/Deferred Maintenance in Repair of Pavement and Zebra
Block Maintenance:
Initiating the repairs has already led to a dramatic reduction in
slip-and-fall incidents, directly improving public safety and accessibility
of our Island. Safer streets reduce accidents and lawsuits.
Empowering Island Leadership to Engage with Stakeholders:
Facilitating deeper engagement between Island leadership and stakeholders,
including local media, to enhance transparency and community engagement in
decision-making processes.
Increased Public Funding for Local Non-Profits:
Successfully aligned
public purpose funding with the needs of local non-profits, ensuring that
resources are distributed more effectively to directly support
community-driven initiatives.
Reducing Motorgate Waitlist:
From a waitlist of well over a year to
immediate availability for all residents, significantly improving access and
increasing revenue for the corporation.
Despite these accomplishments, many critical issues still require urgent attention to ensure the continued growth and well-being of the Roosevelt Island community. These include:
Corruption and Misconduct in Contract Selection: Numerous allegations of corruption, favoritism, and misconduct in the selection of RIOC contracts, contractors and consultants seems to be substantiated. This issue requires urgent investigation and reform to restore trust and integrity.
Unjustified Salary Increases for Senior Staff while lacking Critical Skills required for performance tasks : Salaries within RIOC’s senior staff have ballooned over the years without clear guidelines regarding the professional responsibilities, success parameters, or alignment with current market rates for comparable government positions. Multiple whistleblowers have reported unmerited salary increases, but no action has been taken by the board or its handlers. At the same time, critical skilled roles such as a structural engineer remain unfilled. The lack of a professional staff with appropriate qualifications results in the hiring of outside consultants at significant additional expense.
Enabling Strong, Experienced Local Leadership: With de facto vacancies in our CEO, COO and General Counsel roles, it’s critical to appoint qualified and capable leadership that serves the public interests of Roosevelt Island. Meanwhile, the continued payment for the current at-home administration adds a strain on resources
Self-Funded Investigations: The ongoing practice of self-funded, open-ended investigations has cost Island residents millions of dollars over the years. Often they are without clear guardrails, control mechanisms, or transparency. These investigations need to be scrutinized and brought under board oversight.
Neglect and Disrepair of Island Infrastructure: Years of deferred maintenance and negligence have left many structures on the island in disrepair, from a sinking Main Street to structurally compromised railings to unresolved issues with steam tunnels that could pose catastrophic risks. Immediate action is needed to prevent further deterioration and ensure public safety. The current bus crisis is evidence that advanced organization and budget planning is critical but is rarely, if ever, done. Preventive maintenance of all systems and operations should be done on a routine basis.
Capitalization of Tram Tourism Ridership: The current focus on subsidizing tram ridership for tourists is negatively impacting the quality of service and strains public resources. The increase in tourism should provide an injection of revenue to increase the quality of life of all stakeholders on the Island but no strategic vision has been discussed let alone implemented.
Finding New Funding Avenues: It is crucial to explore new ways to fund RIOC initiatives, such as building out a grants department or hiring an advocacy group to secure long-term operational funding and consider tourism as a source for economic growth.
However, it has become increasingly clear that I have become a focal point of discussions and controversies that detract from the essential work that needs to be done. The focus and efforts should always be on the real and critical issues the Island faces. The work of RIOC and its board, as a public benefit corporation, should be exclusively to improve the quality of life for the stakeholders of this Island—the residents, businesses, and communities we serve. In light of this, I believe that my continued presence on the board is counterproductive to achieving the progress the stakeholders of this Island deserve.
Thank you for the opportunity to serve the people of Roosevelt Island. I remain deeply committed to the community and will continue to support it in any way I can.
Cordially,
Ben Fhala*
Junior (Resident) Board Member
*Disclaimer: All statements made by Ben Fhala are made in his capacity as a RIOC Resident Board member. He does not represent the entirety of RIOC or the full board but serves as a Resident Board member, offering information to the community and its stakeholders.
You can see some of the tension between Mr Fhala and RIOC Board Chair designee Megan Anderson representing NY State Department Homes & Community Renewal (DHCR) Commissioner RuthAnne Visnauskas, and fellow RIOC Board members Howard Polivy, Faye Christian and David Kraut during last Thursday's RIOC Board Meeting. Mr Fhala appeared to be trying to make some information public which was objected to by some of the other Board members.
Reliable sources say that a majority of the RIOC Board had the votes to pass a resolution recommending Mr Fhala's removal from the Board.
Mr Fhala's resignation leaves vacant one of the 9 RIOC Board seats vacant. The Board seat will not be filled to at least January 2025 when the NY State Senate is in session and more likely many months later.
Mr Fhala will be thanked by many residents who appreciate the good work he accomplished.
Stay tune for more on Mr Fhala's resignation from the RIOC Board.
The Roosevelt Island Operating Corp (RIOC) announced on Monday July 8:
Dear Roosevelt Island Community:
Please be advised that a meeting of the RIOC Board's Governance Committee
will be held on Wednesday, July 10, 2024, at 1:30 p.m. at the Good
Shepherd Community Center, 543 Main Street, Roosevelt Island, New York
10044.
