Showing posts with label OMNY. Show all posts
Showing posts with label OMNY. Show all posts

Wednesday, September 13, 2023

RIOC Board Of Directors Meeting Thursday September 14, Roosevelt Island Residents Encouraged To Come Speak Up About Transportation Problems With Overcrowded Tram, Red Bus And Subway Shuttle - What Say You?

The Roosevelt Island Operating Corp (RIOC) Board of Directors will meet in person tomorrow, September 14 at 5:30 PM in the Cultural Center Theatre (548 Main Street) beginning at 5:30 PM.

You're invited to attend,  ask questions and share concerns about Roosevelt Island during the opening Public Session before the start of the meeting. Sign up to speak here.

Will Roosevelt Island residents show up tomorrow to  speak at the Public Session about the transportation problems being experienced resulting from the MTA's 63rd Street Tunnel Rehab Project?

Residents have been contacting RIOC, elected officials, local press and formed a What's App chat group seeking solutions to overcrowding at the Tram and problems with the Subway Shuttle. For example, long time Roosevelt Island resident Akiko Tamura wrote to the RIOC Directors:

Dear RIOC members,

It has been exactly one week since I last wrote to you, expressing my concern about the safety of the tramway. In my previous email, I recommended that the Public Safety Officers be standing at the boarding area instead of outside the turnstiles to help organize and navigate the crowd. I also suggested that the tram operators make an announcement reminding people to give up their seats for those who need them. Additionally, I recommended that a sign be put up to remind tourists that Roosevelt Island is home to 12000 residents, and to ask them to behave respectfully.

However, I took the tram today and found that nothing had changed. The situation was just as chaotic as before, if not worse. People were pushing each other, tourists were rushing to grab seats, and neither the PSD nor the tram operators seemed to be paying much attention.

Just the other day, a resident reported that someone made a racial remark to her when she refused to allow a tourist to push her aside and take a video on board. She reported the incident to the PSD, but her complaint was dismissed.

As someone who has lived on Roosevelt Island for nearly 40 years, I can't help but feel that this is no longer a safe place to live. Simple crowd management by the PSD, making an announcement by the tram operator, and posting a sign is not difficult or costly task.

I hope to hear a better response from you than the last time.

Thank you in advance for your quick attention to this matter.

RIOC Director Ben Fhala wrote back:

I wanted to follow up with you regarding the points you made earlier. The board has been actively engaged with leadership and PSD, and we acknowledge ongoing efforts to improve the transportation process in recent weeks. Although there's room for further enhancement, significant progress has already been achieved.

Multiple residents have confirmed that when they requested assistance from PSD and staff, it was provided promptly. Additionally, I've received feedback from PSD officers and the public regarding instances where the team facilitated the boarding process for community members with special needs. We remain committed to refining the system and are actively collaborating with the community and stakeholders to make further improvements.

While I can't address specific scenarios here, residents are encouraged to reach out to us or PSD leadership if they wish to delve into particular cases or discuss guideline updates with PSD officers.

As a daily public transportation commuter, I've witnessed continual improvements. I recommend considering the subway shuttle, which is currently underutilized and offers a more pleasant ride. Unfortunately, the Tram's service has been less than ideal due to various temporary issues that we're working to mitigate. Encouraging more community members to utilize all modes of transportation, including the subway, ferry, bus services, and the Tram, is a crucial part of this mitigation effort.

I hope to see and engage with you in our upcoming board meeting scheduled for this Thursday at 5:30 pm at the Cultural Center Theater at 548 Main St.

Let's see if RIOC engages in a constructive manner with the community about solutions for our transportation problems.

Among the items on the agenda for tomorrow's RIOC Board meeting are: 

1. Ratification of the Memorandum of Understanding with the MTA for OMNY Installation (Board Action Required) ...

... VI. Chair’s Motion for Executive Session to Discuss:

a. proposed, pending or current litigation; and

b. the medical, financial, credit or employment history of a particular person or corporation, or matters leading to the appointment, employment, promotion, demotion, discipline, suspension, dismissal or removal of a particular person or corporation....

