Showing posts with label lawsuit. Show all posts
Showing posts with label lawsuit. Show all posts

Monday, October 2, 2023

Who's In Charge Of Dysfunctional Roosevelt Island Operating Corp? RIOC President Shelton Haynes Tells RIOC Board Directors Not To Communicate With Staff And Staff Not To Talk With RIOC Board Directors

As reported September 16, Roosevelt Island Operating Corp (RIOC) President Shelton Haynes and General Counsel Gretchen Robinson:

... filed a racial discrimination lawsuit in the Southern District Of NY against members of NY State Governor Kathy Hochul's Executive Chamber as well as the Commissioner, General Counsel and Deputy Counsel of the NY State Division of Homes and Community Renewal.

Though not named as defendants in the lawsuit, Mr Haynes and Ms Robinson claim in their lawsuit that NY State Senator Liz Krueger, NY State Assembly Member Rebecca Seawright and Roosevelt Island Daily publisher David Stone contributed to a "racist backlash" against them.

The lawsuit also claims that Mr Haynes and Ms Robinson were excluded from the appointment process of 3 new RIOC Board Members in an attempt to undermine their authority and "ability to discharge their job functions." Haynes and Robinson claim the 3 new RIOC board members are antagonistic to them.

According to the Haynes/Robinson lawsuit:

This is a case about how the Executive Chamber for the Office of the Governor of New York (the “Chamber”) and the Roosevelt Island Operating Corporation (“RIOC”) have unfairly subjected Shelton J. Haynes and Gretchen K. Robinson (“Robinson,” and together with Haynes, the “Plaintiffs”), two African American executives, to continuous and pervasive discrimination by, including but not limited to, subjecting Haynes and Robinson to frequent unwarranted investigations by the New York State Inspector General (“NYSIG”) as well as ordering an independent investigation by an outside counsel – something not done for other, more serious allegations – based entirely on specious allegations of wrongdoing. The Chamber did so while simultaneously thwarting Haynes’s and Robinson’s efforts to fight back against the discrimination and defend themselves and RIOC against a multitude of defamatory statements made by a local blogger and a group of disgruntled former employees....

On September 18, I sent an email inquiry to Mr Haynes, Ms Robinson and the RIOC Directors asking for comment on the lawsuit and who was currently in charge of RIOC.

There was no response. 

I followed up on September 27 to Mr Haynes, Ms Robinson and the RIOC Directors with a second email inquiry asking:

It has been almost 2 weeks since RIOC President Shelton Haynes and General Counsel Gretchen Robinson filed a racial discrimination lawsuit on September 12 in the Southern District of NY against members of Governor Hochul’s Executive Chamber as well as the Commissioner and certain staffers of NY State Division of Homes and Community Renewal.

Also, it has been almost 2 weeks since Ms Robinson announced at the September 14 RIOC Board meeting that Mr Haynes was on a "leave of absence.

To date, RIOC has made no announcement to the Roosevelt Island community regarding who is in charge of RIOC. Is there an Acting RIOC President?

I am following up on the September 18 email below seeking comment from you on the Haynes/Robinson lawsuit.

Specifically:

1- What is the reason for Mr Haynes extended leave and who is now in charge of Rioc as the President/CEO?

2- Will the Rioc Board allow Mr Haynes and Ms Robertson to remain in their current positions following the filing of their lawsuit?

3- Mr Haynes and Ms Robinson allege in the lawsuit that one white RIOC Board member told the lead attorney investigating Mr Haynes that " they need to end this f****** racist witch hunt now" and "Shelton Haynes is the best executive of RIOC so far" Will the RIOC Director who said this confirm the accuracy of the statement and identify themselves to the public?

4 - Do any of the RIOC Directors have a comment to the Roosevelt Island community on this matter?

5 - Will Mr Haynes and/or Ms Robinson comment on this matter.

These questions are of great concern to the Roosevelt Island community and are in preparation for an upcoming Roosevelt Islander Online article....

Recently appointed RIOC Board Member Ben Fhala replied on September 27:

Dear Rick and our fellow community members,

On August 31st, Shelton Haynes informed the oversight board of his temporary leave, set to conclude on October 4th, with a request for privacy on the matter. As Gretchen conveyed this in a board meeting, I won't delve further into the details than she did.

Since then, our Chair, HCR, hasn't officially updated us on the interim leadership, but my understanding is that Gretchen Robinson is assuming the role. Regrettably, no formal communication has been disseminated to staff nor Resident board members regarding this transition.

The lawsuit has cast a shadow over our communications and reduced interactions among board members. New Resident board members like myself have not received guidance from the Chair nor her delegates on this matter.

Despite this cloud, we remain dedicated to RIOC and our community's welfare. Unfortunately, the dysfunction in RIOC's communications has led us to seek external help to address community needs.

Recently, I learned of a disabled community member unable to commute to work due to non-functional ramps on 3 out of 4 of the currently working red buses. This is distressing, yet I find it challenging to engage with RIOCs leadership. Unofficially, I understand that the executive team has instructed staff to "ignore" communications from new Resident board members, a directive officially confirmed on 08/31 by Aida Morales.

I'm grateful to have been seated on the board alongside Lydia Tang and Dr. Melamed, who have consistently maintained open communication channels and have been strong advocates for the community and our stakeholders.

Nonetheless, we, the newly seated resident board members, are committed to overseeing RIOC's operations and eagerly anticipate joining committee work. In the interim, we will address issues one by one by engaging with stakeholders in the community and within RIOC.

Thank you,

Ben Fhala Resident Board Member

Mr Fhala added on September 28:

I have a small correction to make. Lydia Tang and I recently took the red bus to conduct a brief tour of Sportspark with the intention of saying hello to the communications team and the HR team located there. Unfortunately, we were greeted by Aida Morales, who once again reminded us that we are not permitted to engage with staff members without prior approval from Shelton Haynes. Akeem Jamal joined to let us know that he needs to get approval from Shelton prior to speaking with us as well. The HR team on site were forbidden to come out and say hello.

The primary responsibility of the board is to provide the vision and guidance necessary for the authority to fulfill its mission and meet its ethical and legal obligations. It is essential for board members to have a deep understanding of the authority's purpose and operations. However, it seems that direct communication with team members or participation in committees is not the preferred method, but rather through newsletter updates.

Regarding the correction, I'd like to note that both buses we took had active and working ramps. I will need to follow up with the disabled member to determine if the issue persists and if it is isolated to a specific bus or schedule. Unfortunately, I currently lack a direct point of contact within the team for operational updates and questions.