There will also be a meeting of the full RIOC Board of Directors on
Wednesday, July 10 at 3:00 p.m. also at The Good Shepherd Community
Center.
Agendas for both meetings can be found below.
Thank you.
-Team RIOC
This full RIOC Board of Directors meeting was previously unscheduled.
According to the
Agenda
below, it is described as a "Special Meeting" and is being held in
Executive Session
meaning the public is not allowed to attend and the discussion is secret.
It's possible, though not confirmed, that the employment status of RIOC
President Shelton Haynes and General Counsel Gretchen Robinson will be
discussed during the July 10 Special RIOC Board Meeting Executive Session.
As previously reported,
Mr Haynes and Ms Robinson have been on paid administrative leave since
January 2024 pending an investigation of them about workplace concerns
raised by RIOC employees. The Executive Session could also be about the
current status of the
RIOC leadership team
following the recent departure of Deputy General Counsel Gerrald Ellis who
had been the primary public face of the interim leadership team.
On June 26, I asked RIOC:
... with Gerrald leaving at the end of this month, what is the leadership
plan for RIOC?...
RIOC Board Director Ben Fhala answered on July 2:
I was hoping that someone from the administration would be ready to reply
to you by now, but it's critical that we don't create a communication void
during this important time. The board has decided to maintain the current
leadership status quo. We have full faith in Dhruvika as the interim
leader. She will be seeking advice and counsel from the incredible
existing leadership team that report to her during this transition period
until the board reconvenes and decides if or when other changes or
enhancements will be made.
We are grateful for Gerald's service and wish him great success in his
future endeavors. As always, I cannot speak on behalf of the entire board,
but this is the summary of thoughts that I am aware of that were made by
the board members. If anyone else would like to chime in, they are always
welcome to do so...
The
RIOC Governance Committee
will have a pubic meeting prior to the start of the full RIOC Board meeting.
I would like to propose a resolution to clarify the meaning of quorum to prevent any misunderstanding of the law and how we apply it at RIOC. Deep engagement between board members and executives at RIOC is critical for oversight and to prevent external actors from controlling the agenda and the interests of RIOC. Unfortunately, I've been informed by a whistleblower that there is an attempt to block resident board members from engaging with each other. The whistleblower informed me of an alleged collusion between the RIOC legal team, Howard Polivy, and Meghan Anderson to block interactions between resident board members under the legal rationale articulated in a resolution made by the board on October 17th, 2019. While I don't think their understanding of this resolution applies, I would like to add a clear definition here to enable the critical work of the resident board members. Moreover this update has not been ratified by an update to our by-laws.
As such, I propose a resolution:
"Board members are encouraged to interact with each other publicly and privately to help govern and regulate RIOC. Board members should not aggregate in a number that constitutes a quorum as defined in NY state laws in a non-public meeting. According to NY state law and our by-laws, "A quorum is a majority of the full membership of the board, including any absences or vacancies.”
Proposed resolution #2:
Recently, the chair of this board appointed Howard Polivy to be part of the interim leadership team. To my understanding, board members must be independent, and as the chair of this board mentioned in prior emails, board members should not be involved in operational matters nor act on behalf of the full board. Furthermore, his involvement and decisions have not been coordinated with this oversight board, nor has he updated us on his activities.
As such, I recommend a resolution to ratify that individual resident board members should not be officially seated in any other position within RIOC not mentioned in our bylaws that might reduce their capability of maintaining independence or create that appearance as required by our bylaws and the law.
Neither resolution was approved. Resolution #1 was tabled, meaning no vote on the substance of the motion was taken and Resolution #2 was rejected by a 5-4 vote.
Manhattan Community Board 8 (CB8) Roosevelt Island Committee
Chair Paul Krikler moderated an interesting
Zoom meeting
last night with Roosevelt Island Operating Corp (RIOC) Communications Director Bryant Daniels, NY State Senator
Liz Krueger and NY
State Assembly Member
Rebecca Seawright
talking with residents about a variety of local issues. The meeting began with
Mr Daniels providing a RIOC update and answering questions on the:
RIOC interim leadership changes
- (Deputy General Counsel Gerrald Ellis left RIOC for a job in the private
sector. Acting Chief Operating Officer Mary Cunneen and Associate General
Counsel Lada Stasko will join Chief Financial Officer Dhru Dhruvika on the
interim leadership team),
Red Bus service outages
- Of the 4 Red Buses, 2 buses are currently working on Main Street. 1 Red
Bus is out of service and is expected to be back in service this week
which will restore Octagon Bus Service. The 4th Bus is out of service for
maintenance and no date yet for when it will be fixed. 2 new Red
Buses are on order.
Red Bus Real Time Schedule Tracking service will be working soon and
integrated in
NY Transit app
as well as the soon to launch Roosevelt Island
Citizens Project platform.
Weekend Volleyball Players
at Firefighters Field taking over entire area with no room for others to
use the field - RIOC is aware of issue and will look more into it.