VII. Update on the Board Committees’ Assignments... 

Following the August 24, 2023 MTA press conference announcing the OMNY installation for the Roosevelt Island Tram, I asked the MTA:

What is the revenue allocation of the Tram fare between Rioc and the MTA?

My understanding is that Rioc currently receives approximately $2.00 of every swipe at the Tram. Has that changed with the installation of OMNY?

What is the new revenue allocation of the Tram fare?

A MTA spokesperson replied:

With OMNY, RIOC will get the benefit of the full value of fare revenue for pay go transactions. Currently, RIOC receives $2 for Full Fare and $1 for Reduced Fare when a customer utilizes MetroCard.

More info about the Roosevelt Island Tram OMNY installation in RIOC memo below.

Thursday, August 24, 2023

After Years Of Delay, OMNY Tap And Go Payment System Begins Today On Roosevelt Island Tram Announces MTA Chair Janno Lieber - RIOC President Shelton Haynes Adds That As Of Now, Metro Cards Holders Will No Longer Be Allowed To Skip The Huge Tourist Lines, Angering Many Residents

After several years of delay and a "Bring OMNY To The Roosevelt Island Tram" online petition which collected more than 1400 signatures, the MTA's OMNY tap and go payment system began working today on the Roosevelt Island Tram. 

MTA chairman Janno Lieber walked up the Roosevelt Island Tram Second Avenue Manhattan station staircase 

and used the OMNY to enter through the turnstile today.

He then rode a not very crowded Tram over the East River to Roosevelt Island 

with Roosevelt Island Operating Corp (RIOC) President  Shelton Haynes and Manhattan Borough President Mark Levine  

for a press conference announcing OMNY's installation for the Roosevelt Island Tram.

During the press conference, I asked if Roosevelt Island residents would continue to be able to skip the long Tram line of tourists by using their Metro Card.

Mr Lieber said:

I do not know the answer... 

I do know the Roosevelt Island leadership and the electeds are determined to make sure that mass transit here works really well for Roosevelt Islanders. So you're going to continue to look at that issue in consultation with whoever is relevant, whether it's technical folks or legal or lawyers or whatever.

But for us, the bottom line is Omni, it just makes travel faster for everybody. So whoever's waiting on that line, whichever line they're in, or if they're in one line, it's going to be a lot faster with Omni than people buying Metro Cars one by one... 

RIOC President Shelton Haynes added:

Right now we're currently assessing situation and it's very fluid. As it stands we do not anticipate having a line where Metro Card holders can skip. We're still assessing, we're still going to make the best decision possible for Roosevelt Island commuters... 

According to this comment from Roosevelt Islander Instagram post on the Roosevelt Island OMNY installation today:

@rooseveltislandny @mta Who are the specific individuals responsible for adding OMNY to tram at the same time the F train is shutting down for 7 months? If any of the people responsible for this actually lived on the island it would have never gone through at this time. 

Now residents will have to wait behind hundreds of tourists on a tram line that regularly wraps around the block on the Manhattan side. Previously we could at least skip the bulk of the line by having a metrocard preloaded and ready. This, combined with limited train service, makes the daily commute for thousands of residents and island students very complicated and much longer. The once an hour red bus that moves 55 people on weekends barely helps. 

I’m seriously shocked at how short-sighted island leadership can be.

We’ve also been repeatedly told that a resident/tram priority pass is simply impossible despite the fact this is exactly what happened in 1976 when the tram first opened so that residents could get home ahead of the flood of tourists coming to see the new tram. A priority pass isn’t ‘impossible’, you’re just not trying hard enough or simply don’t care enough. 

How are you gonna help resolve the situation? Please come up with an acceptable plan. Residents are angry and the pressure will continue to mount otherwise. 