There was no response from Mr Haynes, Ms Robinson or other RIOC Board members.

On September 28, I asked NY State Senator Liz Krueger if she has::

...any comment on the current situation at RIOC where Board Directors she recommended are not allowed to provide oversight of RIOC by communicating with RIOC staff?

and

NY State Assembly Member Rebecca Seawright:

Do you have any comment on the current situation at RIOC where Board Directors are not allowed to provide oversight of RIOC by communicating with RIOC staff? Do you know who is in charge of RIOC at this time?

Have not received a reply yet from Ms Krueger or Seawright.

As reported September 18:

... During the September 14 Roosevelt Island Operating Corp (RIOC) Board of Directors meeting Public Session, several residents spoke up sharing their concerns, ideas and solutions with the RIOC Board. Unfortunately, every time newly appointed Board Member Ben Fhala tried to respond to a question or concern from a resident, RIOC General Counsel Gretchen Robinson and Board Chair Diana Lopez did their utmost to try and shut him up, but Mr Fhala persisted.

Here's what happened.

Also, as Mr Fhala was trying to respond to the concerns of a late night health care worker describing having to sleep overnight because of no subway or tram service, Ms Robinson said he was speaking: 

... as a resident of the Island and not a member of the board.

Mr Fhala responded he was speaking as a board member....

  

It's interesting to note that Ms Lopez, who is the RIOC Board Chair designee of the NY State Homes and Community Renewal (DHCR) Commissioner RuthAnne Visnauskas, is one of the defendants in the racial discrimination lawsuit brought by Mr Haynes and Ms Robinson.

Also, during the September 14 RIOC Board meeting, RIOC Board members Ben Fhala and Lydia Tang expressed frustration at not being allowed to speak with RIOC staff about issues that the Board is supposed to provide oversight on.

Mr Fhala asked to postpone ratifying an agenda item contract until he could talk with staff members about the item. He explained that since he was not allowed to speak with staff, the Board meeting was the only opportunity to have his questions answered.

Ms Lopez and Ms Robinson objected to postponing the agenda item. Ms Lopez said that RIOC Board members should focus on policy and strategy and defer to RIOC staff on day to day management issues.

Mr Fhala's request to speak with RIOC staff about contract ratification issues is not at all unusual and it has been a common occurrence at almost all RIOC Board Meetings for Directors to ask questions of RIOC staff about proposed contracts as well as other items they are responsible for. Also, RIOC Directors speaking with RIOC staff about day to day management issues has been a common practice for many years until Mr Haynes became RIOC President.

Here's what happened.

Paul Krikler is one of the Roosevelt Island residents who spoke at the RIOC Board September 14 Public Session. Mr. Krikler shares this message he sent to the RIOC Board:

Dear RIOC Board:

We have been through four weeks now of the F Train Rehab Project. During this time the community on Roosevelt Island has come together to help us all deal with the impact of this necessary work on our transit.

It's been very heartening to see the involvement and active engagement from the new Resident Board members, particularly Ben Fhala. It's good to see resident Board members working with the community at a time like this, including participating in public meetings.

Praise where it's due.

Read the full Haynes/Robinson lawsuit here.

Stay tuned for updates.

Saturday, September 16, 2023

RIOC President And General Counsel File Racial Discrimination Lawsuit Against Members Of NY Governor Kathy Hochul's Executive Chamber, DHCR Commissioner And Staff - Charge Local Elected Officials Krueger, Seawright & RI Daily With Contributing To Racist Backlash And New RIOC Directors Are Antagonistic

Roosevelt Island Operating Corp (RIOC) President Shelton Haynes has been absent from several recent events he would be expected to attend including the September 14 RIOC Board Of Directors meeting. 

During last Thursday's RIOC Board meeting, RIOC General Counsel Gretchen Robinson read out loud the written President's Report submitted by the missing Mr Haynes. According to Ms Robinson:

... This is from Shelton. A message from him, who is out sick unfortunately on extended leave...

Mr Haynes may be on extended leave for a while. 

On September 12, two days before Ms Robinson read the President's Report, both Mr Haynes and Ms Robinson filed a racial discrimination lawsuit in the Southern District Of NY against members of NY State Governor Kathy Hochul's Executive Chamber as well as the Commissioner, General Counsel and Deputy Counsel of the NY State Division of Homes and Community Renewal.

Though not named as defendants in the lawsuit, Mr Haynes and Ms Robinson claim in their lawsuit that NY State Senator Liz Krueger, NY State Assembly Member Rebecca Seawright and Roosevelt Island Daily publisher David Stone contributed to a "racist backlash" against them.

The lawsuit also claims that Mr Haynes and Ms Robinson were excluded from the appointment process of 3 new RIOC Board Members in an attempt to undermine their authority and "ability to discharge their job functions." Haynes and Robinson claim the 3 new RIOC board members are antagonistic to them.

Read the full lawsuit complaint.

During the September 14 RIOC Board meeting plantiff Gretchen Robinson was sitting next to and interacting with defendant Diana Lopez as shown in the video above. Also following the meeting, Ms Robinson was seen in a several minutes long discussion with defendants Diana Lopez and Allejandro Valella as well as RIOC Board Member Howard Polivy.

On September 15, RIOC released an internal investigation into allegations of improprieties made against Mr Haynes. Here are the findings.

 According to Mr Haynes:

 Apparently the Tweet was deleted. Here's a screenshot.

This story is still developing. Stay tune.

Monday, August 7, 2023

Unexpected Roosevelt Island Operating Corp Board Directors "Special" Meeting Held Today In Executive Session Closed To The Public - What's Going On?

The Roosevelt Island Operating Corp (RIOC) Directors do not usually hold full Board meetings during the summer and before last week the next meeting was not scheduled until September 14. But something happened recently which caused the RIOC Board to schedule a "Special" meeting today.

The meeting is in executive session which means that it is being held in secret, closed to the community and media. As of now, any specifics about today's RIOC Board meeting are not known publicly.

Among the two agenda items is:

... proposed, pending or current litigation;..
The use of the word "proposed" may be telling because in the past, RIOC Board executive sessions involving litigation were about "pending or current litigation". I do not recall a previous meeting involving "proposed" litigation.

Here's the agenda for today's RIOC Board meeting. to RIOC:

NOTICE OF THE AUGUST 7, 2023 SPECIAL MEETING OF THE ROOSEVELT ISLAND OPERATING CORPORATION BOARD OF DIRECTORS

PLEASE TAKE NOTICE that a special meeting of the RIOC Board of Directors will be held on Monday, August 7, 2023 at 5:30 p.m. at the Good Shepherd Community Center, 543 Main Street, Roosevelt Island, New York 10044.