NY State Senator Krueger and Assembly Member Seawright then discussed Roosevelt
Island governance issues including:
According to Ms Krueger, any Governor is unlikely to give up the power to
appoint RIOC Directors by way of a direct election. Ms Seawight said that
Mayor Adams has agreed to use direct elections for appointment of the two
Mayoral appointments to the RIOC Board.
Governor Hochul has previously vetoed legislation requiring residency for
RIOC President and for resident
Board members who move away
from Roosevelt Island.
Watch the very interesting discussion on these issues.
CB 8 Roosevelt Island Committee meeting are scheduled for the first
Monday of every month except August. The
next meeting will be on September 9.
You're invited to attend, share your thoughts and ask questions.
sent the following message to RIOC employees this afternoon.
To my fellow RIOC employees,
It is with mixed emotions that I write to you today to share some personal news. I have accepted a position as in-house counsel at an affordable housing developer here in NYC, and I will be leaving RIOC at the end of the month. My last day will be Friday, June 28th.
It has been the honor of a lifetime to serve in the interim leadership role since January and to be at least partially entrusted with the stewardship of the unique gem that is Roosevelt Island. Our work continues, both for this month while it remains ours together, and into the future once I am gone. I leave content, however, knowing that the work lies in good hands with you all, the incredible team who make this island function, who keep it clean and orderly, who come in day in and day out, rain or shine, to do your jobs and to make this island the beautiful, tranquil oasis it is.
I also leave content in the hope that I have left the island and our institution at least slightly better than when I first arrived. But even if that is true, it is you all that I must thank for it. The employees of RIOC are the backbone of this organization—from the Youth Center to PSD to the grounds crew to the maintenance staff to Sportspark, the bus fleet, and then all the administrative staff—it is you all who have kept the RIOC ship steady over these last few months and for that I am forever grateful.
And so, I thank you all for your efforts and I wish you all the best in life and your future endeavors. Roosevelt Island and the community here are better because of you and your work. Always remember that.
My best to you all,
Upon learning Mr Ellis was leaving RIOC, I asked him and the RIOC Board of Directors:
I understand that you are leaving RIOC at the end of the month.
First, thank you very much for your service to Roosevelt Island. I believe that over the last 6 months, you and the RIOC Interim Leadership team have done an outstanding job and you will be missed.
Does your departure have anything to do with the Haynes/Robinson lawsuit? Will either of them be returning to RIOC?
Who will be in charge of RIOC?
Is there any statement from the RIOC Board?
Any statement from Gerrald?
Will update when more information becomes available.
This morning, Mr Ellis spoke at the raising of the Roosevelt Island Pride Flag.
This evening Mr Ellis discussed an extension of the Roosevelt Island Master Ground Lease between New York City and State during the Community Board 8 Roosevelt Island committee meeting.
The departure of Mr Ellis from RIOC is big loss for Roosevelt Island. As part of the Interim Leadership team he has brought competency to RIOC management and real engagement with the Roosevelt Island community. The RIOC Board and NY State should try and persuade him to stay.
Stay tuned for more.
UPDATE 6/4 - RIOC Board Member Ben Fhala replies:
Of course, I will refrain from delving into the details due to the litigation and out of respect for Gerrald to narrate what he wants and can make public.
I was deeply saddened to hear that Gerrald decided to step down from the interim leadership position. Since the junior board members joined, he has been a welcoming figure in an incredibly hostile environment. Throughout our many long talks during this journey of reestablishing governance on this island, he was a voice of calm and reason. He worked behind the scenes to enable, inform, and support this new board's mission to create structures that support the incredibly important work we have been tasked with.
In the very first board meeting, he welcomed the new board members and urged us to reach out to him for any need, reminding us that he has fiduciary duties to us and will always be available. Not long after that meeting, the executive team set a directive to prevent open communications with the board members. Yet, at great personal risk, Gerald kept the dialogue with all board members who wished to remain informed.
He did his best to mediate between the senior board members and the junior board members, between the executive team and the board, and even between NY State Homes & Community Renewal (HCR), the Governor's Executive Chambers, and this board. His dedication and personal sacrifices throughout the last year have made him the most ideal candidate to assume the position of CEO. Unfortunately, due to reasons I cannot elaborate on, his nomination was blocked and delayed. Although he was appointed to the interim leadership team without the support required to operate fully, he helped bridge the gap that had formed between the community and the organization created to serve it. He is still working tirelessly to bridge the facets of this board and its oversight.
Simply put, this community and the resident board members will forever be in his debt for putting the needs of the public and this board ahead of all others. While the upcoming future remains unknown, his leadership and advocacy have left us in a much better place than we would have been. I will miss the topics we agreed on and the ones we had open heated debates over, and I know I made a friend for life.
Thanks,
Ben Fhala*
Junior (Resident) Board Member
*Disclaimer: All statements made by Ben Fhala are made in his capacity as a RIOC Resident Board member. He does not represent the entirety of RIOC or the full board but serves as a Resident Board member, offering information to the community and its stakeholders.
Mr Ellis began his presentation with a discussion of:
What It Takes To Run Roosevelt Island,
summarized in the slides below.
Mr Ellis noted that Roosevelt Island:
... is entirely self-financed—we do not receive any supportive
funding from the state.