Other comments include about today's Roosevelt Island Tram OMNY installation on the Roosevelt Islander Instagram page include;
  • This is terrible for Roosevelt Island residents that will now have to wait in crowds of tourists to get home instead of skipping lines with Metrocards
  • exactly, ugh. The worst timing
  • I don’t know how we will get to our homes.
  • Hahahahaha leave it to @sheltonjhaynes to finally set up OMNY just in time for there to be no subway and now residents have to wait in line for the tram. What an absolute joke
  • and now look out for an announcement about the great @sheltonjhaynes getting Omni for Roosevelt Island to add to his many accomplishments that he’s taking credit for that were all started by someone else.
  • I think it will create a more even flow. Good news and I don’t have to switch between my phone and card. 👍
  • About time.
  • Great!
  • Great news, now #rooseveltisland just needs a working subway station
  • finally 🙌

Here's the full Roosevelt Island Tram OMNY press conference from this afternoon.

MTA reports on Twitter (X)

and RIOC reports on Instagram. Check out the Instagram comments.

Here's how to use OMNY.

UPDATE 8/25:

After the press conference, I asked the MTA:

What is the revenue allocation of the Tram fare between Rioc and the MTA?

My understanding is that Rioc currently receives approximately $2.00 of every swipe at the Tram. Has that changed with the installation of OMNY?

What is the new revenue allocation of the Tram fare?

A MTA spokeperson answered:

With OMNY, RIOC will get the benefit of the full value of fare revenue for pay go transactions. 

Currently, RIOC receives $2 for Full Fare and $1 for Reduced Fare when a customer utilizes MetroCard.

The MTA press release on Roosevelt Island Tram OMNY installation is here.

Tuesday, August 15, 2023

RIOC Says Prep Work Begins Tonight On Long Delayed Roosevelt Island Tram OMNY Installation As Terms Continue To Be Negotiated With MTA - But Will Residents Still Be Able To Skip Long Tram Lines Using Metro Card?

Roosevelt Island residents have been waiting for the installation of the MTA's OMNY payment system on the Roosevelt Island Tram since at least February 2020.

Today, the Roosevelt Island Operating Corp (RIOC) announced:

Dear Roosevelt Island Community:

Prep work will begin tonight on the Manhattan side of the Tram in anticipation of bringing OMNY to Roosevelt Island. While RIOC and the MTA continue to negotiate the terms of an agreement, this work is a good sign that both parties are continuing to act in good faith in finalizing this project.

Thank you for your continued patience, we will be providing more updates on this exciting initiative soon!

-Team RIOC

But hold on. 

With major Roosevelt Island F Train service disruptions scheduled to begin August 28, is it still of benefit for Roosevelt Island residents to have OMNY installed at the Roosevelt Island Tram at this time?

As previously reported some residents see a good reason in not having OMNY on the Tram yet:

Not having a OMNY scanner is actually the best thing it can happen to RI residents as it allows us to cut the long line of people looking to purchase tickets and go straight to the tram.

Today I asked RIOC President Shelton Haynes and Assistant Vice President of Communications Akeem Jamal:

Once the OMNY is installed at the Roosevelt Island Tram stations, will Metro Card holders be able skip the long lines as they do now?

With the upcoming disruption of regular Roosevelt Island F Train service starting August 28 and scheduled through the first quarter of 2024, being able to avoid the long line of tourists by using the Metro Card would be a great service to Roosevelt Island residents and workers.

Any comment from RIOC to the Roosevelt Island community on continued use of the Metro Card to skip the long lines at the Roosevelt Island Tram once OMNY is installed on the Tram?

Is it worth having OMNY at the Roosevelt Island Tram if residents are not able to skip long Tram lines with the Metro Card?

Will update if RIOC responds.

Thursday, April 13, 2023

UPDATE On Roosevelt Island Tram OMNY Payment System Installation - Mixed Signals From RIOC And The MTA About Installation Date, Could Be As Soon As June Or End Of The Year

As reported last February 8:

... Roosevelt Island has been waiting for the MTA OMNY payment system to be installed at the Roosevelt Island Tram stations as far back as 2020....

and the Bring OMNY to the Roosevelt Island Tram Online petition has 1404 signatures (1421 as of today).

During the April 3, 2023 Roosevelt Island Operating Corp (RIOC) Board of Directors meeting, RIOC President Shelton Haynes reported being told by the MTA that the OMNY payment system installation for the Roosevelt Island Tram has been delayed until the late 2nd quarter of this year.