AGENDA:

1. Call to Order

2. Roll Call

3. Chair’s Motion for Executive Session to Discuss:

a. proposed, pending or current litigation; and

b. the medical, financial, credit or employment history of a particular person or corporation, or matters leading to the appointment, employment, promotion, demotion, discipline, suspension, dismissal or removal of a particular person or corporation.

4. Adjournment

Is there some "proposed" litigation involving RIOC being discussed by the Board Directors today?

Proposed by whom? 

And does the agenda item 3 (a) "proposed" litigation have anything to do with agenda item 3(b)?

What could this be? 

Stay tune.

Wednesday, June 28, 2023

3 New Roosevelt Island Residents Joining RIOC Board Of Directors And Will Be Attending June 29 Board Meeting, Come Ask Your Questions During Public Session - Among Items On Agenda Are Executive Session To Discuss Pending Litigation, But Which One?

The Roosevelt Island Operating Corp (RIOC) Board of Directors will meet in person tomorrow, June 29 at the Cultural Center Theatre (548 Main Street) beginning 5:30 PM. 

As reported June 7, the RIOC Board of Directors will have 3 new members who are residents of Roosevelt Island:

Roosevelt Island Residents Ben Fhala, Michal Melamed And Lydia Tang Appointed To Fill 3 Vacant Seats On The RIOC Board Of Directors - Approved Today By The NY State Senate Finance Committee

Here's Mr Fhala and Dr. Melamed with NY State Senator Liz Krueger at Roosevelt Island Day. 

Mr Fhala has said he:

... Hopes To Bring Change And Fresh Perspective To Roosevelt Island - Goals Include Safeguarding Quality Of Life For All Residents, Managing Impact Of Tourism And Revitalizing Northern Side Of RI Among Others...

Below is the June 29 RIOC Board of Directors Meeting Agenda


 which includes:

Chair’s Motion for Executive Session 

1. Discussion of pending litigation

It is unknown if the pending litigation being discussed by the RIOC Board is concerning:

or something else.

To date, RIOC has not commented publicly on these matters to the Roosevelt Island community.

Executive session means this portion of the meeting will be held in private, excluding the public from attending.

With the appointment of 3 new members, the RIOC Board had a few days of every Director's seat being filled. That only lasted a few days. According to a RIOC Tweet:

Michal Melamed was appointed to the RIOC Board to fill a vacant seat and before Mr Ekpo left the RIOC Board. It is not known why RIOC would claim that she was replacing Mr Ekpo.

Filling this vacant RIOC Board seat with a new appointment cannot be considered until at least next January when the NY State Legislature is back in session. 

You're invited to attend,  ask questions and share concerns about Roosevelt Island during the opening Public Session before the start of the meeting. Sign up to speak here. 

But be aware that RIOC Board Members and staff usually do not respond to questions during the Public Session though sometimes they may do so or address the subject later during the actual Board meeting.  

If you have a question or concern, give it a try, you may get a response. 

UPDATE 6/29 - RIOC reported this afternoon:

Roosevelt Island Community,

RIOC has been informed a clerical error was made in removing Conway Ekpo from the Board of Directors. The Governor’s office will reinstate him in January 2024 pending Senate approval.

President & CEO Shelton Haynes commented, “I was pleasantly surprised and pleased to hear about the pending reappointment of Conway. I look forward to continuing the great work we have achieved together over the years. Conway has already left an indelible mark on the community thanks to his inclusive ideas and collaborative efforts.”

Team RIOC

Wednesday, April 5, 2023

Roosevelt Island Corruption Allegations Against RIOC President And Senior Staff By 3 Former Employees In Whistleblower Lawsuit Getting City Wide Attention In Crains NY Article - Assembly Member Seawright Says Reports Are "Alarming"And Demands "Transparency And Accountability From RIOC"

Crains NY Business reported yesterday:

Click here for the full article.

Yesterday, I asked NY State Governor Kathy Hochul and Roosevelt Island Operating Corp (RIOC) Board of Directors Chairperson (also Commissioner of NY State Homes and Community Renewal) Ruthanne Visnauskas:

Roosevelt Islander Online has previously reported on corruption allegations made by former RIOC employees against senior Rioc management including current Rioc President Shelton Haynes as well as a whistleblower lawsuit filed by former Rioc employees who allege they were fired because they reported their concerns to the NY State Inspector General.

Here and here for example.

Today Crain’s New York reported much of this information too. According to Crain's (article behind a paywall):

Three ex-employees of the state body that controls Roosevelt Island say their bosses steered public money toward a personal friend, concealed details about a drowning death, then fired whistleblowers who raised objections:

Does Governor Hochul have any comment on this matter of great concern to the Roosevelt Island community? Does the Governor have confidence in Shelton Haynes remaining as Rioc President?

A spokesperson for Governor Hochul answered:

We’ll decline comment due to the pending litigation.

I followed up:

I understand limitations caused by the lawsuit. 

But can you comment as to whether there is any investigation by the State regarding these charges and if Shelton Haynes will remain Rioc President while the allegations are pending?

These are very serious allegations of great concern to the Roosevelt Island community.

 Will update if there is a reply.

According to Roosevelt Island NY State Assembly Member Rebecca Seawright:

The reports made by whistleblowers, 3 former Roosevelt Island Operating Corporation (RIOC) employees are alarming. I along with my Roosevelt Island constituents continue to fight for transparency and accountability from RIOC, the governing agency.

Ms Seawright adds:

Roosevelt Islanders deserve quality representation that is responsive and transparent. When I and other elected officials received an anonymous report from RIOC employees on March 21, 2022, I immediately referred the complaint to the New York State Inspector General for appropriate follow-up and action. Constituents consistently report that the Roosevelt Island Operating Corporation (RIOC) has been unresponsive in the day to day operations of the agency. The dysfunction and veil of secrecy cited throughout the pending lawsuit is distressing and unacceptable. I will continue fighting to ensure RIOC is held accountable and that the people of Roosevelt Island receive the services and attention they most assuredly deserve.

Here's the lawsuit filed by former RIOC employees.

RIOC President Shelton Haynes did not respond to my request for comment on the matter.   