The majority of our funding comes from our ground rent and commercial
leases.
Mr Ellis took comments and questions from Mr Krikler and other Roosevelt
Island residents.
I asked Mr Ellis:
What are the 3 or 4 most important things on your plate
right now?
Mr Ellis answered:
... That's a tough question. Obviously this interim situation is very
difficult.... There are all kinds of challenges that just flow from that
alone. That's at the top of my list .... There are certain hiring decisions that we cannot or should
not make while we're in this interim position. There are big projects that we
can't explore or don't want to explore while we're in in this position. Basic
day-to-day repairs we're obviously doing and they are big priorities for
us....
... The Master Lease discussions are a major priority right now... An
extension of the Master Lease. We have had conversations with the City of New
York about this but we can't really make progress on those discussions or on
that negotiation until we have more certainty internally about our own
governance structure, about our own direction. There are internal/external all
sorts of things that flow from that one issue that we we don't yet have
permanent leadership...
... We have our next board meeting on the 14th. Maybe there's going to be
some movement there. I'm optimistic but I don't know and I've learned not to
get ahead of myself in hoping or in predicting that anything might or
might not happen at a board meeting....
Mr Ellis also discussed problems with the Red Bus delays, overcrowding on
the Roosevelt Island Tram and expressed a willingness to explore models from other cities that are attempting to manage problems caused by tourist overcrowding.
He reported that in a few weeks there will be a
live traffic camera feed from both the Manhattan and Roosevelt Island Tram
stations available for residents to see how large those line are so you can
make a decision about using the Tram or the subway. Another improvement coming this summer is the Red Bus will have a location tracking system installed so that riders
will know when it will be at any stop.
Here's the full discussion from beginning to end. I highly recommend watching the entire video if you are interested in Roosevelt Island issues and governance.
Great job by Mr Krikler and Mr Ellis. This type of conversation and Roosevelt Island community engagement would not have happened under the prior RIOC administration.
Roosevelt Island revolt, transparency, community engagement and the
recent management turnover
at the Roosevelt Island Operating Corp (RIOC) received some citywide attention today in an excellent article by
The City. The headline read:
Roosevelt Island Revolt: Residents Call for Governance Changes Amid Corporation Chaos
Following the abrupt departures of the last two leaders of the state
authority that runs Roosevelt Island, residents are calling for more of a
say in what goes on in the quiet, mostly residential strip of land on the
East River. https://t.co/WXjk6K0fqv
Click here
for the full Roosevelt Island article from
The City.
Many of the issues reported in
The City article involving Roosevelt Island community engagement and RIOC transparency were
discussed by residents, RIOC Board Directors and the new interim RIOC leadership of Deputy Counsel Gerrald Ellis, Chief Financial Officer Dhru Amin
and Board member Howard Polivy during the February 15 RIOC Real Estate
Development Advisory committee meeting.
During the discussion,
Roosevelt Island Daily
Publisher and frequent RIOC critic David Stone praised the new interim leadership
team but noted:
... One of the things that RIOC has to do is ... we have to have some say of
who the Board Members are. We had elections once with some really good
members ... that were participating and had input. The next time it came
around no elections and Andrew Cuomo just manipulated things to gain
control.
So what RIOC needs to do is guarantee some amount of power to the residents.
You're giving it to us now. It's great of you, but you can go tomorrow and
the Governor can just change the whole things....
.. There a lot of people, including those in this room, and other
people, numerous on this island who have had and do have some
amazing ideas of what we could do with this island...
... We'd like to have the residents have a much bigger voice in how all
that stuff is done. Another way of doing that is to have the
residents have a say on what the direction of RIOC is, therefore have the
vote on the Board. That's why the petition was asking for the residents to
have the chance to vote in the Directors of RIOC.
I understand it's complicated beyond measure with State law. I understand
that the first time all you had to do was throw some tea in the water and
we gave you your freedom. So yes, it may be very difficult
technically, but magically things have a a great way of actually happening
when it's the right thing to do and if people say it loudly enough and
together and I think that's what's going to happen here as well, so I'll
stop making speeches
Here's the discussion.
Mr Stone speaking to the Interim RIOC leadership team also said:
I want to say thank you to you guys and what you're doing especially
Howard.... I appreciate very much what you're doing. It is opening things
up. I hope you stay forever. Nothing"s perfect but it's like walking into a
new found land with you guys. I actually wrote to your Communications
Director and got a response, oh my God...
Former RIOC Board member Margie Smith shares this message she sent to RIOC
Board member Howard Polivy following the REDAC meeting:
I want to congratulate you on last night's meeting. I'm vocal enough when I don't like the way these things are handled, so I want to be just as vocal when they're handled as well as they were last night.
I sincerely hope it will continue this way, and all indications are that it will.
It is the broad consensus of many Roosevelt Island activists that since RIOC
President Shelton Haynes and General Counsel Gretchen Robinson were placed on paid administrative leave last December, pending the latest of many investigations, RIOC has been doing an excellent job under the new interim leadership team of Mr Ellis, Ms Amin and Mr Polivy, together with new RIOC Directors Ben Fhala, Lydia Tang and Dr Michal Melamed.