This is actually good news if true because:

... During the February 6, 2023 NY State Senate Joint Public Hearing on the 2023-24 Executive Budget Proposal, Roosevelt Island's NY State Assembly Member Rebecca Seawright asked MTA Chair Janno Lieber:

The Roosevelt Island Tramway still continues to lack OMNY. Can you tell us why this has been delayed and when you expect it to be installed so that our Roosevelt Island residents and visitors can benefit from this service?

Mr Janno replied: 

The answer is it's projected to happen in the second half of this year... ... We didn't have software in some of the specialty locations like Roosevelt Island Tram, the Air Train in Jamaica Station and a few other places. The software has to catch up and we are working on it but that right now the projection it's going to be the second half of this year....

After the RIOC Board meeting, I asked a representative of Roosevelt Island's NY State Senator Liz Krueger's office:

Shelton said during his President’s report tonight that OMNY will be installed at the Tram Station by end of the 2nd quarter this year. 

At the end of the meeting I asked him if I heard him correctly and he confirmed that he said OMNY will be installed by end of 2nd quarter. I told him that my understanding was MTA says it will be installed by the end of the year. Shelton says he talks to the MTA almost weekly and he was told by end of 2nd quarter. 

Has your office heard anything new about timing of OMNY installation for the tram.

After speaking with the MTA, Ms Kreuger's representative replied:

We are HAPPY  to confirm the date has been moved up from the end of the year!

On April 10, I asked the MTA to confirm OMNY installation on the Roosevelt Island Tram by August June 2023, the end of the 2nd quarter and received a mixed signal that did not confirm the earlier date. 

According to the MTA spokesperson:

In October, the MTA Capital Program Committee updated the OMNY forecast for substantial completion to Q2 2025. The MTA is currently engaged with the vendor in a scheduling re-baselining process on the OMNY project.

The MTA is building out OMNY functionality for New York City Transit first, before addressing other agencies, including AirTrain and the Roosevelt Island Tram; we plan on integrating the Roosevelt Island tram with OMNY before the end of 2023.

OMNY continues to grow as New Yorkers tap and enter the transit system in record numbers – with 2 million taps in one day recorded this month. Commuter railroad customers already have the benefit of mobile ticketing and contactless payment through the extraordinarily popular TrainTime App, which has seen 1.5 million users purchase over 24 million tickets since its launch in August and has a 4.9 star rating on the App Store.

  The NY Post reported:

One resident says there is a silver lining in not having OMNY on the Tram yet:

Not having a OMNY scanner is actually the best thing it can happen to RI residents as it allows us to cut the long line of people looking to purchase tickets and go straight to the tram.

Here's a bit of Roosevelt Island OMNY history. Former RIOC Chief Financial Officer spoke to Manhattan Community Board 8 in September 2021 about efforts to get the OMNY system installed at the Roosevelt Island Tram  

 

and during a June 8, 2022 RIOC audit committee meeting (at 7 minute mark), CFO O'Reilly reported that RIOC receives only $2.00 of the $2.75 Roosevelt Island Tram fare.

Wednesday, February 8, 2023

When Will The MTA's OMNY Payment System Be Installed At The Roosevelt Island Tram Stations? MTA Chair Janno Lieber Tells Assembly Member Rebecca Seawright Software Problems Delay RI OMNY Installation To Second Half Of 2023

In July of 2022 I reported on a "Bring OMNY To The Roosevelt Island Tram" online petition which garnered 1404 signatures

and:

... Last March, NYC Council Member Julie Menin told me that the MTA and Roosevelt Island Operating Corp (RIOC) assured her that the OMNY payment system will be installed on the Roosevelt Island Tram within this year....

But that was not to be.

Roosevelt Island residents were told during the December 22, 2022 Roosevelt Island Operating Corp (RIOC) Board Of Directors Meeting by RIOC General Counsel Gretchen Robinson that the OMNY payment system installation on the Tram would be delayed until, hopefully, the 2nd quarter of 2023.

  

This week we learned that the Roosevelt Island Tram OMNY installation will be delayed past the 2nd quarter of 2023.