The Crains article adds:

... Through an attorney, Haynes and RIOC declined to be interviewed. Their attorney, Howard Miller, said in a statement that the allegations made against the corporation are “completely false and fabricated.” “The lawsuit itself is a means of exacting a settlement over the severance pay that was offered to the plaintiffs,” Miller said in a statement....

... RIOC has filed a motion to dismiss the suit, which remains pending. Meanwhile, in mid-March, the corporation hit back with its own defamation lawsuit against the three fired employees—the latest chapter in years of controversy that have clouded the agency’s work....

During the April 3, 2023 RIOC Board of Directors meeting, there was no mention by Mr Haynes or the Board Directors of any chaos or corruption allegations but there was a last minute item placed on the meeting agenda for an Executive Session (meaning, in secret and closed to the public) concerning pending litigation.

Nor did Mr Haynes address any of the corruption and management chaos allegations in his President's Report to the community. Instead he praised his RIOC team and noted that in 2 weeks he will be celebrating his 7th anniversary working at RIOC.

Here's the RIOC President's Report from Mr Haynes.

Stay tune for more to come.

Monday, February 27, 2023

74 Year Old Roosevelt Island Resident Since 1977 Being Evicted From Her Apartment By Rivercross Board Of Directors - She Says Coop Board Retaliating Against Her For Requesting Disability Accommodation, Board Says She Was Harassing Other Residents

74 year old senior citizen Kathleen Kovach is a resident owner since 1977 of the Roosevelt Island Rivercross Co-op building.

But if the Rivercross Co-op Board of Directors have their way, Ms Kovach will be evicted as soon as this week from her long time home. 

Ms Kovach is a retired architect. She has long suffered from Multiple Chemical Sensitivities (MCS) disability which, she says, has been verified by 4 doctors. 

Due to her illness, in 2012 she asked the Rivercross Board of Directors for approval to modify her apartment windows to open more than 4 inches so that more fresh air circulates in her apartment which helps her deal with the MCS disability. 

According to Ms Kovach the Rivercross Board of Directors refused her disability accomodation request and one Board Member claimed MCS did not exist. Mr Kovach claims that the Rivercross Board of Directors is evicting her as retaliation for her seeking legal redress to her disability claim. Ms Kovach also claims that the Rivercross Board has a financial incentive to terminate her lease and sell her apartment.

According to court documents, the Rivercross Board of Directors allege that Ms Kovach engaged in objectionable behavior by harassing tenant shareholder of 2 apartment units in 2017-18. Ms Kovach denies these allegations and says instead she was the victim of harassment by owners of the 2 mentioned apartment units. Also, Ms Kovach says that for the last several years there have been no complaints against her.

I spoke with Ms Kovach last Wednesday  the day before the eviction notice was taped to her door.

 I asked the Rivercross Coop Board of Directors for comment on this matter. According to a Board representative:

Attached is a copy of the lower court's decision upholding Rivercross' actions and a copy of the appellate court's decision upholding the lower court. The matter remains in litigation and we therefore have no further comment.

According to the January 24, 2023 decision of the NY State Supreme Court Appellate Division:

... The court correctly granted plaintiff summary judgment on its ejectment cause of action, as plaintiff’s decision to terminate defendant’s proprietary lease for her objectionable conduct of constantly harassing her neighbors was protected by the business judgment rule (see 40 West 67th Street Corp. v Pullman,...

... While defendant contends that the termination of her tenancy was in retaliation for her own complaints against her neighbors and her requests for a disability accommodation, she offers no evidentiary support for this claim aside from speculative statements in her affidavit in opposition to plaintiff’s motion. Thus, there is no indication of bad faith warranting closer review of plaintiff’s determination. Nor did defendant refute any of the allegations of objectionable conduct such that a triable issue of fact is raised.

Defendant’s affirmative defenses were correctly dismissed in the absence of any evidence submitted by defendant to demonstrate their merits...

Ms Kovach's appellate attorney Robert Grimble adds: 

This is a very brief summary of the issues in Ms. Kovach’s case.

There is a general problem with the whole idea of a Pullman action. In this case, the vote to terminate Ms. Kovach’s proprietary lease was a board vote. The lease and by-laws set forth a series of notices to be given prior to holding a meeting, but at the meeting in Ms. Kovach’s case, the board retired to a private session and voted to terminate Ms. Kovach’s lease. 

This gives the board essentially unlimited power over a shareholder. We argued that the Court should review what the board did. The case law is very vague as to what degree a court can review the coop board’s actions,  and the coop relied on the “business judgment rule” a position that makes the board action virtually unchallengeable. 

 In this case, the Supreme Court granted the coop summary judgment. We argued that this was improper because there had been no discovery at that point, and we had no opportunity to develop defenses such as retaliatory eviction. We also pointed out that the coop’s motion did not have any factual affidavits detailing the conduct Ms. Kovach was accused of engaging in. There was no proof in a form to be considered on a summary judgment motion showing that Ms. Kovach had engaged in undesirable conduct.

We also pointed out some big inconsistencies in the paperwork leading up to the board meeting. The proprietary lease required a notice telling Ms. Kovach that she was doing something wrong which was shortly followed by a notice saying the conduct had recurred.

However, the notices are inconsistent in that the first notice claimed conduct such as banging on the walls and creating noise for other tenants. The notice that said the conduct had recurred had paragraph after paragraph of claims to the effect that Ms. Kovach had complained of fumes, but then refused (at some unstated later time and/or date) to let building personnel into her apartment to see if there was a smell (or noise is some cases).

The general problem with Pullman cases is that it lets a coop kick out a shareholder tenant essentially arbitrarily.

Over the last week, I've asked usually knowledgeable Rivercross residents if they knew anything about the Rivercross Coop Board's eviction proceedings against Ms. Kovach. None had.

Last evening, Ms Kovach placed a letter under the doors of her Rivercross neighbors giving her side of this story. An excerpt:

... Before my case could proceed to take depositions, and establish the merits of my case, the judge ruled in favor of the building. My attorney says that I’ve been denied a trial because depositions weren’t taken and my side of the case was never presented to the Court. And therefore, I’ve received an eviction notice. 

I’ve enjoyed living here and even after these issues, I would like to stay. If anyone has any suggestions that might help me keep my home, please call or slip a note under my door, ... Thanks for your time and any suggestions you might have. 

In desperation,

You would think reasonable and compassionate people could resolve this matter without resorting to evicting a 74 year old woman from her home of many years.