These are some updates that we would like to provide. The RIOC Interim Leadership Team, Dhru and myself, we're hitting
the ground running and we're working to
maintain the Island's vital services and
to better communicate with the community. That's honestly one of our first
priorities. We've already been at the Operations Committee meeting and Roosevelt Island Historic Society meeting. We also
attended the Community Board 8
Roosevelt Island committee meeting. I
think one of our our first initiatives
is to focus on greater transparency and
collaboration among Island
stakeholders....
And Ms Amin:
Engagement with the
local media. We have reevaluated our
policies on engaging with local media
and are now becoming more responsive to
incoming requests for information and
comment as you've seen over the past few days. We believe this greater level of
openness will help keep Island
residents informed of our initiatives
and operations while also fostering
better RIOC community
relations....
Mr Ellis also described tours of Island operations and infrastructure with RIOC Board members among other items.
Following the Interim Leadership Report, RIOC Director Lydia Tang spoke about problems working with RIOC President Shelton Haynes and General Counsel Gretchen Robinson currently on paid administrative leave pending an investigation of them about workplace concerns raised by RIOC employees. According to Ms Tang:
As newly appointed resident board members, endorsed by elected officials and appointed by Governor Hochul, we bear the responsibility of overseeing RIOC's audit, budget, operations, and governance. It's crucial to counter some unfounded claims by Shelton and Gretchen, which tarnish the reputation of myself and Ben Fhala.
Systematic denial of basic access for oversight persisted for over seven months.
Despite six months of requesting a comprehensive Operations Tour, per ABO recommendations, it was only arranged after Shelton and Gretchen were placed on leave. Gratitude to Gerrald, Dhru, and Mary for the tour, with plans for Dr. Melamed and Mr. Fhala's tours.
Upon joining the Board, I approached Shelton and Gretchen positively, expressing empathy for Shelton's family crisis. Suggestions to "work smarter" were offered, advocating delegation and embracing the "new normal" of new Board Members. If my phone conversation were recorded, it would confirm Shelton stating that Gretchen acknowledged my voice of reason. Assuming antagonism hindered information gathering for our fiduciary roles, echoing the adage: "When you assume, you make an 'ass' of 'u' and 'me.'"
Flouting dysfunctional norms, I urged executive responsiveness to board inquiries. Months of Gretchen issuing advisories against responding to board emails, and delays in answers reveal dysfunction at RIOC, necessitating renewed inquiries.
In response to staff reports, we investigated a procurement contract. Information requests on executive team members aimed to address community concerns went unanswered. Salary requests sought to verify or refute an 18% raise allegation, and requests for work/paid-time details for the entire executive team echoed community and internal whistleblower concerns, all with unanswered queries indicating a potential cover-up and a clear disregard for our oversight responsibilities.
Meetings with staff sought answers to fiduciary oversight concerns. Despite positive interactions, such instances were negatively spun. Interactions with staff were restricted, assuming ill intent, obstructing fiduciary roles. This assumption manipulated the board, allowing the executive team to overstep their authority. Our plans involve addressing RIOC dysfunctions with a renewed focus on fiduciary oversight inquiries. We remain dedicated to providing necessary oversight over RIOC and its audit, budget, operations, and governance.
Here's the February 1 RIOC Interim Leadership Report and statement by RIOC Director Lydia Tang.
... It is unclear how long the new interim RIOC leadership will remain in place,
how long the review of Mr Haynes and Ms Robinson's workplace conduct will take
and if they will return to their positions as President/CEO and General
Counsel respectively.
But, Mr Haynes and Ms Robinson are attempting to stop the review of their
workplace conduct and demand to be restored to their positions at RIOC.
On January 23, Mr Haynes and Ms Robinson filed an
Order To Show Cause
in the US District Court for the Southern District Of NY seeking a Temporary
Restraining Order and Preliminary Injunction:...
The Temporary Restraining Order and Preliminary injunction sought by Mr Haynes and Ms Robinson seeks to stop any investigation of them and restore them to their positions.
Though not named as defendants in the lawsuit, Mr Haynes and Ms Robinson
claim in their lawsuit that NY State Senator
Liz Krueger,
NY State Assembly Member
Rebecca Seawright
and
Roosevelt Island Daily
publisher David Stone contributed to a "racist backlash" against them.
The lawsuit also claims that Mr Haynes and Ms Robinson were excluded from
the appointment process of 3 new RIOC Board Members in an attempt to
undermine their authority and "ability to discharge their job functions."
Haynes and Robinson claim the 3 new RIOC board members are antagonistic to
them...
Reported on January 29 that the preliminary injunction hearing is scheduled for February 9 at 10:30 a.m.
Stay tuned. More to come.
UPDATE 2/9 - The scheduled hearing for February 9 on the Order to Show Cause has been postponed. A new judge was assigned to the case. No new date assigned yet.