During the February 6, 2023 NY State Senate Joint Public Hearing on the 2023-24 Executive Budget Proposal, Roosevelt Island's NY State Assembly Member Rebecca Seawright asked MTA Chair Janno Lieber:

The Roosevelt Island Tramway still continues to lack OMNY. Can you tell us why this has been delayed and when you expect it to be installed so that our Roosevelt Island residents and visitors can benefit from this service?

Mr Janno replied: 

The answer is it's projected to happen in the second half of this year... ... We didn't have software in some of the specialty locations like Roosevelt Island Tram, the Air Train in Jamaica Station and a few other places. The software has to catch up and we are working on it but that right now the projection it's going to be the scond half of this year....

Yesterday, I asked Ms Seawright:

Thank you for asking the MTA Chair Janno Lieber about when the OMNY payment system will be installed on the Roosevelt Island Tram and why it has been delayed.

Mr Lieber said OMNY is projected to be installed on the Tram in the second half of the year which is another in a long line of delays. He blamed software and vendor delays as the reason for OMNY not being installed on the Tram.

He did not say anything about issues agreeing to a new revenue sharing arrangement with RIOC which RIOC has previously said was an obstacle with the MTA to install OMNY on the Tram. Mr Janno said he "would be happy to get in a specific dialogue with you".

Can you ask him if there are any issues other than software and vendor problems to installing OMNY on the Tram and specifically including any issue agreeing to a revenue sharing arrangement with RIOC for payment by riders using OMNY on the Tram as well as transfers from the Tram to the subway and bus.

Ms Seawright replied:

At yesterday’s legislative hearing in Albany, I asked MTA Chair Janno Lieber about the effort to enable OMNY card holders to use their cards to transfer onto or off the Roosevelt Island Tram — because the long delay in implementing this capability is simply unacceptable. We need better answers from the agency officials responsible. I’ll be following up to press for solutions that get us past inter-agency squabbling and instead address the needs of Roosevelt Island residents and New York City riders.

Roosevelt Island has been waiting for the MTA OMNY payment system to be installed at the Roosevelt Island Tram stations as far back as 2020. 

Former RIOC Chief Financial Officer spoke to Manhattan Community Board 8 in September 2021 about efforts to get the OMNY system installed at the Roosevelt Island Tram

 

and during a June 8, 2022 RIOC audit committee meeting (at 7 minute mark), CFO O'Reilly reported that RIOC receives only $2.00 of the $2.75 Roosevelt Island Tram fare.

On February 18, 2022, a MTA spokesperson responded to my inquiry saying:

The Roosevelt Island Tramway is an essential part of the city’s transit network and it has been the MTA’s plan to have OMNY available to everyone including riders of the tramway by integrating the contactless payment system to help New Yorkers and visitors travel to and from Roosevelt Island. The MTA is thrilled that our transit partners at the Roosevelt Island Operating Corp (RIOC) want to join the OMNY team and we are working with them to offer OMNY to those who use the Tramway.

In November 2022 a MTA spokesperson added:

The Roosevelt Island tram will be integrated with OMNY sometime in 2023. The MTA is building out OMNY functionality for New York City Transit first, before addressing other agencies, however we look forward to welcoming tram riders to OMNY next year.

Over the last several years, the Roosevelt Island Twitterverse comments on the lack of OMNY at the Tram.

UPDATE 2/9 -  On February 7, I followed up on a November 28, 2022 email inquiry to RIOC President Shelton Haynes and Communications Assistant Vice President Akeem Jamal about the status of OMNY installation on the Roosevelt Island Tram. I asked:
I am following up on email below regarding installation of MTA OMNY system on the Roosevelt Island Tram.

When do you anticipate the OMNY system to be installed on the Roosevelt Island Tram?

What is the reason for the long delay?

Former RIOC CFO John O'Reilly has reported that a reason for the delay installing OMNY on the Roosevelt Island Tram is because RIOC and the MTA have not reached an agreement on a revenue sharing arrangement for payment by riders using the Tram and switching from the Tram to the subway or bus.

Is that true?