Thursday, February 16, 2023

Lawsuit Brought Against Roosevelt Island Operating Corp, RIOC President Shelton Haynes & General Counsel Gretchen Robinson By Fired RIOC Employees - Allegations Include Corruption, Misconduct, Fraud, Negligence, Cover Up and Workplace Retaliation For Whistleblower Complaints

On February 14, 2023, former Roosevelt Island Operating Corp (RIOC) employees Erica Spencer-El, Amy Smith and Jessica Cerrone commenced a lawsuit against RIOC, RIOC President Shelton Haynes, RIOC General Counsel Gretchen Robinson and others


 alleging (Verified Complaint para 1 page 2):

... an action for illegal workplace retaliation caused by Defendants against Plaintiffs for their whistleblower complaints made to report corruption, misconduct, and violations of law made internally and later externally to the New York State Office of Inspector General and to the New York State Office of the State Comptroller. As a direct result of Plaintiffs’ good-faith whistleblower complaints each of the three Plaintiffs were improperly and impermissibly subjective to a hostile work environment before ultimately being terminated from RIOC in violation of, inter alia, New York Labor Law § 740... 

Allegations contained in the Verified Complaint included:

... 16. Specifically, the three plaintiffs in this action observed an increasingly reckless pattern of corruption, unethical conduct, and dangerous behavior coming from RIOC’s leadership group and which peaked in the period of time when government mandated shutdowns due to COVID-19 began to lift in mid-2020....

... 17. Smith and Cerone, for their part, noticed operational concerns regarding the COVID-19 Rapid testing site on Roosevelt Island that opened in January 2021 known as Swift Emergency (“Swift”)....

... 19. Due to the Swift testing site receiving continuing special exemptions and priority treatment from RIOC leadership and the lack of response received from internal complaints about the issue, Smith and Spencer-EL’s concerns about violations of law grew, and, on or about March 4, 2021, Spencer-EL formally submitted reports to the New York State Office of Inspector General and the New York State Comptroller’s Office reflecting Plaintiffs’ legitimate concerns.

20. Spencer-EL’s March 4, 2021, reports centered around RIOC’s fraudulent purchasing activities related to COVID-19, and, in particular, Hayne’s and RIOC leadership’s push for non-compliance with certain laws, rules and regulations concerning directives and actions being handed out regarding the Swift testing site....

... 23. In addition to the numerous internal complaints made to and ignored by Defendants by the Plaintiffs regarding policies and directives concerning the Swift Site and the Sportspark pool drowning, Smith also anonymously reported her concerns to the New York State Office of the Inspector General.

24. In her report to the Inspector General, Smith i) outlined her previous concerns with the COVID-19 testing site, ii) explained that she saw video footage of the Sportspark downing and that the drowning was a result of negligence arising under Haynes and Jackson’s supervision and direction, and iii) expressed how she was asked to operate in a way that was aiding in nefarious matters, covering up wrong-doings, or having to feel bullied and harassed into supporting improper conduct and/or misconduct being perpetrated by leadership or the “Executive Team.”...

... 119. In her report to the Inspector General, Smith outlined her concerns with the COVID-19 testing site, as well as the drowning at Sportspark Pool. Furthermore, Smith also specifically named Jackson, Robinson, and Sharpe, explaining that she felt that Haynes was engaged in fraud with the testing site and that the drowning was a direct result of negligence under Haynes and Jackson’s supervision and direction. Smith also expressed how she was asked to operate in a way that was aiding in nefarious matters, covering up wrong-doings, or having to feel bullied and harassed into supporting improper conduct and/or misconduct being perpetrated by the “executive team"....

Earlier today, I asked RIOC President Shelton Haynes and Communications Vice President Akeem Jamal:

Does RIOC have any comment on the "Whistleblower" lawsuit brought by former RIOC employees Erica Spencer-El, Amy Smith and Jessica Cerrone?

Specifically, does RIOC have any comment on the allegations regarding:
  • The alleged cover up of the Sportspark drowning incident, including instructions to RIOC employees not to put anything in writing about the incident?
  • The  special treatment received by Swift Emergency in setting up the Roosevelt Island Covid Test site and the undisclosed personal relationship between the Swift owner and Shelton Haynes
  • the employees were fired by RIOC as retaliation for their complaints to the NY State Inspector General.
  • any other comment you wish to make on the subject.
 I plan on publishing an article about the lawsuit today so please let me know if you will comment.

There has been no response from RIOC.

Read the entire Verified Complaint.

 

Stay tuned.

Tuesday, January 11, 2022

Former Roosevelt Island Rivercross Co-op Owner Claims Cancer Caused By Exposure To Radiation From Undisclosed Electric Transformer Adjacent To Apartment Bedroom Common Wall In Lawsuit Filed Last Week

The NY Post reported January 8:
... Dragan Micic, 48, and wife Lidija Bubanja are suing Rivercross Terrace and others for negligence, claiming no one told them when they bought their home at 531 Main St. that the transformer was on the other side of their bedroom wall....
According to a lawsuit filed January 6, 2022 in NY State Supreme Court by former Rivercross Co-op owners Dragan Micic and Lidija Bubanja:

1- This is an action for misrepresentation, negligence, nuisance, breach of the warranty of habitability, loss of consortium and punitive damages arising out of the presence of an electric transformer, which emitted dangerous levels of electromagnetic radiation, in a transformer room located directly adjacent to and sharing a common wall with Plaintiffs’ bedroom in their residential cooperative apartment, number or unit 911, located at 531 Main Street, Roosevelt Island, New York. The existence of the transformer was undisclosed to the Plaintiffs when they purchased and eventually moved into the unit on or about May 31, 2019. For the next 17 months, Plaintiffs slept less than one foot away from the transformer and their upper bodies, more specifically their heads and necks were exposed for 6 to 10 hours a day to levels of radiation that exceeded recommended standards. Despite Plaintiffs’ repeated complaints, Defendants did nothing to effectively remediate the situation and allowed the dangerous exposure to continue unabated.  

2- As a result of this sustained exposure, Micic developed a tumor in his nasal passage and ocular region within his skull, which was diagnosed in August 2020 as an aggressive form of Adenoid Cystic Carcinoma. This is a rare form of cancer caused by exposure to radiation and other environmental toxic substances. Such type of tumor is normally slow to develop. However, in this instance, due to the constant daily exposure to excessive amounts of EMF radiation to Micic’s head and neck, the growth of the tumor was accelerated. In addition, Micic and his wife Bubanja also suffered persistent headaches, fatigue, anxiety, and insomnia caused by the exposure. ... 