According to the Feb 8 case filing:
NOTICE OF CASE REASSIGNMENT to Judge Analisa Torres. Judge Katherine Polk Failla is no longer assigned to the case. (tro)
... The Roosevelt Island Operating Corporation (RIOC) Board of Directors
received notice of several employee concerns about the RIOC workplace. The
Board has determined that it is necessary to conduct a review of these
concerns by way of an outside professional. During this review, Shelton
Haynes (RIOC CEO) and Gretchen Robinson (RIOC General Counsel) will be
placed on administrative paid leave.
During this period of review, the day-to-day operations of RIOC will be
overseen by an interim leadership team that includes Dhruvika Patel Amin
(RIOC’s Chief Financial Officer & Vice President) and Gerrald Ellis
(RIOC’s Assistant Vice President & Deputy General Counsel). In addition,
RIOC Board member and Audit Committee Chair, Howard Polivy, will serve as a
dedicated Board member liaison and will provide additional support to the
interim leadership. No further comments about this matter will be made by the
RIOC Board until the review is completed. We thank all of our RIOC staff for
your full cooperation and support during this period of time.
... Ms Amin and Mr Ellis also participated in a frank and open
discussion with Roosevelt Island residents, Board Directors and local media
during an informal meeting organized by RIOC Director Ben Fhala which took
place immediately after a
contentious RIOC Operations Committee meeting on January 17. {link added}
It was a very productive meeting and an example of positive community
engagement by RIOC, a welcome change from the previous administration under
Shelton Haynes.
Community Board 8 Roosevelt Island committee chair Paul Krikler noted after a
January 18 meeting of his committee with
residents and the new RIOC leadership:
Yesterday we had a very positive meeting with RIOC leadership. I think it's
fair to say that this marked the start of a reset of the relationship between
residents and RIOC.
It is unclear how long the new interim RIOC leadership will remain in place,
how long the review of Mr Haynes and Ms Robinson's workplace conduct will take
and if they will return to their positions as President/CEO and General
Counsel respectively.
But, Mr Haynes and Ms Robinson are attempting to stop the review of their
workplace conduct and demand to be restored to their positions at RIOC.
On January 23, Mr Haynes and Ms Robinson filed an
Order To Show Cause
in the US District Court for the Southern District Of NY seeking a Temporary
Restraining Order and Preliminary Injunction:
(a) Enjoining Defendants and any persons or entities acting in concert with
or on behalf of Defendants from initiating an investigation into or
disciplinary proceedings against or taking adverse employment actions
against Haynes;
(b) Enjoining Defendants and any persons or entities acting in concert with
or on behalf of Defendants from initiating an investigation into or
disciplinary proceedings against or taking adverse employment actions
against Robinson;
(c) Directing Defendants to restore Haynes to his position as CEO and
President of the Roosevelt Island Operating Corporation (“RIOC”); and
(d) Directing Defendants to restore Robinson to her position as Vice
President and General Counsel of RIOC,...
According to Mr Haynes' January 23
affidavit
in support of the Order To Show Cause:
... 45. On or about the morning of January 16, 2024, Ms. Visnauskas and Mr.
Polivy informed me that, effective immediately, I would be placed on paid
administrative leave.
46. During this meeting, I was told that the RIOC Board had received
complaints from at least five staff members about me and the administration,
alleging a toxic work environment. I was told the Board determined that it
was necessary to investigate these concerns and to put me on leave pending
that investigation. When I noted that Mr. Fhala and others had been
harassing and interfering with my work and the work of the RIOC
administration, Ms. Visnauskas said there was no recourse.
47. According to outside counsel for the Board, the five employee complaints
were submitted sometime after my counsel provided revisions to the proposed
Protocols, and after Ms. Robinson and I filed our amended complaint.
48. This is the first time I have ever been placed on administrative leave
as a result of an investigation. In my tenure as CEO and President of RIOC,
I have faced twelve other investigations—none of which have resulted in any
findings of wrongdoing—but I was never put on leave....
Ms Visnauskas is the Chair of the
RIOC Board of Directors
and Commissioner of NY State Division of Homes and Community Renewal. Mr
Polivy is a long time member of the RIOC Board of Directors.
28 ... Mr. Fhala, Ms. Tang, and others have continued to harass and
excessively scrutinize me and Ms. Robinson by, among other things, initiating
a new,unwarranted investigation into a procurement contract, attempting to
limit our authority, conducting pretextual reviews of our confidential payroll
records, and making critical statements about us to the already hostile media.
29. Within one week after Ms. Robinson and I initiated the Federal Lawsuit,
Mr. Fhala sought an “emergency” Board meeting to reduce my monetary approval
thresholds by nearly 50%. Specifically, Mr. Fhala wanted to reduce the
amount of funds I was authorized to spend without pre-approval by the Board
from $175,000 to $90,000—a substantial reduction that would significantly
curtail my ability to run day-to-day operations.
30. Shortly thereafter, Ms. Tang requested an accounting of my time worked,
leave requested, and salary since my appointment to the position of acting
CEO. Ms. Tang did not need my confidential time and leave records to
complete her duties as a Board member. Instead, I believe she requested
those records to try to “find” issues with my work history.
31. As another example, approximately one week after Ms. Robinson and I
initiated the Federal Lawsuit, Mr. Fhala, along with Ms. Tang, met with Mr.