Does RIOC have any comment to the Roosevelt Island community on installing OMNY at the Roosevelt Island Tram?
There has been no response from RIOC about the status of OMNY installation on the Tram, continuing the practice of Mr Haynes and Mr Jamal in refusing to answer questions by local press in order for RIOC to:
... Control the narrative...
as told to me by Mr Jamal in a brief conversation several months ago.

Wednesday, July 27, 2022

It's Toddler Storytime Today At The NY Public Library Roosevelt Island Branch With NYC Council Member Julie Menin, Also Ms Menin Urges RIOC And MTA To Install Long Delayed OMNY System For Roosevelt Island Tram And NYC Council Redistricting May Move Us To A Queens District

NYC Council Member Julie Menin visited the NY Public Library Roosevelt Island Branch this morning. Ms Menin read at the Toddler Storytime, gave out books to the children and took a tour of the Library and its new outdoor plaza with Branch Librarian Carlos Chavez.

Also, Ms Menin shares a July 22 letter she wrote to MTA Chair Janno Lieber and Roosevelt Island Operating Corp (RIOC) President Shelton Haynes regarding the Roosevelt Island July 16-17 Transportation mess. According to Ms Menin's letter:

I write to you both regarding the difficult travel conditions that residents and visitors of Roosevelt Island faced this past weekend. Over the days of July 16 and 17, constituents reached out to our office complaining about two hour wait times at the tram station. The issues with transportation to the island stemmed from a lack of coordination between RIOC and the MTA. The MTA altered the standard routing of the F train for the weekend while RIOC is in the midst of performing tram work. Altering the subway schedule combined with limited tram service led to exceptionally long wait times due to the lack of other viable options to commute onto and off the island....

Ms Menin urged the MTA and RIOC to swiftly install the long delayed OMNY payment system for the Roosevelt Island Tram.

Under a preliminary plan for NYC Council redistricting, Roosevelt Island will be moved from Ms Menin's NYC Council District 5 to Queens NYC Council District 26 currently represented by Julie Won.

Were Council Members Menin and Won discussing the redistricting plan at lunch today? Stay tuned for more on efforts to keep Roosevelt Island in Manhattan NYC Council District 5.

Saturday, July 2, 2022

Sign Petition To Bring The MTA OMNY Payment System To The Roosevelt Island Tram - Residents Ask MTA And RIOC What Is The Very Long Delay Getting OMNY Payment System On Roosevelt Island Tram?

Roosevelt Island resident Paul Krikler started a petition to bring the MTA OMNY payment system to the Roosevelt Island Tram.

You can sign the petition here.

Last March, NYC Council Member Julie Menin told me that the MTA and Roosevelt Island Operating Corp (RIOC) assured her that the OMNY payment system will be installed on the Roosevelt Island Tram within this year.

During a June 8 RIOC Board of Directors Audit Committee meeting, RIOC Chief Financial Officer John O'Reilly said that discussions with the MTA about the OMNY payment system integration with the Roosevelt Island Tram are scheduled to begin in the July or August time frame (video here at the 7 minute mark.) 

You can sign the petition here.

Tuesday, February 15, 2022

When Will OMNY Fare Collection System Be Installed On Roosevelt Island Tram Asks Assembly Member Rebecca Seawright To MTA Chair Janno Lieber At Transportation Budget Hearing Today - What About Seniors And Disabled People OMNY Reduced Fare Discounts Seawright Asks Too?

An update.

As reported February 10:

... Roosevelt Island NYC Council Member Julie Menin, Assembly Member Rebecca Seawright and State Senator Jose Serrano issued this press release demanding OMNY installation on the Roosevelt Island Tram. According to the February 10, 2022 press release:

Council Member Julie Menin Demands OMNY Installation on Roosevelt Island. Tram Commuters can not access OMNY free transfers or utilize fare-capping pilot program. RIOC Missing Out on Critical Funds By Not Using OMNY 

The Offices of New York City Council Member Julie Menin, New York State Senator Jose M. Serrano and New York State Assemblymember Rebecca Seawright have requested the Roosevelt Island Operating Corporation (RIOC) advance the timeline for the installation of the One Metro New York (OMNY) system on the Roosevelt Island Tram. The letter sent by the Office of Council Member Julie Menin addresses RIOC President and CEO Shelton J. Haynes as the Roosevelt Island Tram remains the last MetroCard only station within the MTA system...