... 5 - On the advice of Micic’s treating surgeon, Plaintiffs moved out and eventually sold in July 21, 2021, at an overall financial loss, their Apartment at 531 Main Street in the middle of the pandemic induced dip in the New York City housing market. They incurred moving and other related expenses as a result of this move.

Below is the full Complaint.

I asked the Rivercross Board for comment yesterday. They declined at the time but sources tell me a statement is coming soon from the Rivercross Board, possibly later today.

What do some Rivercross residents think? According to one:

If true it’s going to be a real problem and it’s really scary.
and a second:
... this will raise some concerns for a small number of shareholders, who have had — or have — cancer or related illnesses & reside near the Transformer rooms.

The lawsuit does not say if the new buyers of the apartment were informed about the electric transformer.

Stay tuned.

UPDATE 1/12: Several building residents shared this email they received yesterday from the Rivercross Board of Directors:

This past Friday, we learned of a lawsuit filed against Rivercross by a former shareholder, which was picked up by a local newspaper.  The claim involves alleged exposure to EMFs (electromagnetic fields) from the transformer room located next to his apartment.  The allegations against Rivercross are without merit and we will vigorously defend against the lawsuit.  If you have any questions, please direct those questions to the Board.  
I asked the Riverwalk Board today:
Will there be any statement to the media? There was not much information in the statement. I've spoken to Rivercross residents worried about the health implications of the allegations in the lawsuit. Will the Board answer questions about what safety protocols are in place regarding living near the electric transformers?

Tuesday, May 18, 2021

Former Roosevelt Island Operating Corp President Susan Rosenthal Wins Discovery Motion In Wrongful Termination Lawsuit Ordering RIOC To Hand Over Info About Her Firing And Safety Hazards Of RI Steam Tunnels, Files 2nd Lawsuit Too - RIOC Board Meeting In Executive Session Today To Discuss Pending Litigation

The Roosevelt Island Operating Corp (RIOC) announced yesterday:

Please take notice that an emergency meeting of the RIOC Board of Directors will be held on Tuesday, May 18th, 2021 at 5:30 P.M., via videoconference.

According to the May 18 RIOC Emergency Board Meeting Agenda, the sole item to be discussed is pending litigation. This discussion will be conducted in Executive Session, closed to the public.

Although not confirmed, it is likely that the pending litigation to be discussed at today's emergency RIOC Board meeting is the wrongful termination lawsuit brought by former RIOC President Susan  Rosenthal

against RIOC, members of NY State Governor Andrew Cuomo's executive staff and individual members of the RIOC Board of Directors.

As reported October 23, 2020:

‎According to this June 20 statement from Rich Azzopardi, Senior advisor to NY Governor Andrew Cuomo:

A complaint was made to the Governor’s office and others on June 12th by an employee of the Roosevelt Island Operating Corporation that alleged that the President of the organization had u‎sed inappropriate language and engaged in inappropriate conduct in the workplace.

This complaint was immediately referred to the New York State Governor’s Office of Employee Relations for investigation. This investigation substantiated that the President had used racially and sexually offensive language, in clear violation of State policy and the strict standards set by this Administration. The President was Immediately terminated.

The specific allegations made by the employee are contained in an email shown at this prior post)

Ms Rosenthal has remained silent until now.  On October 19 Ms.Rosenthal filed a lawsuit in NY State Supreme Court alleging wrongful termination. According to the lawsuit (Page 1-2):

... Rosenthal, until her abrupt and improper termination on June 19, 2020, was the President of the Roosevelt  Island Operating Corporation ("RIOC", or "Respondent"). A long time, fierce advocate for civil rights and, more recently, a supporter of the Black Lives Matter movement Rosenthal, a white female, brought an increased level of racial diversity to RIOC over her more than five year tenure as President. It is thus both ironic and tragic that Respondents blindly accepted the malicious, false and baseless allegations of racism and using sexist language from a known malcontent employee (the "Employee"). 

Rushing to announce their decision to terminate Petitioner on Juneteenth, Respondents conducted a brief, sham investigation which ignored irrefutable evidence that the allegations were nonsense. Had the Respondents conducted a good faith investigation, they would have quickly come to that conclusion. Instead, not only did Respondents terminate Rosenthal in violation of their own internal policies, but they did so with a public announcement which had the anticipated effect of besmirching a more than 45 year long exemplary career. 

In short, in order to obtain some cheap publicity on Juneteenth, they arbitrarily, maliciously and in violation of law threw Rosenthal under the proverbial bus. By this special proceeding, Rosenthal seeks reinstatement, back pay, attorneys' fees and damages. 

Also (Page 9):

... When she was hired in 2015, Rosenthal was warned by RIOC management of a 'cabal,' which included Employee, which targeted management and sought to oust them from RIOC. Roosenthal was told to be careful because of their propensity. Again further proving the axiom that no good deed goes unpunished, Rosenthal even supported the promotion and increased pay Employee enjoyed....

On May 14, 2021 Ms Rosenthal won a significant victory when her discovery motion seeking information which RIOC objected to providing was granted by the NY State Supreme Court. According to the Court decision, RIOC is ordered to produce to Ms Rosenthal (the Petitioner):

... 1. Copies of all recordings of Petitioner; 

2. Notes of any interviews with persons complaining about Petitioner; 

3. Drafts of the June 19, 2020 press release, and any communications relating to such press release; 

4. Communications concerning the decision to terminate Petitioner; 

5. Communications, including but not limited to emails, memos and status reports, from Petitioner or other RIOC employees, to government officials, concerning or referring to the steam tunnel on Roosevelt Island, and any documents reflecting the government’s reaction to those communications; and 

6. Communications, including but not limited to emails, memos and status reports, from Petitioner or other RIOC employees, to government officials, concerning or referring to the public health and safety hazards regarding the steam tunnel on Roosevelt Island, including but not limited to the reports from the United States Army Corps of Engineers and Langan Engineering and Environmental Services, Inc., and any documents reflecting the government’s reaction to those communications....

Below is copy of the May 14 decision.

Will RIOC, the Governor's staff and RIOC Directors decide to settle with Ms Rosenthal rather than produce what could be damaging information about the reasons for her firing last June 19?

Also, on April 27, 2021 Ms Rosenthal filed another lawsuit in NY State Supreme Court against RIOC, members of the Governor's Staff and members of the RIOC Board of Directors.