Ellis, without our knowledge. I believe this meeting was conducted at the
behest of Mr. Fhala and Ms. Tang for the purpose of obtaining information
that could be used against me and Ms. Robinson.
32. Shortly after this meeting, Mr. Ellis requested access to RIOC’s email
search systems, under the pretense of needing access to obtain information
for certain legal work. In reality, Mr. Ellis used the access he was given
to search through mine and Ms. Robinson’s emails. I believe Mr. Ellis
searched through our past emails on multiple occasions, from on or about
September 26, 2023, to on or about October 20, 2023, to try to search for
information to be used against us. There was no valid reason for Mr. Ellis
to surreptitiously search through our emails.
33. On a separate occasion, Mr. Fhala emailed both the NYSIG and the COELIG
to suggest that our procurement of a contract with a digital reputation
management company was somehow improper. The contract had been entered into
approximately one year earlier—well before Mr. Fhala joined the RIOC
Board—to try to counter the negative impacts on RIOC and its staff created
by the onslaught of unfavorable press. Moreover, there was nothing improper
about the contract: it had gone through a public procurement process based
on responses to a public Request for Proposals. RIOC’s comptroller, director
of procurement, IT director, and legal staff were all aware of and/or
involved in the procurement process. Before the contract was signed, Mr.
Polivy had even encouraged Ms. Robinson and me to counterbalance the
negative press with positive stories. Ms. Christian and Mr. Kraut encouraged
us after the contract was signed. Moreover, the Battery Park City
Authority—RIOC’s sister agency for Battery Park City—had entered into a
similar contract with a similar media firm that has conducted similar work
and no questions had been raised about the propriety of that contract.
Despite this background establishing the propriety of the contract, Mr.
Fhala has attempted to raise suspicions about the contract and used it to
attempt to initiate yet another frivolous investigation into me and Ms.
Robinson. Neither the Chamber nor anyone at RIOC ever took any action to
counter Mr. Fhala’s conduct....
39. Mr. Fhala has also repeatedly “scolded” Ms. Robinson and me and spoken
to us in a condescending, derogatory manner. For example, at a Board meeting
on or about September 14, 2023, Mr. Fhala condescendingly told me and Ms.
Robinson, “May I remind you that you report to us?” He has also written
similar things in emails to us.
43. On or about January 2, 2024, I met with Ms. Christian. She informed me
that she learned that a few days prior to our meeting, Dhruvika Patel Amin
(the current CFO& Vice President) was having trouble accessing
information for the Board regarding confidential overtime records for RIOC
employees. Ms. Christian believed that Ms. Amin was attempting to see if I
received overtime pay during my time as CEO and President (such pay is not
permitted).
44. Also on or about January 2, 2024, I spoke with Mr. Ekpo. He confirmed
his belief that the allegations in the amended complaint are 100 percent
accurate. He also confirmed that Ms. Lopez had instructed Mr. Miskiewicz to
remove observations of racism that were in the first draft of the report...
... 50. I am aware of numerous RIOC staff members and employees who are
terrified about their job security and career opportunities given
Defendants’ unreasonable and targeted treatment of me and Ms. Robinson
following our complaints of discrimination and retaliation....
Though not named as defendants in the lawsuit, Mr Haynes and Ms Robinson
claim in their lawsuit that NY State Senator
Liz Krueger,
NY State Assembly Member
Rebecca Seawright
and
Roosevelt Island Daily
publisher David Stone contributed to a "racist backlash" against them.
The lawsuit also claims that Mr Haynes and Ms Robinson were excluded from
the appointment process of 3 new RIOC Board Members in an attempt to
undermine their authority and "ability to discharge their job functions."
Haynes and Robinson claim the 3 new RIOC board members are antagonistic to
them...
... proceedings held before Judge Katherine Polk Failla: Telephone Conference
held on 1/26/2024. Attorneys Milton L. Williams, Jr. and Jeffrey C. Skinner
representing Plaintiffs present. Attorneys Alan Schoenfeld and Thais R.
Ridgeway representing Executive Chamber Defendants present. Attorney Scott
Todd Baken representing Defendant RIOC. Defendants' opposition to Plaintiffs'
motion for a preliminary injunction is due by 2/5/2024; Plaintiffs' reply is
due by 2/7/2024, 12:00 p.m. Plaintiffs' Second Amended Complaint is due by
1/31/2024; Defendants' time to answer the second amended complaint is stayed
pending further order of the Court. A preliminary injunction hearing is
scheduled for 2/9/2024 at 10:30 a.m.
The Roosevelt Island Operating Corporation (RIOC) Board of Directors
received notice of several employee concerns about the RIOC workplace. The
Board has determined that it is necessary to conduct a review of these
concerns by way of an outside professional. During this review, Shelton
Haynes (RIOC CEO) and Gretchen Robinson (RIOC General Counsel) will be
placed on administrative paid leave.
