Blockbuster News, NY State Inspector General Finds Criminal Conduct, Kickbacks, Nepotism, Abuse Of Vehicles And Credit Cards At Prior Roosevelt Island Operating Corp (RIOC) Administration
was investigating the leadership and management structure of the Roosevelt Island Operating Corp (RIOC). In December 2013 I asked when the Inspector General's report would be released.
Well, the answer is today. Here is the full 53 page NY State Inspector General's Report on RIOC, which I am still reading, and below is the press release from the NY State Inspector General describing the report.
NEW YORK STATE INSPECTOR GENERAL FINDS CRIMINAL CONDUCT, KICKBACKS, NEPOTISM, ABUSE OF VEHICLES AND CREDIT CARDS AT ROOSEVELT ISLAND OPERATION CORPORATION
Inspector General’s investigation results in two guilty pleas and systemic changes to RIOC Policies and Procedures
Three executives of the Roosevelt Island Operating Corporation were engaged in misconduct ranging from steering contracts to relatives and taking kickbacks from them, using RIOC vehicles for personal use, chronic absenteeism, and inappropriate expenses including the use of RIOC funds for unauthorized meals, according to a report released today by New York State Inspector General Catherine Leahy Scott. Inspector General Scott’s investigation, which covered the years 2007 to 2012 focused on Fernando Martinez, then Vice President of Operations for RIOC, former President/Chief Executive Officer Leslie Torres, and former Chief Financial Officer Steven Chironis. As a result of the investigation, all three no longer work for RIOC.
Additionally, as a result of the Inspector General’s investigation, Martinez pleaded guilty to charges associated with contract steering and kickbacks. He was ordered to pay approximately $86,000 in restitution to the state and sentenced to six months incarceration. An associate, Javier Ramos, was ordered to pay $7,500 for his part in the scheme.
“As my investigation of RIOC makes clear, illegal and unethical behavior was common at the very top of RIOC’s executive chain of command,” said Inspector General Scott. “Officers charged with governing and delivering services to residents and businesses on Roosevelt Island used RIOC to enrich themselves, family and friends to an astonishing degree. This may not have occurred had there been effective oversight at RIOC.”
Charlene M. Indelicato, President and Chief Executive Officer of RIOC said: “RIOC can best represent and deliver important services to the people who live and work on Roosevelt Island only when we maintain a high degree of integrity, accountability and transparency in government. This is why I am very pleased with Inspector General Scott’s completed investigation and grateful for the guidance and recommendations her report provides to ensure past mistakes and misconduct are not repeated.”
The Inspector General’s investigation revealed that Martinez received kickbacks for steering a contract to Bright Cleaning Solutions (BCS), Ramos’s company, in November 2008 for shoreline cleanup. He steered another contract to BCS in September 2010 for an office renovation project and received $9,390.
Additionally, Martinez utilized a brother-in-law’s printing company for RIOC projects and hired a second brother-in-law for the position of Parks and Recreation Manager in violation of state ethics policy and RIOC’s anti-nepotism directive. Following the Inspector General’s discoveries, Martinez resigned his RIOC employment in December 2012.
Former President/CEO Torres violated RIOC policy by utilizing a RIOC vehicle for commuting and personal travel. In addition, she inappropriately charged expensive meals to her RIOC credit card, with one lunch costing $355. Finally, Torres was consistently absent from RIOC’s offices, instructing staff to keep her office lit while she was away. She resigned in September 2012.
Former CFO Chironis tacitly approved Torres’s misuse of the RIOC vehicle, and miscalculated her taxable fringe benefit in violation of federal law and state policy. He also permitted Torres to inappropriately charge meals to her credit card, incorrectly classifying them as “business expenses” in violation of RIOC policy. In fact, Chironis and Martinez engaged in the same misuse of their RIOC credit cards shortly after Torres began doing so. Chironis resigned his RIOC employment in August 2013.
Inspector General Scott also found that since May 2011, RIOC has not had an internal control officer, as required by the Public Authorities Law. This position is charged with safeguarding RIOC’s assets, checking accounting data, and ensuring RIOC is adhering to its own policies.
Inspector General Scott recommended that RIOC:
Inspector General Scott reviewed her report with RIOC’s new management, which has agreed to take corrective action, including:
- Follow state procurement laws and strengthen its own policies;
- Review all procurements, monitor credit card usage to ensure conformance with RIOC policy, and issue credit cards only to employees whose daily activities require them;
- Designate an internal control officer; and
- Ensure vehicles are used appropriately and consistently with RIOC’s vehicle use policy.
- Take measures to recoup moneys improperly spent by RIOC employees
In addition, RIOC has issued demand letters for reimbursement of inappropriate expenditures.
- Instituting stronger, more effective oversight measures of state procurement law to prevent unauthorized procurement and strictly bar nepotism;
- Incorporating layers of review and reconciliation of procurements made by RIOC personnel:
- Retrieve and discontinue all credit cards used by RIOC personnel who made unauthorized purchases and act to recoup those purchases from the cardholders;
- Recruitment of an internal control/compliance officer; and
- Revision of the vehicle use policy to reflect state policy which strictly prohibits personal use of
- vehicles and requires travel logs be maintained for each vehicle.
Inspector General Scott thanked Manhattan District Attorney Cyrus R. Vance, Jr. for prosecuting the Martinez and Ramos cases, and for assisting in the investigation.
RIOC was created in 1984 as a public benefit corporation to assume responsibility for the development and operation of Roosevelt Island, a 147-acre state owned island property that sits on the East River between the New York City boroughs of Manhattan and Queens. RIOC is governed by a nine-member board.
A copy of the Inspector General’s report can be found here
UPDATE 8/8 - More info here including comments from former RIOC President Steve Shane on IG Report.