According to excerpts for the lawsuit:

... 2. Rosenthal, until her abrupt and improper termination on June 19, 2020, was the President and Chief Executive Officer of RIOC. Despite her exemplary record as a promoter of a diverse and equitable workplace over her more than five year tenure as President and Chief Executive Officer, Rosenthal was the subject of a malicious, false and baseless complaint of racism and use of sexist language on June 12, 2020 from a known malcontent employee (the “Employee”). The Albany Defendants immediately commenced an investigation which quickly showed that the allegations against Rosenthal were unfounded. 

3. That did not deter the Albany Defendants. The Governor’s Office was already motivated to “get” Rosenthal because she had repeatedly complained about a potentially catastrophic safety situation on Roosevelt Island. Rosenthal refused to accept the Governor’s Office’s determination to just sweep the problem under the rug and wrote and had delivered a detailed memo highlighting the issue. As a result of Rosenthal’s repeated demands upon the Governor’s Office to take action on this issue, it was only then that the Albany Defendants decided to make the complaints against Rosenthal a basis for her termination. During the investigation of the unfounded complaint, the Albany Defendants purported to learn of audio tapes which supposedly contained the voice of Plaintiff making racist and sexually harassing statements. The Albany Defendants told Rosenthal of the supposed existence of the tapes but refused to allow her the opportunity to listen to them, a refusal which continues to this day. 

4. It now appears that none of the Defendants ever actually had possession of the tapes. They refuse to disclose who created the tapes, how and when they were prepared, on what type of device, all of the voices which were on the tapes, or any other identifying information. None of the Defendants made any effort to authenticate the tapes. Moreover, given the restrictions in place during the Covid-19 pandemic, it is likely that whatever it was that certain of Defendants claimed to have listened to was heard over a telephone or internet connection. 

5. Rosenthal denied that she had ever used the language as attributed to her. Instead of taking the time to conduct a fair and thorough investigation, or to even allow Rosenthal to listen to the audio tapes, the Albany Defendants rushed to announce their decision to terminate Rosenthal on “Juneteenth,” a date celebrating the end of slavery in America. Not only did Defendants terminate Rosenthal in violation of their own internal policies, but they did so with a public announcement which had the anticipated and intended effect of besmirching a more than 45 yearlong exemplary career.

6. Rosenthal’s termination violated federal, city and state law, including: 

a. Title VII of the Civil Rights Act of 1964, New York State Human Rights Law and New York City Human Rights Law in that Rosenthal was treated differently because she is a Caucasian female; and

b. New York State Labor Law §740 in that Rosenthal’s termination was retaliation for complaining about a safety hazard on Roosevelt Island that an engineering report stated could have a “catastrophic” consequence. 

Below is copy of Ms Rosenthal's April 27, 2021 complaint filed in the NY Supreme Court.

RIOC has declined offers to comment on this matter.

Here's Ms Rosenthal speaking during the the February 8 2020 Roosevelt Island Black History Month Celebration at Gallery RIVAA.


Stay tuned.

Wednesday, November 29, 2017

Roosevelt Island Newspaper Main Street WIRE Commences Legal Proceedings Against Roosevelt Island Daily News Web Site - Allegations Include Improper Use Of Email List And Defamation

The Roosevelt Island community is fortunate, in my view, having three local media sources to cover and opine on various issues facing our neighborhood - the Main Street WIRE, Roosevelt Island Daily


and Roosevelt Islander Online.

However, rather than reporting on Roosevelt Island news,  the WIRE and Daily are now making news.

On November 10, the WIRE and publisher Briana Warsing filed a lawsuit in NY State Supreme Court against the Roosevelt Island Daily and publisher David Stone. The allegations in the WIRE/Warsing complaint include improper use of an email list and various defamatory statements allegedly by Daily/Mr. Stone.

Below is an excerpt from the complaint:
FACTS COMMON TO ALL CAUSES OF ACTION

... 15. Prior to the spring of 2016, Defendant Stone worked as a freelance contributor to the The Main Street WIRE.

16. In the spring of 2016, Defendant Stone engaged in discussions to take over the The Main Street WIRE as publisher, replacing the retiring editor, Dick Lutz (“Lutz”)

17. During the course and in furtherance of the discussions identified above, Stone requested disclosure of the Wire Bulletin List. Lutz shared the Wire Bulletin List with Stone with the understanding that Stone only use the Wire Bulletin List in furtherance of the business of Plaintiff WIRE.

18. A satisfactory arrangement could not be reached between Defendant Stone and Plaintiff Wire.

19. On April 13, 2016, Defendant Stone informed Plaintiff Wire via e-mail that he was “moving on”.

20. On April 16, 2016, Defendant Stone sent an e-mail to all people and business on Wire Bulletin List to announce that Stone was starting a competing business, i.e. Defendant, Roosevelt Island Daily.

21. On April 25, 2017, Lutz, on behalf of Plaintiff Wire, provided written demand to Defendant Stone to cease and desist use of the Wire Bulletin List for his own purposes. Defendant Stone provide written refusal on April 25, 2017, stating that Lutz, “[a]s a 77 year old man, [has] a lot of growing up to do”.

22. Bulletin List:
On November 12, 2016, Stone conceded improperly retaining and using the Wire Bulletin List:
The email list [the Wire] claims I don't have ‘permission to use’ was already in use before our deal with the WIRE collapsed. Lutz gave it to me, along with detailed instructions on how to upload it to my own account.

The reason he did was because I wanted to restart the Alerts that he'd dropped months before after reducing full time activities with the WIRE. Warsing had not picked them up.

I picked up the list and began sending Alerts as a service to the community. No one paid any sort of sponsorship. It was just a good thing to do. So, why should that not continue after my deal with the WIRE ended?
See http://rooseveltislanddaily.prosepoint.net/143780.

23. Defendants Stone and Daily acknowledged on August 19, 2017 that the Wire Bulletin List was created by the Wire:
“[the] mailing ... did not originate with The Daily. It's a list compiled from residents who wanted to receive community alerts from the former Main Street WIRE... Our active list is roughly 90% subscribers who started out with the WIRE.
See http://rooseveltislanddaily.prosepoint.net/risa-gets-little-support-for-rioc-public-purpose-funds.

24. In August of 2017, after the termination of negotiations between Stone and Lutz, and after the creation of Defendant Daily by Stone, plaintiff Warsing was appointed the Editor in Chief of The Main Street WIRE.

25. Thereafter, Stone began to systemically and repeatedly attack Warsing, the Wire and anyone associated therewith with false and misleading allegations of racisms, sexual misconduct, and lack of professionalism. ...
You can read the entire Complaint at bottom of post.