Today, Assembly Member Seawright asked MTA Chair Janno Lieber about installing the OMNY fare collection system on the Roosevelt Island Tram and reduced fares for seniors and disabled people using the OMNY system. 


According to Mr. Lieber:

On the issue of the Tram, which I rode for many years, I know it's an important feature of the Roosevelt Island community. The Roosevelt Island Operating Corp operates it, not the MTA. 

We will make sure there is a plan to get it OMNY equipped. I don't know why it hasn't been yet but it is not part of the system. That may be part of the explanation but it's a fair point and we will make sure it gets done....

Mr Lieber added that OMNY reduced fare discounts for seniors and disabled people will be coming in the next 3-6 months.

More info on Roosevelt Island Tram OMNY service at this prior post.

UPDATE 2/17 - Below is letter sent today by RIOC President Shelton Haynes in reply to the Menin/Seawright/Serrano OMNY letter.

Thursday, February 10, 2022

NYC Council Member Julie Menin Demands OMNY Fare Collection System Installation For Roosevelt Island Tram - It's Up To RIOC Says MTA, RIOC Says Roosevelt Island OMNY Installation At The Whim Of MTA, Can Mayor Eric Adams Solve This?

When will the Roosevelt Island Tram Stations 

be included in the MTA's One Metro New York (OMNY) 

system is a question often asked by Roosevelt Island residents.

The MTA's OMNY future does not appear to be coming to Roosevelt Island anytime soon.

Responding to the Roosevelt Island Twitterverse last month, the MTA reported it is up to the Roosevelt Island Operating Corp (RIOC): 

... to add OMNY to their fare collection systems.

But, during a September 21, 2021 Community Board 8 Roosevelt Island Committee meeting, RIOC CFO John O'Reilly said:

... Roosevelt Island and the Tram was set in a priority listing, not with our input but basically unilaterally by the MTA, that they were going to do the Long Island Railroad first and PATH next and then we were going to be third on the list after they got Staten Island, Manhattan, the Bronx, Queens and Brooklyn done.

We were scheduled to have negotiations and discussions with them in the spring of this year to negotiate the new contract. We were given the vendor's name who was supplying the equipment and we made contact with them. The last I heard from them was February 2020 right before the pandemic hit...

... We were scheduled to have everything done by the late fall, early winter of this year or early winter of next year so we will be in position to be in play by January 1st 2023 when that was their deadline to have everything in place. 

I don't know if they've extended that deadline or not...

... We're basically at the whim of the MTA on this one. We did everything we could to try to get them to move us up on the priority list and renegotiate the contract and do everything we can but the pandemic hit and then everything kind of fell off ....

Today, Roosevelt Island NYC Council Member Julie Menin, Assembly Member Rebecca Seawright and State Senator Jose Serrano issued this press release demanding OMNY installation on the Roosevelt Island Tram. According to the February 10, 2022 press release:

Council Member Julie Menin Demands OMNY Installation on Roosevelt Island. Tram Commuters can not access OMNY free transfers or utilize fare-capping pilot program. RIOC Missing Out on Critical Funds By Not Using OMNY 

The Offices of New York City Council Member Julie Menin, New York State Senator Jose M. Serrano and New York State Assemblymember Rebecca Seawright have requested the Roosevelt Island Operating Corporation (RIOC) advance the timeline for the installation of the One Metro New York (OMNY) system on the Roosevelt Island Tram. The letter sent by the Office of Council Member Julie Menin addresses RIOC President and CEO Shelton J. Haynes as the Roosevelt Island Tram remains the last MetroCard only station within the MTA system.

RIOC is a New York State run public-benefit corporation that maintains and develops Roosevelt Island, operates a Public Safety Department, and also provides services such as the Roosevelt Island Tramway that enhances the residential island community. It is one of the few forms of mass transit in New York City not run by the Metropolitan Transportation Authority, but uses that system's MetroCard. 