During this period of review, the day-to-day operations of RIOC will be
overseen by an interim leadership team that includes Dhruvika Patel Amin
(RIOC’s Chief Financial Officer & Vice President) and Gerrald Ellis
(RIOC’s Assistant Vice President & Deputy General Counsel). In addition,
RIOC Board member and Audit Committee Chair, Howard Polivy, will serve as a
dedicated Board member liaison and will provide additional support to the
interim leadership. No further comments about this matter will be made by
the RIOC Board until the review is completed. We thank all of our RIOC staff
for your full cooperation and support during this period of time.
The RIOC interim leadership team of Chief Financial Officer (CFO)
Dhruvika Patel Amin
and Assistant Vice President (AVP) & Deputy General Counsel
Gerrald Ellis, together with Communications Director Bryant Daniels, participated in the
January 18 Community Board 8 (CB8)
Roosevelt Island Committee meeting
last evening chaired by Roosevelt Island resident Paul Krikler.
Ms Amin and Mr Ellis introduced themselves and provided some personal
background information during the meeting. According to Ms Amin:
I am the CFO and VP of RIOC. I joined in September 2023...
... My background is in financial and operational management. I've been
responsible for accounting, tax, audit, human resources administration,
investment reporting matters and charitable philanthropic affairs.
I grew up in Queens and always thought of Roosevelt Island as a green space
surrounded by water that provides peace and tranquility and beautiful views.
I chose to work at RIOC for these reasons in addition to giving back to the
community, to work with the public and be a part of the corporation's
mission. I hope to bridge the gap between RIOC and the public.
I hope to learn a lot from this meeting. Just know that RIOC is under new
leadership and we're more solutions oriented. If you reach out to us, you
will definetely receive a response. I hope to work with you very closely to
meet our objectives.
According to Mr Ellis:
I am the Deputy General Counsel of RIOC.
... I live in Astoria, right over the Bridge. It's a half hour walk over the
Bridge. I have a background in affordable housing....
The things that drew me to Roosevelt Island?
I have a long connection professionally with Roosevelt Island. I worked on
the financing of Riverwalk 8. I used to work with Related Management Company
and briefly worked on the lease of Riverwalk 7.
I would come to Roosevelt Island a lot to ride a bike. It's a great place to
ride a bike. There's not a lot of cars and it's beautiful.
I honestly believe in good government... and believe in the mission of it.
That's what attracted me to Roosevelt Island...
The onus is on RIOC to be out there and to be available. I understand
that. There's been many years of tension building up. I understand we need
to be the party to break the ice and to be out there and be available to you
all. You'll see us on the Island, out and about. Please stop me and tell me
your thoughts about everything
I'm genuinely curious to hear people's opinions, complaints and suggestions.
I really am....
Meet the new interim RIOC leadership team of Ms Amin and Mr Ellis.
Click on the beginning of the video to watch the Community Board 8 Roosevelt
Island Committee full discussion of a variety of local issues including the
Tram and Red Bus.
CB 8 Chair Paul Krikler remarked today:
Yesterday we had a very positive meeting with RIOC leadership. I think it's
fair to say that this marked the start of a reset of the relationship between
residents and RIOC.
Mr Krikler is also the
organizer of the petition drive
started last October under the prior RIOC administration that called for the
election of RIOC Directors and:
Based upon the last few days, it appears Mr Krikler's petition request
for a functioning and competent RIOC is off to a good start.
Ms Amin and Mr Ellis also participated in a frank and open discussion with
Roosevelt Island residents, Board Directors and local media during an informal
meeting organized by RIOC Director Ben Fhala which took place immediately after
a contentious RIOC Operations Committee meeting on January 17.
It was a very productive meeting and an example of positive community
engagement by RIOC, a welcome change from the previous administration under
Shelton Haynes.
Watch what happened.
Immediately before this informal meeting, the RIOC Board Of Directors
Operations Advisory Committee (OAC)
met for the first time since Jun 2021. OAC Chair Fay Christian immediately made it clear at the
beginning of the meeting that no questions would be taken from RIOC Directors
who were not members of the Operations Committee nor from any residents
attending the meeting. Ms Christian emphasized that only OAC committee members
could ask questions during presentations by RIOC department staffers.
RIOC Board Director Ben Fhala, who is not a member of the OAC, tried several times to ask questions and
participate in the meeting but was refused participation by Ms
Christian.
I asked Ms Christian why she was not allowing questions from anyone other than
the Committee members pointing out to her that in the past it was a common
practice for anyone attending RIOC Committee meetings to ask questions or
comment. Ms Christian responded that was true if the Committee chose to do so
but for today she chooses not to.
Watch what happened.
At the end of the Operations Committee meeting, Ms Christian and Mr Ellis
appeared to suggest the next meeting would return to the practice of allowing
questions and comments from non committee members.
It's a good start for the new interim RIOC leadership.
Roosevelt Island is a mixed income, racially diverse waterfront community situated in the East River of New York City between Manhattan and Queens and is jurisdictionally part of Manhattan. The Roosevelt Island Tramway, which connects Roosevelt Island to the rest of Manhattan, has become the iconic symbol of Roosevelt Island to its residents.
The Purpose of this Blog is to provide accurate and timely information about Roosevelt Island as well as a forum for residents to express opinions and engage in a dialogue to improve our community.