I asked Roosevelt Island Daily Publisher David Stone if he wished to comment. Mr. Stone replied:
First, I was surprised by the WIRE’s claims of defamation because no one connected with the newspaper has ever complained about the factual accuracy of anything I’ve written, not even once. When I heard about their concerns, I immediately informed them that I’d be eager to correct, retract and publicly apologize for any factual errors. Most newspapers have practices like that, as mine does, and had the WIRE ever complained, I’d have taken it seriously. They didn’t, even after I offered.

What all this appears to be is an unprecedented attack on the First Amendment by a financially stronger competitor seeking to silence criticism by dragging them into expensive litigation. It’s made even worse — and potentially embarrassing to the community — by its being driven by a newspaper that exists only because the First Amendment gives them a right to free expression. Even Trump doesn’t do that with CNN, and certainly, the WIRE has every right and a broad platform to defend itself and counter criticism. Resnick, Lutz and Warsing chose litigation instead. The Roosevelt Island community can reach their own conclusions about that.

They may be successful. The Roosevelt Island Daily is a financially borderline community service online newspaper. We simply don’t have the resources to fight the WIRE’s backers, including at least one well-heeled nonresident. But they don’t seem interested in any other course of action.

The WIRE and Warsing have also complained about a mailing list Dick Lutz gave me for the purposes of sending out alerts. Because it was filled with duplicates, stale and uninterested addresses, I haven’t used it in a year and a half, but I do not agree that I have no right to. The list was given without any strings attached, and there was no agreement about limitations. Moreover, as I’ve explained, I was never a WIRE employee and never finalized any commitment with the WIRE, although I was willing to until they backed out. The transfer happened while negotiations were ongoing. Later, Dick along with Jack Resnick and Briana Warsing decided not to honor the terms under which we’d been working together. I was saddened when that happened, but I don’t see how that gives the WIRE retroactive rights they never claimed at the time. The list itself is not only stale and outdated but also unused by the WIRE. Why they would want to prevent Roosevelt Island residents from getting daily alerts on transportation, weather and news is beyond me.

They have also complained about my encouraging businesses and their customers to consider what they investing in when their money goes to the WIRE. That’s a reasonable suggestion, I think, and conditioned on specific actions by the WIRE that I sincerely believe were detrimental to the community. Again, people can decide for themselves. Print media everywhere is bleeding advertisers, as you well know, because it’s not considered an effective way to reach customers. I can’t change that nor should I be expected to protect the WIRE against its own practices that hurt community members and institutions. If a business or a resident disagrees with me, nothing stops them from supporting the WIRE.

I can’t see how any of this reflects well on Dick Lutz, Jack Resnick, Briana Warsing or the WIRE or why they’re so concerned about this much smaller competitor that they’d attack the First Amendment in a way that has never been done before in America.
I asked Main Street Wire Publisher Briana Warsing for comment. Ms. Warsing replied:
As provided in the complaint, we are simply seeking redress from defamatory comments and theft of property and are not seeking to limit any rights under the First Amendment. We would prefer a private resolution without court intervention, though the other side, to date, seems uninterested.
Below is the Complaint.



Click here for better view to read the complaint.

UPDATE 11/30 - From the Twitterverse:
The Roosevelt Island Daily publisher has more today including:
I haven't seen the complaint Main Street WIRE attorney Marc Jonas Block filed against me and the Daily in Supreme Court. Others have, including other local media. Word spread around Roosevelt Island....
Click here for full article.

Wednesday, July 23, 2008

Freedom of the Press Also Includes Bloggers - Doesn't It?

Image of The Trial of John Peter Zenger from courts.state.ny

My July 18th post concerning a proposed Roosevelt Island waterfront development project at Southpoint Park by developer Stephen Jemal of SSJ Development linked to a post by Brooklyn Blogger Gerritsen Beach that described, among other things, a lawsuit brought against the developer. According to Curbed, the developer's attorneys sent a letter to blogger Gerritsen Beach:
demanding the post be pulled down, that blogs linking to it remove it and that the blogger sign a "non-disparagement agreement." It also requests $20,000 for legal fees and to "act as additional consideration to induce him not to file suit." Also, someone believed to be "close" to the developer's firm allegedly launched a Denial of Service attack on the website.
In my opinion, the threat of a lawsuit against blogger Gerritsen Beach is a shameful act of intimidation that threatens this new media outlet of citizen journalists and local neighborhood bloggers. As stated by Gowanus Lounge:
The lawsuit threat hasn’t been settled yet, but the intended chilling effect of threatening a small, non-profit blog with a costly lawsuit is clear. The threat is the same whether it comes from a local online community miffed that emails circulating publicly are being quoted without “permission” and are “illegal” or whether they are from a developer who demands $20,000 to avoid a lawsuit or to induce someone to sign a “non-disparagement agreement.” In either case, a blogger could face a fortune in legal bills to fight off someone with deep pockets who wishes to prove a point.

... The problem is compounded by the fact that bloggers don’t have access to a team of lawyers that reporters do, that many don’t come from a journalism background and can be easily intimidated by bogus claims of liable, slander or copyright violations. It highlights the need for internet groups or a new organization to step to the plate and offer legal advice and counsel to bloggers who are often operating as journalists with none of the institutional protections.
I hope that I never need them but the Electronic Frontier Foundation is a great resource for bloggers providing a:
basic roadmap to the legal issues you may confront as a blogger, to let you know you have rights, and to encourage you to blog freely with the knowledge that your legitimate speech is protected.
as is the Chilling Effects Clearinghouse which:
aims to help you understand the protections that the First Amendment and intellectual property laws give to your online activities. We are excited about the new opportunities the Internet offers individuals to express their views, parody politicians, celebrate their favorite movie stars, or criticize businesses. But we've noticed that not everyone feels the same way. Anecdotal evidence suggests that some individuals and corporations are using intellectual property and other laws to silence other online users. Chilling Effects encourages respect for intellectual property law, while frowning on its misuse to "chill" legitimate activity.
Here is more information about this particular incident from bloggers Gerritsen Beach and Sheepshead Bites.

Also, the NY Times had a related article about the Bronx District Attorney issuing a subpoena and gag order on the blog site Room 8.
A grand jury subpoena sent by prosecutors in the Bronx earlier this year sought information to help identify people blogging anonymously on a Web site about New York politics called Room 8.

The subpoena carried a warning in capital letters that disclosing its very existence “could impede the investigation being conducted and thereby interfere with law enforcement” — implying that if the bloggers blabbed, they could be prosecuted.