With an annual ridership of over two million people and daily use in the thousands, the Tram currently is one of the most reliable services for traveling into Midtown Manhattan and a way to avoid crowded subways cars on the F train that travels to Manhattan and Queens. Those who forget or are not in possession of a Metrocard, cannot use their smart technology such as smartphones and watches, which could also have their payment readily available. If passengers used OMNY earlier on their trip, a free transfer is not available and passengers cannot take advantage of the weekly fare cap. Starting at the end of the month, New York City transit riders who utilize OMNY will pay no more than $33 per week for unlimited rides on the MTA’s local buses and subways.

In addition to not having OMNY integrated with the tram, RIOC is also currently missing out on collecting full revenues from Metrocard rides due to an outdated agreement with the MTA that did not account for fare hikes, as RIOC only receives $2.00 for a Metrocard swipe. Adopting OMNY technology provides an opportunity to collect full fares and create a fairer agreement. 

“Roosevelt Island residents shouldn’t have to be inconvenienced by a fixable transportation issue. The Tram is vital to our residents, and making it affordable and modernizing the technology will be a benefit for tram riders and RIOC alike as they’ll finally get the funds they deserve,” said Council Member Julie Menin.

"New Yorkers across the city currently have the option of paying their fare by tapping their contactless smartphones, cards, and other devices using OMNY, and Roosevelt Island Tram riders should be no exception. With the substantial growth of the island in the last few years, ease of access to transportation options has become more important than ever, and I look forward to seeing RIOC advance their timeline for modernizing the current payment system,” said State Senator José M. Serrano. 

"The clock is ticking. The MTA is moving forward with its plan to fully implement OMNY. The Roosevelt Island Operating Corporation is late to the game. RIOC must come forward with a timetable to deploy the OMNY system while also ensuring that Tram riders continue to benefit from seamless payment and transfers," said Assembly Member Rebecca Seawright. 

“Very few Roosevelt Islanders remember when Matt Katz spent years advocating for our Tram to accept Metro Cards (it didn’t just happen). For a ridiculously long time we had to use outdated tokens that were no longer used anywhere else at the time. I remember listening to my neighbors, particularly those with families who were financially burdened by the extra expense…here we go again. Why can’t RIOC be proactive and reactive in support of our financially burdened neighbors and prioritize this change making it happen NOW and truly support the people who need it the most,” said Lynne Strong-Shinozaki, resident of Roosevelt Island and Chair of the Community Board 8 Roosevelt Island Committee.

Below is February 10 letter sent by the Roosevelt Island elected officials asking RIOC President Shelton Haynes to implement the OMNY system on Roosevelt Island Tram by the end of this year.



 and the full CB 8 Roosevelt Island Committee (chaired by Ms Shinozaki) OMNY discussion with RIOC CFO John O'Reilly.

During yesterday's NY State Assembly Budget Hearings, NYC Mayor Eric Adams told Ms. Seawright that he is:

... is looking forward to that Tram Ride. It is one of the greatest attractions in the City...
 

Perhaps Mayor Adams can help facilitate the future of OMNY installation coming to the Roosevelt Island Tram sooner rather than later.

I asked RIOC for any comment on the matter earlier today. No response yet.

UPDATE 2/11 - According to RIOC President Shelton Haynes: 

Simply, we agree with many points our new city councilmember and elected officials have made. RIOC is equally disappointed with the lag in integrating OMNY at the Roosevelt Island Tram stations. We welcome and support the advocacy, although somewhat misplaced, as we have implored the MTA and their integration partners to ensure Tram riders have access to the same benefits enjoyed on other forms of New York City public transportation. Further, and for some time now, we have been aware of the fare disparity and our CFO has been actively working to engage the MTA on renegotiating the fees in an effort to close this gap.
I replied: 

What is the obstacle in getting OMNY for the Roosevelt Island Tram? When was the last time Rioc and the MTA discussed the matter?
UPDATE 2/15: UPDATE 2/17: Below is letter sent today by RIOC President Shelton Haynes in reply to the Menin/Seawright/Serrano OMNY letter.